CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="120"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "publications.waset.org",cType: 'non-interactive',cRay: '9134b51b084afda0',cH: 'Rrn92ZEKAuxNzDCBUD0_zARQOHYPJWOQszs7dt11xxk-1739784088-1.2.1.1-Xm6Xf7h3xR880yNbfiNN6Pgp91yiwdHPw2sBHCsb86ZjoU.gW.1_sAOaS9Z5fieP',cUPMDTk: "\/abstracts\/search?q=civilisation&__cf_chl_tk=4g1bgkjVcUHJXgIawNjkPvhtXbDcrwTg8x9OohdOWw8-1739784088-1.0.1.1-Bq7RpQRqKKBPK_RivDmWBxUhZjt6MPT.274c7xKR_PQ",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1739784088',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '120000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/abstracts\/search?q=civilisation&__cf_chl_f_tk=4g1bgkjVcUHJXgIawNjkPvhtXbDcrwTg8x9OohdOWw8-1739784088-1.0.1.1-Bq7RpQRqKKBPK_RivDmWBxUhZjt6MPT.274c7xKR_PQ",md: "ktiZZvNXaLANeAbRsomnC7n_ez3oPLMIIw2c6RSVDtI-1739784088-1.2.1.1-TbfZ7asrAa3aQCWGfCqcEEZipQQ7oPulCmrvcIMlrGQW6svoFjWHFgK1nupMvZK31uK0lC_aDM.bEuFaf4_j1Xndz9P1mjBRjHRQBuOmhRPMVxy.pzX9ZWg1LZYxq4sJhy7cIROzshzADSHmykE32hpnh7wXwzQnRzBcxEwHn..CkrEogZ5fgNiF3vw8r34dB_wi3mM5nwKNMURld3UrE.sfPT1M9TekMmfr_eDJ7ECi2DxtofqRFNn65IXHZAKA9Mn1E3AOfcuErMx8ODSUny8NsZCJoZzV8aCBimNZ8wRnRAPFuaFb5BN7Qp_uvE1BYwt_Tr8nkxj97WegL5Wm_B3NT8u852SRBoKu7FQqxErmRLSMUfouYug4rIf0Sb03BSfTY2zr3B51Vi1o28ZrEA80kiWHYnk_XmJynkrAjXjXq4fLzBDf2XmJABdOMTSF8hf.9jJGhwfCRbatzuHQsSFVATrup1Y2d7WoJkseklJ.wzHXchlPVYXxdabLfRNQLXidpUn4kN3JA8PyUQ0PzZTvbcBL_034bpcaud6Xh2.tRq7vAOTw7g_F_WxQ_SgjM2fY5XQFC64IwrL9Z49cBAb5LL3ZGexG4.2DXrFb9ubm0VBL5FjiCYvPlJAFEjY7MHWwOFK2N8XzdLZWFPm6sJJxXIc0P9OnSubTiPO1RSbhYQptsX5HZaXd5uGG3jRr5ANXVEmCRxCh0yj4R3i3UPSa_AES3D.KJ21Z11N5aR7AHlJD3VNZU1tsaruPCOZ.DZuGvdrKXBK3CY_rXVlBkbdB07QsoUCqy3UYZJJqF_nQPFnr01v1A87nVTStfm1gpigl9tqPvo.fLsH7OuEcF5PpYpJ1chwIdbsj3xUQOTHrC43XSQFLP_iXr7aXbJN3TO_VL7C38EqahXDRdJ2ebM2GftVcHR196H0yg_ZGB_JRFDMlDdmwjVr76XRcE4eOrIAHvKlOLtC.hRyY4Cyu.dY9yspch9e9obKvx4AyDKX58iQ3Mhr8fmq4FKRlgx6I2GrEaKgyfZA9jheObgggq7pRbxxUf.Y15h4DXPZjRbS0fqaGThqXzZwJDNZRq9FOF.XVCrzzFdSXe35uX5hYFPZgIvu8t1zah9eael7dohonJBwSg9x3WCQ922Z5gwJRgl4uek4Q5CuvfnHwqzbJzj4i_r2SleeHT64ZFfpyV0Llpp5Leaohh7pKDUE7EVl2cOia8cn9rPIACfNMmgOygZVjkJuCBchf0bj4B4e6exjqkIu36qKabeXSjQpeNgmNyWb5fBJ8p7EALWW94SaRdt_t8uuDU2uTIl5myfptC.7fVuUAyvzxALvBtvFkiF5mwqjJsJjBdsjmFv_1wBOIxE033aJCIz55n6CBwC.SoHJUd1O.Pix3UZI39IVWTzxTb8AVQM0uOKLJ1H65yv7v5P_wGOfbiPp3kbqh0peMqotQ4NXfMoToajBqAeBjih_NxhzDDubTeB6gfI7cTga.BbwXT8fpd4pb.atElcFFceu9cfkc7SnhCy2ycXCAhNxqztPuKqB_xZjPzK.isZh1eibTOPzjlMhBPFCiP7l1NjnoyQlr9iHyfaFX_sYcKIHqyTJ6Kt6kvZBY6odFsicX8u4lwgWPDUYTR8SdnXPwLmUTfpMh.N8Yt1dH1CVHEj0y5mo_Jtv2pHUG_lGPTX3mMgCwHA19jsKIi.QEjTFrX.rk0HbqlK3JmUX2R2H09AdiiMVUVUG0lfeInJNRMmH1HBMNNkSni2Dn.ZCMgTziXLcafvvPB6DYlcGy_PmGhFQM35b4i2SB_TbJ_h0fGwaK4kVOAcj92O9nNNdt0VqohCrVu1cMX.mHMaTU3cLShozKgeg5ylfcB1WdZetfePr7znze73PDNMbJbBy0YT4DNPm45XcqE01tEAE2LxIJMu2UUISLbqb.dRsdMeUU4nu.FQ",mdrd: "lJcneF_Mldj9dSxvF7pnEoSjJIn3Sro3dyWg9V2wAxs-1739784088-1.2.1.1-CNXc8ddANypPLEzJV3Ob6_0AG0ALdNkKUzeueiNXvuPYKe4xEad_lS4hteJNF7QffB1ZssDOxA3e1rkIbXhuOVj1YIe2fVRf_FfZCuZQNe9baRg9GfJYreJN9r38C_DcbY30jhkAzLmKijxw4kc.u.PCd9IXhhLzq3c3hDN9oFEloZP4t1FhnNGB3jGSnPjyMt7Fa20FsZsoXsaJDe1vbp6nJcwNowBeFi_ySny3HbsWLA.F.1rMQ_VokReluQgq6ahgykaONt2.Tz_iJSoC7.kIk9GvKuROJ9qertuLzh._P044TwIPD1hFCg9OYdwZR_Rupjmz58HPoi77q47S5oLuM2gFiiCRBQJBIu3bHgcwD0x9I7gSkn3PVRJSW7hS86AMsKw2DBfGIELakTJI8lsZWoOl4QUuF0UlSEI9YQVrgUFoNrA8gteANaP9IgtN1HddVBvOdl3W2hp4d_y_vqPol693Pc5Le2.W8Ik6La9kWuh6ewN5yUywvu9E92bls4lqAdXI974tp60imo5zJM37_lXa9DdpChti7qZgOpjTnqXy2Ys_EDs.8rwFLEFMxvLVihrKTZGUlWHMhuPMFBUU6S2lIJtMk5cgBpJ.O1WBfd5vAkvfnoxej95H_6eu7D9xfsnQDIiEKTbeQvoBHatY7kgzzENxWtqEyfXQbaK.DAM4XgiFBEuT8ajtuOhutYowGMinUPF3sar6sg2wMzrzdLX0ivbnpViJPRAIzwGVXw7Za3LbiLsd6SpO5UmkZ5L7WrvPQFMubyCxAdgzxJw5.ebrjIYIb8WHhOnhoMkzyiBndO2L_aW2teCFZ26M7xxY66NzL7Cykn33sn.PzOhC8sQJLhYXr44IGf1HbzIKExvKfz1uXea39.X7MXdOL212IE09LZljDigeapfQ2pw7l1XQnjxmmJFKE7UU_Y2vEx1pSshcWQQsE532yyWokEeAbMmSz8DKk5HfC1.ZsZOi9fkgERR6nDgxZO7_CN9Lox11auqzGY4GiNelYn.39cY3VmON8Ml1r6vZ_0dxU9kiGvET62Cc_6eIwiPD9JXhef0WY6bDuDpT6YBZtrHaf.kgINNBiAgzv7YtGWD8adPvUugY2pEYXbKUybnL29D8HKG1qg2__G2gMPNNkNgOkD9AMtdOdMconxiHF7JLlSzbF4ph.Df52PlLH0h72oY2Tp4bK0.c5pHuwTGulZ64kYBdPybbkg0MmPzQjNVjKmLioHX7It21ilmrF2EPUeqxg2vz_N0c6YDg_.mPGrYTRkeFK1HJXRywGkq31eMR5.zciKHNrgzO6.DpztrdUigrO.stmwhFQ60m3q6NKyyMfvdkoIrTlEe792q2d6LaN0jXzzIzYzAnpHlu.JE3PYX8L_ugV2ov5w3uv4TRBZKGNCC3cyjtwsUajP.rSi7glFuSxpBP3mQTSTAtIPitXV2LKwvzNkG6T8b5Bmp3hECm2vrdvDsISdXNBA8wdi3kLizFU7KN9Lqua3RONWwlTt5E6SMmfG60_wvjpOz82Nf3rJC.POzkOGgNxbt3rp9JyK8Gdaj9l_DA8iL9IHG2_QkWXI6S_zSlS5ftw969EAsZqlO1yvP_Em5_KPwoi1MWRmXhwcvQCyRaA.zR_QSvvJHT45H4jmG1UfFfipduedHbKL4tBwIwS.vTypGsCCDHcVkPkqBCfHQJQGlZCK59MELOm13vU6TIk8Ace9.ehbQjJB0pKs0nPFHnNQR4sS0l76b0N7Q7XrtMTfVHsKOTSAEkDjdqPcyVnYwl15bg4IDA_EDYCqiYH3xLnKr12ANTJxyEFAPIoLy6fanXhbcUWyDjm4eo0V5OAKaIOAQFrs9HqJYTheviWL_yJFIKN3jLY02jKiB.9WaEdzaAU9S2vdkWalMT4fO3NTOCUc6YvRTzoja1PvVg2ny5saezvAFdOLCiWyUfLH6jjnAdSq01DZ6Fol0G2gfnXONlbMt_DZfgXf3bl90aRa62ICwd08YoUA"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=9134b51b084afda0';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/abstracts\/search?q=civilisation&__cf_chl_rt_tk=4g1bgkjVcUHJXgIawNjkPvhtXbDcrwTg8x9OohdOWw8-1739784088-1.0.1.1-Bq7RpQRqKKBPK_RivDmWBxUhZjt6MPT.274c7xKR_PQ" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>