CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="120"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "publications.waset.org",cType: 'non-interactive',cRay: '9135916328163f4b',cH: 'Sm1ZqzFLTYJRMTdbf0FSXfxUgv7Gz6Ke4CDVaAGKyvo-1739793111-1.2.1.1-9CDulZQcltzWmzkX8SPwv3nIsJ43leIyDB_X7QshN5iThe0kax7ZOH1ZnA2ZsbBh',cUPMDTk: "\/abstracts\/search?q=critical%20Realism&__cf_chl_tk=QUEwWby66f1SO8GQnOe1LIrVE3RGMXBQugInfcRBnzg-1739793111-1.0.1.1-aOGxbWW9No0vaE7bhgQBtf_xEdXNtWKmlAu_SUVKRfY",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1739793111',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '120000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/abstracts\/search?q=critical%20Realism&__cf_chl_f_tk=QUEwWby66f1SO8GQnOe1LIrVE3RGMXBQugInfcRBnzg-1739793111-1.0.1.1-aOGxbWW9No0vaE7bhgQBtf_xEdXNtWKmlAu_SUVKRfY",md: "oSiej4SeSVL3qyjickgEowsDkDTyaZ4WFj2iTU..GLo-1739793111-1.2.1.1-zj_n7maMu1xTV3Sgl.aq6GmvaRxtdVRXqdXZYleAUScdElS5so.WSfrPXzHK3tx.xSwxzzOBoTltWY_JVuyzgF.GZAwJc7z4yPHPVPJ3GNloPsNUxkKBhLFbDNxlL9635g7iE5QHrRKILUsjPkJHVU7hBlC9JkuY1x8sdVx.yMo.KsUWqqT6OurCvhoZdbEMEr6EeKzCzxPDHdksh46.gq6mYWXV4TxSjckx0ik3abC57j5.qy9Ptz3uod7eyS47zv8E8dtnaxGtlNMukGreCGsmFciTSQaWV_Wskdw90f7fjQgRtcpAzr9QE9OWowUhuydf4idBW1GgZTgrFbKCSSQ2UgCeQU2kFmnD0yzHle0CQ8WsgpjrbkW7jX7Vx3uGY0A.YxK2pEjO_9ZGDlhpBMheUei6DW1RlvJRHCmaXo9l0_XJlsneuWK4NngVuIcoelxEdvavhn20Ts0EPMgXpGOSbPaJS4oXtrGaJ_t5rBsrcVpPnXMSTMJHqhLG63FH1fcxUdl62Lrq5ZSMst67G2UFuyJd8JWco1quwsbYzsZQdCQ5lYJ_lw5TqaEqhgkXxkk_.tl6JlI5tGJWDNlb.YLvGs0Z2Mz1e3kRkH6s65VwZ4sXGdsK2qt3.hf5w9WXItIoLpfGY6xN5Et.qn5DPzZfZXt6S6TWKo5566jddozCEdXoJ4n1YQi1eGs2m5rbhh6Ieq.5oVnptt.Pnb8KWiSWguVo5eOXr_28pIR7Gn5tBhg8hGJtnbb46FpQo4KVhhqMANH31KV2jOIsNdWc_M5Atvb7bZNvT1XCkDrDdO4nGv7E5NPWu_pqhANrVR7FC0_NGEYMQIggVXK21AgZkvGBs7GMoLODVBhZjCWVWaN1YKFpDn1sK_lLiJW3dlNUBST.MGJrgFGaoGq8GgZe4frhvkOJbdstJ5JWj2M_1j12TMqwA8wDA.EsoI9x5qkgFISIRBWgvK3PH1jbuyLPiFnD8tJRLy2i_ALbv6gNSKO2KetRwSa6Z3Db1mqFmp4C9wxyz_1QSIpcmUBj7OYaflZJqMCaQM2itOc5GyxRD6Q4OzfLUEhWhZg_4pzDjoZfTetI3uW1wmtZ_12OlcQKm67jud9MV3Fg64fcZLC0Y5gfh6XPAmJoGa.X9MNfmhL8yIZ4gW51rypzhMRxpfPWE4Zh9TzAhC6VtD7VlgpQXD6LzWfgB2vWxDOvxh4ilmsBMCOiwTpkaTzonuSYTKHA9.BpjDOaaeT3gRE.T1wdCYBcXsRhsZCiG_cNkrW_Wkr2u4Ym1Vuc8UU.93LlMVN4ZIQNAm.rNxmdfMLo938IKlmj6.FKmfbU8oH9A9tP6Dg4.Rxq9Ip.9HSnDdClP3GN7coOE6Jn2PPBcYGXkqlwG5brbYKQMbWf7qcL5Z5ahELGZUyZVyNnT0IvKeD37gjgZjci14tti_eGGcHbl44lhN00bTnf9ecb07Pai2Vq0P7zSwm174rzl450ZxhRRLEsbW_PWZLwEytwgV_3lTV9I.2QKjP8IZE_CtBVJT56h2wTXcdD8P9yghQvxoXf2hkLgM8AmJe199NpvJ2ZQy5BpnieL3qnYM0.iudgymdETi0p.JP0AZcGJko6Gy2_19EEmlwbcngJPogQoUX.LGHr3NQaaZevzAd47rytKtmOr5sGM.sTsMkFRI7BcdZhSq.SbrYYGcd1ZgqctKZPboOcQXlqL6G0XR7C.dhKElcmiokWv7.XDKvsHg916HyzjNMRrLZLlpajFklC2rouWGsU_GuMeJBnSGCbvOSq96q_NYKSFaz5Ux8ctRWIl45W288uNqLCZgAnFYlNM3yzDgdhdUo288gasysY79RtJKYydG.HNivNCOfqzpyzu0Q6hXS32q2Kc17ydVh7HYIfkINzmbzcL81qDbcHg9OHphYmQRsOTFyD1.igzRpBrKX16ERt5UQZHc2Ek2nMmV1owmkEBEM",mdrd: "PJKb.NAVVxCad8tyGB5a9ER23kyKuEeN0tuNrBzVFlQ-1739793111-1.2.1.1-ZKMmQqFoJsUcqYb5PNrMCktQoLPWkIVVPRBkqrH25iMv6phP2hmB_KMfNcN.FfMQMou0XsWOQmO9mbsecgjpr6wMqQOicT6_qdKxUig5rZQ7u792heMvwvwvwhHLy_RhBgLMi89xzaZ9TVwaD8btWqd64NbXNwiwsf_b9fdOCOej_6lsNMqCFX3Oa5xTwOc_2ZzyJY2dwVRjnV8zEdNPDRcEpq5qZL_kt6DRPi6Ko9xlqsmrJLxfk3AcZjUg2VcYDKfCWr_v0Mg8X6eZFsDy9zH1DKK3d19JW9Bs9WtekIlsivFnc5M5GsRCpfcPuWEMq2i9uc1wNzZYMFzS6K8pIHmQIxln1AvQHvLnIXG2PQjFWrECWHvqDPJNJBlUa7jPa3xSYUcIYX17nMzyQYa.O8zEK2XFHxOqxEKbXspuo.G5h3WTqPyp_GJjmdC2NhkFeEpV_DROta9fT8SWPeIEZGZuF053SIZtpcZBvzqcTnRAWvyYoobNkTKKUIqAAdb1wSTGfQm0Xa74MR49m.7mv6hDi2n.OlEeM84zwrfidwKGZoIJ3dUcnEXpu4E0s.oec.jRw1btveQ_vnnqSGl3oILVbRn8DLtofFRUyJ.0NG1LFMsCXH3su7RJuMsaCLF_F16fCyW89bUO1jR6rQEK075zav2zyEgxfk2UWejRBWypCCJnrQ6SM_B4a4yG1tnuAXHEkfZA2o.hlwpCIgUA.UY2.5U59Yvx4vb85STQybmScs_ZeRiiOiqB5NDj6TGjHZQ98ZHUhRJGiKGU15zAxjXMoLcOvApIRa266Yll9WlCAJGjC4vmNA_iDBdUEseSflbwct8nA6fHK2a_soIoUrI67sh4W5ydoQFoC2O0Huwn1zI4CbUvHvADU1rJpXdcAGbvkGD1k5y05E45EFLwhgwknV9bVtVShFP_Yvcd99RV74kMCAW2eSvyNB_37vcTzqNSalII2N1eyzlqzq.3Ni1ew0sEEUCsqA5pnA_ZKuzJcrlwOv3AxI3jEwPFNFJCZftnzOsYirYe8hkhjAU5Wkpo5TCfKIABaKoMDFgCn1LQ0f0eiXprJgH8uMB3s6ea3la6hVxSGD.yArO6g9g._m_HZFp1CAmP_CRirRVId38d.fq5FjOwe6HqXv8OBpYGhjFdBPMbdDQQNkBoZrDMQomKY0GV_4Nw8VXmaSnot_l8suRlbVv0KoRjKRYSO96GmDVGuruDO4K1RzRnY9RiAvxbnkg7oceqtM8WEOFq_MkSlxrGcjplwNU5orvQ7hbVl3GeTOe12J4DV9Am5klJC4oC0TRiaaknx_gU0v0H0tPEnGizJyccwKKFH7rl2HTpoGuWgSgBBNxpAtkglVNDcvxqvsxuaX.4NU5q8mRrTdIhsRRLx.xxXVhvXYXHm9eIPbXJe5U3dKX_uN05wMkjibJlOxqbE0Z9PeU4gVil9JFC76tguLi9QSfD54p1ZaL0Lyste4TP7MhAd.7yjvzGJk91aKHcxhJR199fBQkyYJDSRlvh.TyD78hpoxgdBn5e2A.QyONW0Sfy5NxOz8EpPIer0Ss0FUritx0u1JRYZvHq98e3teYmWHOnpThyBVP1OAC6LxbqdA4Zw5e9EXSv6tffDvvHJpBmB6PHeDZ_c8p9FhntqbSAOJcWgizrPWqtf6QwEbf7lYRBiZQHHdoL56xRSN9IGb1SS0thfuyFORDuU.1_nINpC7jP8qeDwcqQ4T91hpPKlpwKjNvA_M8Ea3AauMJagTKAQ9OkIFsuRkqk7ATIGa1C9D.iLv01Pi8cZer20VU0gQxVCpz8aJdVDDMSsWJtO436pjstXMRHuq6CT47frDxuPOPwmAhBUPNKbf.xI4cuzJ99AtaOg62VhKB9rs9drINwjj6XT.TIMUDJiZChIsyNZiqm4E_BX3C7hVFapMjUUS7cRpfM1YK7K0jF_AkX8lXbApwxPFNVe7uEAkmBOfRvBCVMvIjpuLSw"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=9135916328163f4b';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/abstracts\/search?q=critical%20Realism&__cf_chl_rt_tk=QUEwWby66f1SO8GQnOe1LIrVE3RGMXBQugInfcRBnzg-1739793111-1.0.1.1-aOGxbWW9No0vaE7bhgQBtf_xEdXNtWKmlAu_SUVKRfY" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>