CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="120"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "www.annualreviews.org",cType: 'non-interactive',cRay: '8ec132fb781a40ba',cH: 'i.ag_O5QaapPKL2eGGqd6EZqMNZxDVL4skDFSoA0GrA-1733204187-1.2.1.1-UCH15P23te6gGzn.dN03uhiW9uPevUpcuaq4qWM0uzMleZFrWyqolu1qHMBSKgY.',cUPMDTk: "\/journal\/resource?__cf_chl_tk=EGnDjRTcri0xitpgzbMPGTJieKrBS9ySd0r_juW6et8-1733204187-1.0.1.1-ruyiduayEss_X2w97ZPI6Fkv6c0dUbDcw89yZE_.2Xw",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1733204187',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '120000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/journal\/resource?__cf_chl_f_tk=EGnDjRTcri0xitpgzbMPGTJieKrBS9ySd0r_juW6et8-1733204187-1.0.1.1-ruyiduayEss_X2w97ZPI6Fkv6c0dUbDcw89yZE_.2Xw",md: "thOi6KWzujBbeV5e1G2ZZTYYShLvHQrA2jQoNLyNth8-1733204187-1.2.1.1-qZNSDmQ3pY8XwOZ5grL3PImM13cVY91qZUkhwH0gU4GzHjaOsnUgSfuJiLEepVOasFehroMuqIkw0a_yRbB6MXAViS0lZXKMMW5a00Tas8xjaKXtJGjvJ6IKeLa0soPQCj14z1Epsddsf9oBjFBIUonIG2DLTgebNGWeAKie..vIXnKBzIfXkRPszrjyW0rNIDMrU2k4pM7VnlPmayWl1JpeW1uUyo9l5Fqlb_mZ6L6ZDLGXWdt6AhTr0rucD312eELCqbB1QcdQ0iqDNZLW5aFNR4ZEOttN.OwDy24QlCURUHvKP3iVZD.I3UVZe6wkmcdJgKckZIfs.iHWn8AVHM4zJENRrPjjWF5ds.bX0R7jtkvIfQ._sQnvfWGCYKZJNyoqdvYBA3GrQGqttQtCDX0p4vn15kCSS8WdbNyuFlu_dLyzDovxkp2G2KiEb0OTqn5NzyvdIetKd_O0ZZCLUJwCdUG5Z9mjzDoamGUpgsuUOg3cp5ZaytxbQ4Mb9Jwm1bD2exb7QRV4UkmNzH6gIojkyv5xV_xAZwzw39KFY4XdJ.UgTuwCfh3Qo1bx98qBucP39BIW6c1cxspF5TqDqOFQxcm2p.3mDpqiuoS7fmJKJMCjH2LUQ2Op8c56YHy1IgTJW0kpYAmfLRVkH_iRsoiOyyT.axZukKLaffWj.H0KGBJ0MtMdaHn9jbotdd6I2zQBwTLxl8KVy5N0ty9c9wZ03sAJKaFDBLMv8YpYBkbjLdZX7dJsv7BCYArdN9JWdxI3znBzb.6DC1sqKxKLvD3sycUSNcKMRwhNYCTsui.jpUIiKvUrl7RdUrjzkkHJUW8NsyTODSU4sFhF8MrXIENMEqSWMtQfiWuIHCnC5wh3bf6dAwh3thBLdR30xTKG9ZcfR8xqssIM89__XD2S5bsXKliU.X2FnXteA9WRdYEe2gr6XwFajey5v4KMA2Wup1Nxq13r31cSeIM864jEty6CZJ7jcovBn37u6UC6aj8NzBb53XRg8r7gZyn2EmBkW2JQMLLS4E1UZDKizblBiqeUSFzCrQrCl3q9_T2K0w4qdagXTFhvYON4cga4qWdUdQVh45ducNVMc0f77mgvqDzEeTqbsBUmAlTzlIxo467BYMyjuzNKdqqls4LI1HboVLJ5B7uwHFylzdU.iRaPaqrt6EOMLSFDSf.fkl_ytSgYYRbnLpicGVRFGg5FGKFjn8AYvPEH3Ay6qOsw9pPvNyPq24n06qiBIolSl867BPjHDowKUCw5VxEpePxNBvdCe0s94NX6YjE_fzA7Pnf21iB9884PVR.emtr3kwOxS_RB_287XMQa9r03lSxFzoGWRMsCw5hO7h2HDkMEZpM7rHFKZKvFY1Jk1xjYsEcoUaERj8bSq.wDP613Ii_W3j8ALv8mCRPs84xxpDVDdOSegckjI49u.YBgTPTJaBxhrhZiEcvlaFhRjK4tO8Z5a6YinKI6iwji0LZ.fLwuO__lyE.JE7KxtCSod9wjCtMM0Oo35rsMB4A6sOG2j5iJECMfVTPwZ9aH9k_YJwlIEp2AUHFYRG02iMtDvGmoJdr6Gz9k9NWJ6Zg6JqO_P2puJE.KaKaL25GbtK2z1Xq9_sW7nArEYB.5m_Iu7IVGRftC7LjInVjXo5NyiK9VUzOgige48eKYIyKcoKA7rJyjryq0EF3fFTY61u2d1m4xWPvnRZqX8aTBks2.SOfnva111gH17F9w.LRh0Igy6syBWjuw_pPZrpYGzDhE6ewACbb6Iw3HqG7Ra8Fmr.RHetsymYoqkwxi8eFb_WRS9YZ.3YfZmOS8TG7AejVBp0kPAy2PxRhaog1HNi3gicPkhSPAgLncyjG6n3KmVhvcfD8r0N.RC5HVXMUJW_bg15BaeQshNaIGadEFJZW0HG.LRDy5dMN8Nl.hW4cvk0XxZ1UeL.Dnf9_y7VXjiUAivc6oEvuv.745kAuE5c8zu8Um_cxRVzhv",mdrd: "T97VMvQXv7FLEsHIz6azx_2Y9KM3XcmLPGcFEMjVzZU-1733204187-1.2.1.1-Whsel03kGngcehgTIBUc4luLhKyZcE2HotNaTAP.PKGOYv46E27JyRNlley2Kq3Ub3U3aCJ8JqPSwbbQYmbTVydOg2twETEg1fTextH3HM5.rFEMrH0xlgmS2urQo48MRbwDpMwiqIuKlDUhLfwBJ8vItRdFRWlkUbT8W9PppOD4whSdlzISh8xwoCaVBs0m8Oi72B08eap0k9UblAnQVUevRMfuY4bQE3Vc.NR4IQxbDZ6pVIpmeLCCa7ZYcVTET2JSJndQHtYrZygTIVvs_jgf6EpQ5XVHTW2Fksu3oEo1JBzHDly1O6EOc2CjU9gTsxtDg_NCN8wCkiBI2xHNUvhVZo.JlexAzFOweLxmlqiBJ.tA4w6dOTe0GwtT0ZPN0O8u6rAXvtOoyh0HU1RjkjxkZrgr6_NKJvtkX4Gelbk4X3PPRN25GV7PCmLxZCdFSLKqoamp1z4.wskZSAVQvkldNZ83JhHQv0tEmiklKsbV89oOcxSasEMtht1up9av3sEnloZDXFLyGYZMRXlTBA.zvOJZ2GHc_TS9EHpu108HyZDrASUtCxGQ1ZKWzYS50Av8FnAiXRXn.rKbD6_gfdkDrUJQt9R71U15cBwIBiflBaWMEeOTJKvDhPZldvTR3Oa8lh7DoExjXXcXJ5sZsbNw7xMGVEUNS9HImnp_WlxA6meJncg2XUmqWdftI4EzA6ot6Nu.oPvUZM8hUYYa4swZtMLKkkY6N_LfoAKu7iRW0db2N2G0de7Aw9vXDrGDX7_3ay4P34TKlVbKIdHWoFy6vsop64ADIc_YUAAT60VRxBUTUMvs4mSrnQsRRYpcbSqiZhvFahvHpaXp_SAssa0hVWmVU88RsJAvvm_bKFzcMH.uE8bWd41Q34zyYPYrg6TKjzdmgA3qOm1EW.5G5vHDgLm3nMi63izPUvH5O.ZNx4M3heuMI.VltkDTClpyz1WFy0Z_n9qBmwF9Y1wPPJI0zKhLZszyklu7QWIR8..WjKMzsBUk4U3J63c8g.y81FZA_i5HZd7GK.aDj.KEE02gCjPsD.tgsBYgMvUyeOzrfNLowQS9H2T409tDv1SYT7wogyZK_iuTQxdGyr1l1qhKedmquE5yiKYK9WjJCJp5eeYlti0pK_jlL7BYbf5aGdou3RFRaO3ClWh8zEEhCzd7lg9UWF36dYAdv3W1blzgqS4mD_9thOTrnO6tLzrgzWVBfk1tqrUUwFw1LhAna.BDcf2BZn4ix0G5ik3walofpFt.Ue8CRpSgF0XhPwri6r34_N2C695sjrqGGDCOp657yTxo3I0YVDQgcZdT_ZvULG.DnhAU3NRzs8iELXn0hlfDrowRjXOO10agnk88usRvPuRXdv_8Hj0raNP0t6JVaJ9ecFY1WJw7x8M4wSC7Hg.73.jewIkSjlNSDwujNJcbqCk3pOszABr2daTW0a0yl0l4sEpqAvjLxmJoNey8_RUUGRs07pH2He6jU256baByWCVifb3vtnie7zWtwOgYp9CJpE3iESYUhdGeXHtg9NXOZmJTYSzhE7YmxnaJU3gqnCMYwQK.lnjKKwofO9g3o0JnhrZr_U0VBnNZm9IofQhBka0sfeBWqEp7R3ygYkCkeSYBpkeCm5nQB0OB2eOOoAXwrT2Qz0pBYcVtMMODJ3c73jIPBW5QH0pwi0kTPWsK_UWqPO70EeowzLt6T0H20_TAYt9B5A9ECqpUdyFaSMKOeyhSdMwEqBK.39V3BQid2QmvR7w4HyjdYSPoPnbD0kcz.rEHkQk0zlnISZQgdbEwILA65KnrIDbpMzlmvkf0OtFvu.Qx7lJbfqGxuvH6dm1h.b9JltMkRWq4maTB9UheeThS_LjqeOhjHObD7V3RIsm0UtZhy7FnWIA.nvDQVLr4XyQeJm4OTUk_Ls1gbu1GCRbw2EvNOgRHvZkGxrkM2prkov81bapNZWhngGzM15f3LTSem3lkceHUK3spkErA241u1nfvs90hNRg_iA"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8ec132fb781a40ba';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/journal\/resource?__cf_chl_rt_tk=EGnDjRTcri0xitpgzbMPGTJieKrBS9ySd0r_juW6et8-1733204187-1.0.1.1-ruyiduayEss_X2w97ZPI6Fkv6c0dUbDcw89yZE_.2Xw" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>