CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "www.smithsonianmag.com",cType: 'managed',cRay: '9138f3fff8a0ce4a',cH: '8QiYL5ZATgjjfwdbaamrN2sBBbimuJbOZGpDMBJWl7w-1739828608-1.2.1.1-_5eTA4TapmDYfrXMp.Q.Jor8juxbNWZtMdtcVnnm8K0vRfh7P8apQ9IyDW_BIEk5',cUPMDTk: "\/arts-culture\/macys-thanksgiving-day-parade-modest-start-american-tradition-rivaling-stuffing-pumpkin-pie-180985216\/?__cf_chl_tk=z4giXuEXJUeLkhbBPoM.sLxhpgye8Llpa1MogAxffbw-1739828608-1.0.1.1-40jrXwvEI61RgaIzOpXdfGnH3YQMumr8nHw2.QMnMjE",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1739828608',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/arts-culture\/macys-thanksgiving-day-parade-modest-start-american-tradition-rivaling-stuffing-pumpkin-pie-180985216\/?__cf_chl_f_tk=z4giXuEXJUeLkhbBPoM.sLxhpgye8Llpa1MogAxffbw-1739828608-1.0.1.1-40jrXwvEI61RgaIzOpXdfGnH3YQMumr8nHw2.QMnMjE",md: "9YX2VqSbluw.GJVtvITur2zXvZ_V4pkL2fqIdD5sW60-1739828608-1.2.1.1-8Kc8QWJR4i8GHGrQgBtFP1I8foo5xuxvk6N08brzTCnjFk83r0KKsvf.rEUu7YDV6IoC42le9LuSHo.nDo7fehMLc747xDQVhoojvFrwWQ.JB_mLZ8uhA41Wxei6NQdxe0XJV0MnIz23pqueYdKXI.avrKdlDW5IIFdxw_.7AjsZvz5SY6_dyjAt0CRB5C9BJSY8pCZhmdqFLv4B5eGG6Dco2EXPklZozCtzexjMAiJev3V25Kb670RxRQJhZ9oUCzkufD1BbTfNA4NXKHL2bvcC6qvwLz30dYF03knx1k6.Qt4f_Wx3_jZ0x2XKS.iHmjnAIJ_LKw6ajRjgN_3Kquu37EE67_OyQlkN0mSxZ2poiSA9N7v6F069fWiH9_X81bRFam9ctDCQWA5V4f4fp8foJpeW0mVsqv8v9LMp8BM14Ob4FYEnMSCggGXdD2dCcZmSyp2Sb5ZuwF7.zuIV4Ar.38KvZbZmvRHyx7LGRkzRnLjRJB2Qk2ctACUT3w64JUZLnAzwQKnA3p5TQNsuS3KhimdF7eMJQEoRwTii9P5EwgOJDV15u0SjqO4SAP6vxH6Wq.nHjVQClIEv0OnMG12gjcEobZwoA.LHBBaR22A5RYf.CWXyXT9hQPP45B0wMpIzuUpw2gusuEjR1wYFyHdb29CmDDNXVn5dLjIAiQuK.4N8BPFBUHYubjr0CBHB9vAAUZ2kTS3YqQxLtPx2Q.bieUa70LpmWfXLp6ZC6S1N69b_r4.wuA2iXWXwisHDmJ4fKn.NxA6ndoNb28cwpqQQqXQBU6gfRQNpTPzESceShjjQ.8jwzp3gunClL9qO.qbCNlHoj2HSyAeTBUiLOLR7KbCqQSMEftAxjpZw_MmtS2owGaD39YD3va4Ob.44UJXV7o7LiWMwVWK9.pnssBOBRbQIdAPa1oJcHKkK00XQgoaW1XUeZGILffzILk6hTqdrqmcMDcO9OVsxSiHQ3VIC7NwGXgsHFnm.gKJio4Fu.iPAwYlpXrNe2uK5d9bI6x_WOXPl8BNBbC8vQ9BUf6IZDJ7EdL2Fj1T0dsQYJKmkna3_DrfAla0fWgCObXQW2nXXodMXriBjbdrGr8Cdw9MtPYmoAwSg4CLZN7VIOnCA3CgxDTEAUHxWJQFkWWESnKNS2RGHx2HHDPNsDl3gelg7AIuWXf7ne.unzPrnrnDyDdCRbkrbzQpZv_oIHFjllDsQ2yQhXV3X9a8C1kYlGuCMSdg74JP7qv6w8PoFFr8viw3IcD65v4tjFCjKbEBuTdhhgwyEy2lY8tzcLeEpLBJw456kGGmDzTlHkEJoB21iOcS0unVefcg.0gRaIaGxp8qgzLBHWw5MnznN_qpyiKyCXK21BGsnqO5xTTV6kq7armoRhKHkuGW8ibAUINmbO3ukrrl_iX9U9JqEM0cadvdWUequE2ngALxZqs81gknp2Cre6E3JRNQ9.ZJLQ932x7yv4AKrJkVMqwvR3QYnWbH1JsVlDQkRPCzFlAnrb9MdvbO_LxbXIVQ995HwoAwxTTvYqO2OgGR2pr3rrhcSrLuTATwdW7Gft5lQXBcX8IsmtuqSOIro8yG5sLLZMxWTD2e6OSV2d5VwgoUPs8qLmtdnX5iDfp8naskVJM9FGrADtrmQFccMce2qBdWIrMPbjbXnm5uRttG34BEPelIp1ZgaegUI8u9VmbcKwe3x0bLG38._jmXW.Dp.xDGDMQ5m.SvO_XCbVFoJevSpiM5hrq4kNQacWhhvvgjRz1KlldZZJ_zw7IQKjwkhcUnKDp3ondI1Dj.euOWlnA75xusFZnSFz4w6bYWla2Kg8iAoHLB.as6QRMCc_WsoJwlDK3q0ZBrUXYKv_hz8Qlie.sKnTIkl5bPgsxjeMJRM5_weJ9HmMLFaS0bBmJDuTjgB7lotyicVr1XNDcrBazNa0y3hS1mk.4jiBcdWGyeBwuZOTXUcWwpdS9Z4xqplrJNM7UlrlKK8r6WBzs7gQfChFTmL1a7wORqXB4p8gCXNe6XD.sU06KCsZbEs09tULLoEIsCJaCAz677IS66d2RIgEL35osxT1jDAsNFOJR1dL8vgWT7tZ1gqdsevJNicy3qzYQL4UOQdJd.swW5JhlhOnMM7H4N97KrRo4aeZ9o_ApuFYs.X.Z0Tu.9U4HiOODXUAi5AevZradpNI4hGZjd7OI8PWkGuDKEWy01dK5TtqS4G1wsy7ZHIjpL3AykBOHrzeMhNJBhrLJDTfi7W0rJVJ8hAkXZ.Z6B8T3FumkxAyRnOU..ItzZB3ibdVXOzMfiPCyUfRQ2IUXIBWHwLCkq2EmXa1MnfuvLpM0G2gBQJ2w5_d9F_8a1EoCTeCAL99qSHHAqxnrF5E7I5TFyQ5iJsVELIuGFoE6qQMDSblL9bwxMLQzgbHc6YMmV8gqrHPhpScKb8izeEoJCCWcLSPHv_FwWjy87qz0d42f2b.iyI0MDJMhIZ8IUbk5pGZy0dbvVerujZMF5UvuqLmBo1CytulaE4PRKocntWzVv.tHm1Zeiwo0ARAMnXfbAKooj_X58CkEakHMQykK39r1gZP9WAA1RezoLLjTowGVmTjGfQi19lOAXza.iqLouR7fQgjS5nXHOH8jwF6ZOkjGdSnMarxT.c7S2zULwWbKGsp.zvcqnZ296fwVN3uXK._bep4EZgzlDlLdZVXNmjuHoXjMnMJtykABb0ocgxJpo9.8CZe.vx7fxWE001h5TTuEqNvIqZFbUTvI88.hrVT5HKx9kOSL5QRq6OHHQJuQY2affZVsUlugo",mdrd: "IO6W3yLXVjmP82GdeHV3T8L4Bbur.X3oOW8Q5wEg6Nc-1739828608-1.2.1.1-OcEKQMCa4hVX.kSN.N1NUovT_9vKQo6m1y2t8V8IwroipDiRDQzWXZfGzung_jXJri.RgmKpK_tHzMpNyutZK7zqojcN.DJXKoyP5DVOflZtK3mgPGP0dA.qX1SrMc3cTvkf63bhVZB9MTu1lxfT62LMLGqnhFvTrzMtjLA7tp0.sOmV0LtHaGMXuImRxIxALghRk8xmC1dcxCE9ikeFbrwHOlpun_n86hIKJbnG4gw1dqxKRMcPTpf03bjXc66WInclWCWiI0JeuRGDQ0LucESSUtADkNJ7D6F4ABkOn0o7gMNoBJf5Ogup0DlA4bUUqV0wDOWYNwYSGhVe_h20lSUWUn5.gdLIyXFwlh.hrzG9cPpMNTP9t_4p5VG5ebAcHw0I1_aX9n9Mix25AxSuynYTPgdI64jYzouZ5WxOWnbQp8IUjWRKnffM.hoMtTDi.b5OZLxzqrpWqgWepFHuCFcrUyLmdjdrL9gI_ZyPVT2hUoSJOfgIGQ5YHDOnUvmqabkeHHYl4mBNHboV21igK8YXyaWS66KBnq7WC.LVe_3ON9eZEj5hyDt8st39dbRhXMOWO_4dfOVQy9Fim2e5Pf4APSswC7_qccKW6cWwXLnAyqqmnPVd4jF65DVQtjurvQPJSat.Y6hlzQI0PXbsp6nUk4IH5Gy5JJvE68vMrLJA5gE50NKMXiMOguJeuwDR1KwQ4UYUav0xiHdaEVpLVsd3M9iSwTxA399ZlB3XZjwGtVjBNOrdJL6Q1lz2FxmTAm7YuH.FVkPaHY4eMztkpzKq.hL61n8tyW8708Z8goF1aOImqTGiLh6X9G1sVq8liIDQtfXy1AWFOFB2Bl_SkpDp0I5otwGTjOpg_h5TZ0umwxGWvPccYp9xR0jILLWEpqnW._zCbksY2O2Tii28pYCp9cyQywOw9_qk5nYynD91GGSQaaON6CmCJ1QFzmDz6f5zHS85O6dyerKzLm45uc1d0jvgb2iGJ6rGUVo4SKxNmac2Qd7qrFWMjOH_9EXPcIuhYzOge2NdFGaCkOwx4WoIyZy59DsySHMT2ZW9fsSTpkVdGA4NWMEvECxnwXawOWWIhJ5oEVz1xL5xDOV0TaPGDJ7qJzHjsYYtJh5yITkTXr_DOX8c.Jz9lfgG.KCUlTkL_UG4LuJc1.WJMcJVwoSYcq.5izn9DLBSxQv4XSCsdSsimzfYSBpaku7eap7zBuBi_oTigB8zO_THv7OPjUGb95gvbBQ65qXY908_.Q6Kr9Dhl6spHw.k4OxftfE7VVRqaTtV6OVzUGLtlj013PoVVfv2YWZJI5v.QPyulfkPIHVYw1UuUOopi0w9dGJ8h3hl09CAGWu55G2rCymyKrvr7N81qW0YN0wYKC.g2qcyerwUXykLe.od7R5Yf5bN1CC.HChL.BUin7bv7x1kUiaTyo2n45B87xgFQYcJzbHI8dkwwMjfGjcjp78tZMw3cU54CBZVc84zkTuLelOKImp5_RDuq4.UsPKunTfxo5AlVCgy8R4Bb4qx3VmaTzui8p8dgvgZZNvNEp1DaoWFiZ520ASvZsh3fri3ZlXi_gM2SI9UbPRQzh1YYQgG07fLFVoszJsvEn.xd0wZiwHFL0HsJLC4qHfmYsYMFipw3Wx7B8QhyKrqxap4vUmwjCPXtCKgptEw92h940Okdj_YHLkUAafL9SHXS6fUmNjwHRXjn69WwbRuIITDK_ulEsbKXcFskAK2_04viEnrJiTljMJD2aZJq7xFe_aqUtpUGJFCJKER7SaTDdvZiiuAOR8y74CkGSMLry7A.h37udBoFuaUbTkHv8yGPhfUSImYEbNVCdi_XU4cuigZSzjaNILN_RhSw21nbnt1gPrOxhLN7h04H6CVGbi56EShMVcj.F3lFcXwsH2bya8TQMv0uFwkMtQX5DI1I2oMv9DmdOfi3veNEWsDme.Rnrb8CREAXpjpQT3L8IERlJekmQsc8w3Q22X5tC0BzNs1FvWsu4E0FQ"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=9138f3fff8a0ce4a';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/arts-culture\/macys-thanksgiving-day-parade-modest-start-american-tradition-rivaling-stuffing-pumpkin-pie-180985216\/?__cf_chl_rt_tk=z4giXuEXJUeLkhbBPoM.sLxhpgye8Llpa1MogAxffbw-1739828608-1.0.1.1-40jrXwvEI61RgaIzOpXdfGnH3YQMumr8nHw2.QMnMjE" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>