CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "pubs.aeaweb.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8eae8cf00f62d43a',cH: 'hTP0cdWodqZtMULndJoxNDp3RPwDGositUhoenAIsCc-1733008642-1.2.1.1-z5cQZbViUr2U4pa1VD_Z8tya_.yTDr1Fo5aVrzcmXiEFEOLx_ZYJGf2sZgjcEHKu',cUPMDTk: "\/doi\/10.1257\/jep.6.2.117?__cf_chl_tk=kxdXU.5.Myyvh9CY1NF0OvYSTWg2UcPFKT.0hMhzriI-1733008642-1.0.1.1-QHALfTX3Oj_LZCgel7Pr3zRHgmFysKLh4A96Uu7vIXs",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1733008642',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/doi\/10.1257\/jep.6.2.117?__cf_chl_f_tk=kxdXU.5.Myyvh9CY1NF0OvYSTWg2UcPFKT.0hMhzriI-1733008642-1.0.1.1-QHALfTX3Oj_LZCgel7Pr3zRHgmFysKLh4A96Uu7vIXs",md: "m5ITxSdmVGFAN0hJyGvpC_k0qkgEViJ44D9r8kiU0oI-1733008642-1.2.1.1-zq3FoKOr264QCffi5n.gnVtghMP4X0.sUkY7OFSEDs094tsT7bMouDRO2YJ5.mH8Ote8HIuLdCfGdDxDhKduvVbDSmSn7Wynximi2dT7UCAx5dpWUhI99hlliAmdAyIU742RB4auzV5C9rXjMy4l0Ki2ROuwNN05Obh9eebwCOKlT6nK_PB36fo2FsYglAsjSTBa3UD4yIsQdT5EIMh.hz9cjoKK1qBhmig8YUSuuE2Em9WpKvj65vgbuG2unuqjMtVnpTzkWUS3l7j57yeotvQAnbrtc7JvbqBzk5sBbxsziVbzvIedmmzPlSEpmfEx6BavF1gHG3A.BUBn.xZBSrz35tVOGkQLs_hZUts54Vkqi.yk9pW0HLh4Egu.TjrDTQf3vZFTXDP3v8L8ArLZ_h6mbhjWDl7Oe1Ofn3_SRfUDBEMQEQ8I6XwPjbZBWZ_TYatlZoQpRiMkTQ9Shp2iduAH00JvXX2oP1zvPlDG8h0M0niUBCB.oVoEqABZDvqfilTCSpErGDHeWBt7jVAKjGvb_pPY45im6m.dw3RL1pDm8GsN4n64gZ75Y2UDNpRcpXci3cTPEkf86ZFyoXnOHeEvBey1QmlFuK4iZkbsUlUvLy2RPwjK43d1Ke4l_eB9w5jgH8nf.k0seaBUaKr36ye.LakKRDYrvpD1hd2tT9xfMah3rkKS5ldw2DXSvI_VTN4QzdtAsBkY8dLfZE0ORmIF6_oe3NLsBhQkVfFLYHFGs.YTJaBnCYASbJ9OsJtjtjWppmpoYPFgy65U.A_V_ZsJGQ7.6SAWmxA1pGaE79lETrqVc5l6svEFYrGeDF2H8u4sOm5hUQMMvDudLbqvnrMDOOYtrLX0Rhmmppzzl8AfA_7hzCtiNR3nd4uKQVNfcYhWclMQ1gtuGXddeZ9ANpL4qiYX7UiAMoNCEfKOixkdtmxKL4TIZG7a2nu2rNVASGh1Y9PObDI.fUb4lpUSChdlJqjL6PgY9JIYSBccXcs9rEQH4ybggFE6lVq78pPgPGDYCl2Rk5lZvmKYxygoHFTpk3._OiQdvoV7FBzDi3IqTBBSG0..WPbcyq.IljMMWpehU3U1YNQcjUtX6ZEn4fTAM6CNrKXhegUrrmDfttixTNKmc0D_LOYyD5K3e6ZDis7mGe73JSY8bl5DrgnYyL3LGwdFkcgur5oIropmO1NB9ek93cVBdWXDTLNEaGuFSr_t1w13Cn_UlPL2S9yNXZTN6f1CaAyhPydyFfJKKKEEgQWYd7iCByRpId84tZC_7.eimiV6mXVPcSpSE8iOb3yX1YrXzKLV8sUL2MOJJXlhqk1sxtavMio9vpZOAl8nSfEMwDAO.5WPc7Z4R7E3iMIZ5AueAsddMQrDs4ZKhviQ4ZFFkjmKWTbS13qSa3adbyIL0NyN4JqmV8PRaT8irakbtAkAMTbGUYqom77vuadvVv_gUdqRYM72rld5IQT_hx34KZRnzdIW8tAm90x7xKGj4TFNrLtPDLxQIu7unQMfRZFf2lfQFX0vrwpR4WfiPYjj42lSaj15KNJpySr7p3rB_.lCGB6hnV0kR4zbmudBIh_vT1Ji84H2aU7uyD4ertHmpc1UqOKSCxdapopNvJ.t2JQLmIAom8xL8VcNnc2O3QHZjPsF6zF80IM92b.ZBAwBTT2Pt5.E1YXKcO_VUfoiTgFeckV4VO5XeQie7p0Axug8zFrrIZtpHg_floruqI4EPdz5XdX0z5Ed7g9jysuMFq.wvjam5buzCbuGTAj6D_KID9z.RiWwdyGSw7fR3_e3cZh39GSBN0GbNBi.8aQeRnkiNlBhY6ZdoUH2Elss_J3kHzngntu9Cy93Hj_4ObF5OEC1t2c.6Jaj1i5k0JCxXcZtITwb8MvNRKnyS04GTpjaOXZK0CpICQLjJU5frwbWBjSfjV1DqCfRMIKDohSgcqQnAf1kltI.hNMM.z51j_SZnJUllfgQ.n1WVE2mDem_6f4.e804bP2uc2bcUgj4oAUghY4dia7AM6tZVLiHdeLchMSFioRFbsB72CpeZ4jwLzHdkCROacqetveCJKxbbhPhUzHSbEum2EXGiG7oG2KhrGQNffWN8EZ7.vKbFPJe4JIrSQteHkbmyZG7o6Gll4U4IBGCbjcUUE4AFtBPdlfkisrz_hlvAgUsJ0A38kMrmhMJqSeP5p5sBYF2O7kjbK5J0cz0V80u93BX1VPhnxKZ4sKR6jFDjUCkB93aQrrxzxkAd_oPR2iaeCHTf_HSbAPIkCraNiXpwwxiXQjLNpHXX3qT3NsfwU2prUfcpWbBWyHNdYkY6exxrPH20wQQ1hNqajVZUpAQ9qbrlnGZ5GXs0KImpWYLuzfTk__YR26xgIo1Ma.cmWpQE1x4O3eQdRUqNvG4OTBK2vZquHwnLo564d1BmzdczpXWSZKbTScvG8fq3953gWPXCmhL0v2QgBYecVuITRwI3gJkBX1yCvADpCnC618Ycoxzz40hKPTAG5RvdD4rAw_eI9T95nm13tBEyMKdMdpd48NSltVIsMhtN4L5yty4cBHfLMI9x7jwTmuEXhnh8V3vO9rbNghyh.OJuVMb01QgGO_F0HVXwF_S8P0A0TudV.ZUGsy973b_MLkQg0zNv25SfJgT.Msfvunb8m.rXZxJkL4NoROQOeNKWO5Zy5MBnjm70jOUJ8o_L9GjuhOWhO774aw_HpE87txlb5F7rkjNhjBQauExZxmD1asZHE.jm51ybw1emdoFyIT6dDbkbKL5bNDGw51nCVhuiWa6rIrps.5ZOinSaeA4vjAv15VHnNWogv21Gwa3vnUgpLoNWzABzL.BIBf3emb0wTrhLOpJGkdKPMnUCEALdIunQJZpudW5Lo8C8Ig0IdUPW1pmfwhKz97Ig_w5zhC3Z6rvx2SZlBaE1HgQxltOF8AOhENxHuRW__Ecv2adirE3.K3t9ny0wioY6g",mdrd: "UTqa4gD1esG4cbOzBkEHBUpPTRRH_.VQGqNvBC7S0fE-1733008642-1.2.1.1-YGSyYdViXvQVMNE7lxrbpQ83SoUq8lG4tmZvznI_jbjzGxisM91f2XRaGc8UgMLD2xoe5wlRJDp5GVdqhikx3X.sCocxMOkfwZGloSZedXpJxksx6qLKbQMtjUntvK3DRLEEZleB52cO9k88NRxRitKjKInRwvzNMdChdzi_J.M7DC671Gv1zSae0U2QZOySgS_6veDijVHrKtKaAVO6mm5y1cGknCAIgQkBZwVZYy_iKAM5nxB8bfJOfyfUOVOFMKb_XA36VcMs3AKFC_2NsmRl4apQm9R1d_WgR4SQkxwV0Ncw7EekccD9fh9KlapJ3Ww8gv5va5whrdvh.86kf8jDy65K3j4RTHqxDcdgzxmCkKvukU08SFpNppPIvhwyoNzh10EXYm8aUo4S6Oo0auEr7tFI5KwfiS0.PV9RCPpVoHjhEj0eIIyX0vt3dToMzK9A900qhRIbqVbvOmlHMssszrk_TUXNbzNHFhfqfi1QZa4QQpZWkryfGyAcgNOhyN9MIhbARvG6Bthr9doJPZwzAsMCYih9c8S75JSxuVbHwWsHLuqmkm3HdaArUJci2qE0GEpWA31y__zRQsdS058_8BrMF21yZ8DyexKTM8Ovy6XqNHp13ywTP7.poJ8vfiPHbw1y8IhgVAMw8k_41ZTdi2ZWd8r_J1A47WUwDVJty3.3YXd__mV5baNiFp12nO3xVUdN9d81W_fSSRc5cGd9q2EzviPsDL2tgslQ_CkGN67Eo7l6ftEPFpMk63aEpug16L6LwEKOnR5.hyMPZZpnIzWE7vsighWUJodhVX1oOmcFccpqRMvZmKdrD6fRiUAvOG8WPgbRkE27vKjpCnR4rNLI5gkmCfFtEE3.re92eXsOpeFeUgcDNEtVfQIIgmiSDVg9GgHmQKMvqT8_nkYtSRV3zaqiWAiR.JulncMQPcA0YAcgqewuI0ztjKXLc1efXX7CMo0RD6u7Rhonktd_yo2q6n7OQYdQMAMr4pBdTP5K4JukW9Il06gGrNgOk.w0CfCSA2C4BSl0N2JUPLJ3f299OxaIB3yeJZ8r9CCHsgiaolcW9KoIK0kVLmNG9vRuCWQRl7pSQupTojouXV8ILNzOG1f95j29I1d6910tbOWMjZsgB9uAOCvY9rBhx6aCId6Lwjr30mMfeSEexZgCCf1xflnWEcMDIsRVjFrJiSFYsR7yIyJECOqoLEXNBF63kMyBNt1SzrnqeHXRVpJWq6SLc9_owvbx_VmsA.nGhnSReSrJpWjQ4LoH_.C7iJCcirAz2Du8mamDcGtRm.sZNCTZL6xlwvSZcm8lE._KcQto.ee1HfzufLIWRjFNRu4wWa9E7NM7LhyMjcraOMQb.fQRyU1SaRQjO9BB3c2C7sn0uu0hypvRcM2gFGZAtc3lP5pv6MN.MZQ_5V4oa8a42kdCgqzGW0TjAARVBXreqJOJZ00ls9yum4Rf3sgcuIcsUtNkcOy_svras_zTu5VvKushx5ND9K2g5UqJB6fb_vKrJODP2iceiOPP_PNE0bOkwRcI9g71IxiORrCv6cGJA7sXQvWb3OGHgjNLvMlo7jurW7uf.5XMddFfGsB3.vSBwDRUsmDtkq1lbo0nEWPrqLNoP.uprzzKh5tuyyMgaB9ruxItUd2tIg2VqCrisc5LfY.oasN2cT1v2oQ3ioGvZK_BcCC8IcOUUX434x2cN_uNipyN8CNlKli7K5VVYAKVBVS_KVoyBjMhF40VjiEcTej2B4NSsqTEJCPdNLGN2Rz5q3gKCvL.Ej7PnlWXW2zzvncrHFt25Mro_8XFstSnVnFSqviVk4pzq94vzWi1MTnij0KJ3J6BHhiRUDiij.MbVQwBVuiI4F2RCH6LcD.rQN4hwnbMRbd_oez9oIte2epdIyGbZHTebEFOK_K3PpMvNHUARp.faoYT5xdnyIGxzPqkOtVsHfQJTv2teK9.x8123qOb_zOvfZzucsg9"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8eae8cf00f62d43a';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/doi\/10.1257\/jep.6.2.117?__cf_chl_rt_tk=kxdXU.5.Myyvh9CY1NF0OvYSTWg2UcPFKT.0hMhzriI-1733008642-1.0.1.1-QHALfTX3Oj_LZCgel7Pr3zRHgmFysKLh4A96Uu7vIXs" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>