CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "philpapers.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e732e446d05ce32',cH: 'cEWf6IygEd9XYHUlnhZNwExZ3n11NlOMpj7LxQke.8w-1732386105-1.2.1.1-zFViUCW320Q._Cp7q0tsMiETyAWek.rqHr5XF2k_Sflou_4_OEEawwMP7G4LP_tE',cUPMDTk: "\/profile\/18436?__cf_chl_tk=AgPQGyft04_Yi8Ey8g3fuFEI.NyMaUSwQSCbJYVXb_0-1732386105-1.0.1.1-i0AKGkrAxDsPMoMq1zxCpZtyUnjNiPGg5mB7BaEH2Xg",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1732386105',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/profile\/18436?__cf_chl_f_tk=AgPQGyft04_Yi8Ey8g3fuFEI.NyMaUSwQSCbJYVXb_0-1732386105-1.0.1.1-i0AKGkrAxDsPMoMq1zxCpZtyUnjNiPGg5mB7BaEH2Xg",md: "lumNfcmUaOE16TuOWEmGP0S54VjQWCYad5COi4uG9lQ-1732386105-1.2.1.1-3rXIPAF14hePCyQXtQizo4Z.DbjyWUBS58ivK9u_KwlMtyHdJA_ZLEx290QKk6_9TL0o_8HlrEXs04QqP.OGF2Jeu04G3DD6SvyQgFcSW1Ur2CmuACaRZ_SBGs5pRqheQxmPibrNiR7Np6_YA4Ga3uy2LU79uDTauiDMdrQAlAlhYSJW5ZFcbOJhgsWXmnecXznMinL74OJHKhzjLPLFL8zFz.vANwRgaYt1LMBCXHuwOiwU0mfWlT5TGKY3HPCmn_PZsexRaOJSZyYy8T1T.l56IQ14Xg9V0M2Ak.XmtJrPEHijfYpkjbPpRRNvELNfyxe.Z0cgMTKzoRhBreim78SNHqD92obQUANcWVM5AONckL09Vb8i_E8dHzoIERo.ih_3w4fOCp.iPV0D7_5.6cPNHWY8vdwiMkpUEh2cvVjcETZx2LHOqwQIZUYmplpZg_WpCjKJBOzizM3EzNGpLj_ePTmoLyQuA_3aF9KgbHkweGa_5vu_K_4o9ETCRgniUdMTmvyX7TKZJfCJRCrDmbZEPVWwcbFZ5zjpjfTJrcoXrwnGcWpwDgjesUM4RnySeS53aQge7D.O1RI_tr5RGqhEdVbN05KwH.Y1E8zowH3H6wzNPHRjf24NHrwzI6CEa4JRcNr0IXvH72jbTnxl9u62femMIOw3mvO2UWAYTRPadw8MgN08S9sDrwUJsEJYkh8AWpFj9E_OBNC85r0_YVBf2pFaopnr94jAXjqFpKJQvIKAP9tn73f9rutAEcwPAV4S0w3NBTyEUAAmXmi2csn3Kcmm2AtXXfNtUKTCDb2frArAWc7fAtScuTwK7eEjgjUuOHNzJD7lSj_q9JNFcLssloP4suTZvYMbPO80u3RLgxBn4wFPy8jslXjgq6x7zrSgtwlw5Pwm9BBHKsvz.uRx4YF8s9QFucqp_HL1.TrAB9bDebpcFChYvSndkbxgsSJFXkiatE.YCoWkJmu4.nBD9O1wHuVt6qQUlhRHrvZqN8G6LorHAOZMmsEv21oPiDb33Vvw_rI5C4sb0GfVxzur7fO35cGUZyuX9txuecWNqxa4GPIV1Pc0xKYt31DExR0mH_XoJwfPZpXpnShsd6s156UvR6effuH2bWit5Y1pWYWfkd24_aDburNdMEywMyP7j0h9f.626BX2Cnae3Z_Bd5p4ACYhN4c6o4tUM6EEyxmvruPLWZnUZBm.mkX28Gl7zZfrxtU.B12G2vnHhcwVHSTnNhaJoSWnsCSdJP_Abo.pVoUys.0SMdkPRSDcOCCnEmwo4D8zDNA0jafHwwyN5YRjqYdm3GaAWs79FU8DX8_pjsRrT50jBxIdcSrSLmZr7pjl5XXFO2L9b4A1mBTjonq.BDQVpge78wA.ZW1kBjQCdppcjT8UBUXIK_tLukEzt27LwomT020V2VrzvCQ1fk8E1bzkbdMrPlePbHFkYiXno_nkpROz.0YDDR4M_IWnm0oFfxtXLTVbNRSqDP40GBlWE0a8C8KxORFaXf.JKlCPbUwyA.Tz9NCtbN9htBJX69DCicPt5huQ9BSPgOk3lcrR93ZopxSBkkBmJggSt7CSPo2RULH7PFO0l_UpYAv_QFALcD9eFjh17pF6odOQpDMX4RjnCOFn_yyVCBOBJcz78.PG6rzZCVUgefRVTI08b6TmZpdwqUmlFHU_qcGGaAzZR6.nLt2AL4F0RYWe25WsojbJxy9OQvVo.ZlDX1coUpjvcN3SOm2CcJCDuLGz7Kw1hLW06Ai8S3Hx7QaENWBTquE6pJfMy0eH2ODopjUpWnmgJIBnR0RMNGaYrHkxDyQpFibryq7Rb0XYThAPDX4FuJoD6uc3qPa2aRSfR2cT49CR2EZlqW2ecvy8EjbXd7eUXuy0T_Tr6i6b2bB5pN50BzrZlYeft.7LxPASWWMic90GmHm.olg1Ce8qzGCeGnPBM2IeILynfUjM3Nxyk3tdZcSJLlD9uY4wIazYN2n5dDtAEE5cs7QwkdPTyLZzUjMC8AqOOY063bDkYXHZsCNOC50ZndYMzMgKummw3AyRhcQ77uUxJpOyfukSNgQTs7pmbxNrixOOvy3TRa7KnQYuvrT2Za41DJi5j5N.2aSoavUZ8BdSzOpICICnoN0CgE3TnEyqVW9BfV3qmYtdGqYS3wkwD7dG.LasbflxzwmrUkQ3bE0n0MOk1T271zIEpVq_y0JGzKGRVvOw0IApon9xP_R1l5xjrSLGTbzTRMvqhQCL6KZiyzMTgDiddEfDg71ZfPl_vdAgujo2tjmAum1g0JXrb5NlJ32NonWaR8bGIVWrm1g7Qn_YMXaeC2qN76GlMUzzUhwNlYX024HihXn7AmbZNJRLTWh9CjnoZbC8xa0GJgG_zBL5SVHQSbH6LoyoVgvskgZlgH_MpUCnjumJvZkmGQnGV94CocplBgGGitKyRjLO8L0HhJyaauWBNS50nMXlOkYZzolvRRGJOStM2k5BwNH2NxdOMa1W8sYFDQeYgd4FADCwcLYosdX94DOVRsQ9.xdbSYGog2WXyNVC0qPz_ktruaDI.6r7iwVROGEpss6x2_W73W4CNchopns6C2kXwZiTQ20oR2i6SG3QytfkXTJpPrziZqtwLXarknZ69lTHh0srPHefXouQQia5b633HbGl2yQnVTXO0ACSUma8W4FKmQAIWrnzme8PEiGwrG4jS4sNCEhAmrgH8oAfwbpRlLRx7KNbFmdMLlJAgVHxHM9foQYsrAqj.tuLiQKtfcYB.RzIeZ2vsLHEKjSWGmHgsGolFeMfU55TvOysFEApME08tbLPT1kUwr5I0j9oIiy2f2LNjq1AkA0iCPe8GCxXpRZxdSbp9jxM_tcTzTuQW0tFBD43cowrlpB_GDIh7ew9DYHqb4mpyVOsWZ1SmoqrgOHRWztsyic",mdrd: "lJzsXIY2rMRvHPZhlGw7QLKHttaxmhwTB9qvsDcx3Qs-1732386105-1.2.1.1-YrrCJppR8iYHPMHRnhIU03AfftRTi3ncO8X3zagUWKn6egoBzNCycP0oeXRLkEHwinHD0ko5qdpEm6f5n9FzBIc1ed4nEmywpJ1PxgPNB.RpbslHzn9dxm9EoBHZorkuwWpSU3vSRW6hlhHkQKif0G5zUZYMAZ_lGauAanD.D2Y1Vkart_1MQClr9t3r3_CKFieaYjZCTmqP041pPaGVMz5RQGCOJuuLUWdBze7gT2YNCdKUvyhBkM1BWqC5BC0wOFotDMUfsXEYObKObQxK404DOhTZ65qa8q7taz5.9IZD16vlAtA.3vNvMZCCFbEoz5PikQi1Ui_srbOTRAha5GGCk3jB.LMHtf2lU64szR9oYH3lqFqFortPeAM02hsL8h6Xzh57m7T_GRwxFJzB.kf6BjthZK5accPO7XU3YzWrOJrNHTscZRIooqb5GjwyxYsHT7dNRdnFoD6HCOuDEJXqgiU_Q6CoKhvm8CmaoT4Wbf1_BrEdzWqsVqYak5eJ0Dch3SUZgKeormKrH_hIH5D3OIh1hjHWvbFc97tUEyhW20QfPGPaGuGquRgUCGxk1rNOVCMBMReJraKzIT805zy2TQy85211GjAtkMwUCJgScF_EDYGPxShjhHwkvbDdzxkwJgAyQDNMQtVkV4WgmJ1dOhcJ2WJg1XeLr1jHUTyk14E36ghd55D.Kea6RSPMZ_pgBicTgaRC3rgMYnYbNbNTjWixeOBX9C3OUtXndAmb9JVDuG_wMF5vHg9L3al0lZ6ZgPVHIiOpL.wi_mLp.sOslqRWNY4WUvzkM9t6nYeNoZgc2fzDxyA7A4Xe0WWOmjpgEYdQcnfiV1ln.qoUUPSMEyTNoArI9hvSW3qgXXrUmmihscI.YWTP4AcdiQh_aO.vY2.eKtKvEE21MV_NmOmL4IfeV_nLDqYNyyj6xqCEmUMhWcXRHyBOJPdl5lFEvzlVgcnD.LqvvODEDLJC4z_.IY.GIXRPd5ZHmjXW69s6tIJfNpz0QSge1f_zVAsQXfHB07TN5sMyAafa4.cN.v9QHc2wscCdHiLWM5fEOREVqmiGpjl9AL1KlNj4WT7h_z5ORhoyCRhYK37M_7z9nKcYXUX0NBYWlqb_B2tYyvYdh4nk8JbQ3AdAepzNvnRiTaubMoH2ouVt9DSsDOMMrQpCWl2SxCN4vyJVuegSqp5e6wf5tuZIYytEjJMiHB4Yi0WwDV0FDmxizIgGwcs0QgPX.fgaFhARl6YQ_Ao2a4czSWLTFLMFUI_nvDJnZFib8vlBcNMbggkDva6ZkK00qI89ZWJ88WK84Vnkw8Fsm3jM.We4JRRMNHaQLKMy4u1kXoWMkvH1KpYdShphxXVmb5GVqrd93S5LhdvmvZl.J3o_BDgFVyQclrAFv0_T0P9QDqc0kqA8CM_HLciepWd2T9B6QlfO53hUNVM8qc3KuygYeY3jfABKiJsJbgpVVyhO0Ll5AzqngTga5QfMlE9Boaq0CInBweJodIvtBdONjD0Nc.SbXfJBkd4en5aAgenLzVc4fEAeBQU46YRAV_5ORiq8wp97HvpNwShvTnjhoguvH5dnXsyRT.DErBz8lKWiHnQ4XEm5JR4BvBDiB4Ed9wgjkWuSLNuyMy1rOf_2mI0nYDgKfKjMOUv.J92wmUIn417tDWA4HLN5beoJP6BFfcvSrYoIp6A0vnrAXGvPirleVnE3Jh_o15tkqxq6ml2nMeK88Y__PAO55D2ox7szMLe7p4KNYzwQpNijy2lsgGzEUgnKw1NLK831PAjcku1aOSiswmWumdQc6g__nTjmIFU8Qrrbc0KkdOcIVmu.O1Ca1wyLuUwWSX5VOASOjYPkq.ZAVghPTXKdQK_GzpXAWNxUf2E.oHXSbpcetfAmwfiPA2c977OupdfOngKiSaqDi1Lnd_DSMb9S9GKAl3hgWEZ_ipyatC.S8F_sC8Ed7bJZuIqFk7ULkAEAMIPtZ4K1"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e732e446d05ce32';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/profile\/18436?__cf_chl_rt_tk=AgPQGyft04_Yi8Ey8g3fuFEI.NyMaUSwQSCbJYVXb_0-1732386105-1.0.1.1-i0AKGkrAxDsPMoMq1zxCpZtyUnjNiPGg5mB7BaEH2Xg" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>