CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "www.researchgate.net",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e91e48c3d1791c0',cH: 'Wvi8C27jxxXw9qydklJr38zNl78YBR3bGpDgbJQQYb8-1732708144-1.2.1.1-dbXo0eTmqi0_Jx2dpBTxN4hjaBuy9gDUEWkIEZOY09nZyI3UEzVlHhpEpYV8462T',cUPMDTk: "\/publication\/255703431_Artificial_reefs_as_fishery_conservation_tools_Contrasting_roles_of_offshore_structures_between_the_Gulf_of_Mexico_and_the_Southern_California_Bight?__cf_chl_tk=BAA3TFgLHM_Y4xHmjBZIXh8vOj1beBmJroRC7BRk9OI-1732708144-1.0.1.1-horpsOGzi9K94EjiXIpIHNMtBxfdi_ewGGzByGntZwU",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1732708144',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/publication\/255703431_Artificial_reefs_as_fishery_conservation_tools_Contrasting_roles_of_offshore_structures_between_the_Gulf_of_Mexico_and_the_Southern_California_Bight?__cf_chl_f_tk=BAA3TFgLHM_Y4xHmjBZIXh8vOj1beBmJroRC7BRk9OI-1732708144-1.0.1.1-horpsOGzi9K94EjiXIpIHNMtBxfdi_ewGGzByGntZwU",md: "1eeVnw4A7jlAePI1JZY8dch7uTDYCeEaYXhzEn2Cds8-1732708144-1.2.1.1-eOOapRH5EmB4fxJMgN7kMmjprnX4xUvfSRfH_PxWryVgu_Z.gxf5g2GT6V8JZT1XhQCffq2kjAtiL4QPGCxycqkfiChuwS20PDGR226wuMCpCQ2PsiQ8tUBNbGOA2R_MdNW0dag5.xxMyxn9HQNjKpaBgGX1ERoF5QesRaEu8qvJquDVTAssg_DV9M7DX_x2x84O_MbfFDetPZ0LYygX5hvrHf235wI_I8yWxWZS7exKBLVX66a9mGwqe_CfT_F.2P55HBzVqcDGaqEULa7ViNF3GmbNQ8993vm_gipulVpyFGBycUKdMADp0EeqibpwChkYw1cjiyyHZiRmzHA8rawy62k1Ze0riHFah2unY.Y2ihaZ6qFmZDbTLsfY99qGTrfwHVxAXU8pBMQZlPbe6.5ERMrz6m4L1NtC4d9kBnvEkuMu3rh6BzrSokofdtVtUN75FNxnnY9aeeH21rTmfNOQi7foqFI1AsSWWPI6TH4_SKbFi.uCqlgFUrKvm4iv4j0L4Sy2IcNlp2Zba0o4r66c_84Mg_bKdN8.orvh.COAd3Uu2qbHmkGbeYRcX77MXzCHNKdtSdHEUjj8uflQ5wVAy91UnpHQWXrQ8yQNLGrYckVhR1soIWTq6gw8NScl.Ix7FQsGr7US7I_qMbY5e5zbG4X3gVDztXYpkREnJxtsGRrn6MnbLu6EUqWYBGyrnKyrkFnA4mDGhur9T8Yt68BJ8y7VpqqE1vBvq.M6dsqYhFsKmEduA6AhGeb2gEAUn8znxzadGKQ7iS403AhLZPJNLem9KoiYqdBI2KGw88UbZ86fF_aV0oyTF3e5HYtNBdY_SfbmBlZ821PE6D5AGVeUnibX5cG2wHCZANUw997rifBd5XZEMYJFUMtkjPuZXQ_YTU3..v1aghnqdcZExPu5ycQdRQdeaHWMY9jI.S5Oi0Uqh6lZF_o7XVWR5dUKH0_11vnOJB2qNhkIPfxJnTGGr3inoRPu3NNG.ooWPqQQWJxgGQqkCg3QKemnNlJDuclYwAqKRiGfYwd1KpKd6TfmUMmq2cjTWiKxUUdIgfH.Gop82lM9uN1zEC5mGw8SQSvSRed8NJhax.KuLOwXets.iMMF6sNMV51O6BAajBtx8k9PJW6nWjjBH3xG9IqWlb3H4XPAjYiGxoA_pllMObOwxC93LocBouGtHUQW_qrqEYROOWEWm70TSl3m.VNsZlz3nYKdhrBngzJZF7Lu7yjEDR3C059kTvgt3fGFjoFLv_iYpb2MPH_GR4popJwx7gs0h_lL9wOwbBDX2wTFmeHxCOyajU9nEC21SY.OiQBp.w0tgRpb09kRPGk2onpiq8.Wc9rFqyXPX7.ko3Knfx0xQeM37ekQyZQUdJBT2.VPVzY_kvtBrFGlwPeT5LCbjD8KshNILOyUk7pTSJwZSi3emY35zHKQvL3smk29xWtdlhrrJnBGaVBZT1IV8cCmglktc6b.7SrSrcE4cma8ZthWfqLmLt9mFx9u6NIyFi80UbQY8n2McqwARhOkXC5WPPO9U7WkflsQS.mt81AsNCd5v7Plr5QFP8nel0rxwqJ9cy.CJgv2xafZwF7pC7mbal2GRymju2GGKINn8zixRUEZS82NUDqhRAUKjC2_.TvN6UYzt0eLFeVAMldMuW3hzfzAGKxs2ap.5GeOC_SsmdYwxrWkRsWQKQnG5JpAw2iiwx1RGxCK2AqUQSB6LFGiTfmllpXhS9POLLRk3ebJkdWbBGOCPwaiTIoP1HEo.LOFM5SAjZ_EVtiP._dbuMh3fYWRIqe7StY1LKS0P2prl1vvdmixuWlH3kntVWVepgSCRbZTtvvZXn0xRSZrrhhWdWYXnlWJYbvD_VN3Ue1wN4j00MBdhpI1_qUq3rnBlW9lNTNKrDeXxw8Y_ZQz.c_d1rbvAWCmN7r83Dre8jcB8LS24UTCsuufVHXVJJWR.Hgo1alsWPxzYLyiVBMYbRhl1Owoj0_apYoRPWRb2gOHu2BD96fTsd27SnK4x7ZP6K5.ebJ92hdWtsIpQbsZ7zlI_no6IG4tv_vmONpvIhXW_Z4V.47rFECjENNhiRCrAk7oTQBeCqrG0IksIpK8sz5_e.nae.V15aIoGiuoIeRYMcfQEqHopqjhjSqzVTHG4dD9yMu_dq1JcSc3fYjBVJkTfokX.JzZXsKv9jHY9x5NVw4BZ0hryR_HaC4.g97EphPJHAKy8Z1BB9NvWXt9lygX5..UcyZqWyML7GX1Zi72cCY0e5HRc12ai7FZj7IFg.1HTJCVR86WW2QLwfoITaBMBatk2hXavKIwtxzdoZre1S.8ox0jIoAPW6vVOO4hvazFVr0OEHWLiGZOT8xsK84xAoxMm._9Q_jm2tJYOZnA_TBhJyKmEFI5k_aKgFMlMJmUmPSPPfzAd5QvlY2NUNJxB5C3H.RmOrWc9otTW7poDcknldPozoYgV7n6ucCbJZVjSnE5_7.neKMwCXetKClyKCU67JxAcNhzozLXbWLMIyBXOl03Yovoe5c8tbjDnDmr.AE2f5LTSxpLELzyzgVK5THHmEzmUfF1fa5SXQQBq4JMYjkchQ_nxj.uQgfAdeBmZdIZfywBJg8mIJX7kzLTdhHsCTinLCRM74q17ovJiryblBlejIhN5CFKkmcJAvOGD_bUUXGvwtsJIay74sgpCjhVqtl0AkHcD_RJsYmn0U3bvupFnVM2iIWKBP48uEMH7_fpQ1PZ2ZXozr2ajwVXHS21w7iqMvswfpAjIgmpPnYpyXiE6h9gBPBGEeB7Hmgfn12rLbZtTi2QbdeBrOoL03rAj992q.szVCYEnWPZXnwplyHfHgvfm1OMHePw6aWp.hOadXDT7LH5obFBaIVWlTxNvaB4aoaVke.jEjCcW9oR1SwR17gyxgnkjKGIUPZXmhmRswIdFdGmQ9tQ0NX6sLZVJJAf.1QSf1UyGYCcPtSGjdcixbNZ7qycGE.mEoD4wXzlXh9KyMzJ18o95DJ1GcEcZm.E7VDUhK0z5RTUbBcN1Q9PQKslI1PhHzQUOOG0TTb3IIfJ3A_oqehuQ0IxPn0COZQzwiJ.71JR5WGVkyjk25mcZAUy42N7aNCwXtGL3I4Jh9r_RY90Z3LvNliPNMSjqelhH4veRcYXh4qeqHo4XOIRraUlPo9eewBmDI3Ux.0Hn4vuAq7UNjPEI.tEVQ3eisTnijZXl7.AkHvRqbSJko3C9MBp_3yhpEmgY3mRsr586wDfJkJOnBJjTT7x0cRQhTNH823dbe5RKf7hFKi31hOjsG4iCdn5jXfYiZbj2BSyIhGsJxOHv_RrmFhviqHQBLJVpqajSzfh2cF1qlR7gCoD_q5B6AbWxzUuFFzQ.xZhO_ULHoyuJJJUKxdqHLnnJJyi835252CupAtMxA",mdrd: "JeWbNm9npTGZmQMTW8enPmzij.cMY6LBz4Phm692X0I-1732708144-1.2.1.1-RLM2LX5O2Lc4oKd3l6Cl.3Q2NiwvoPmCWTn3EUZoY4VC9_tntieWBmLESZgeXCtXi48WUgQ18nl3_YfDG1VQMUrO7jL0q.ire1d2PbRPwi9Mb3NbhFErGbu8NZ3521kSjA0JPa1AF6MIiuYc_c81GlJIsYle9c6.XGRJD1I7n5nD2amHeWW5pP3xUppL59OkGgnD2IbUmCH0lQLTsDbpXBWenmbU4NM.IB3Oq5kpfwTvfkb72uXo6JAUaMsBuBZJsPua500ljDvtMZF2Sl.rm8XbjsVXwV1CohxbIhsepJSlFcLElLBXeu.E1.cDqcg33_bD0gZ.08zI3HYbmGB6GfmGq6FljIMsClW0UC9tszS6DC_i2zr2i4385pBrUyPUGRwkYb5irJv1Be8ItaogFfD9qkqtbMe9QsyoGbomWD78s18BUCiGPRKYj7SDe5uJa.n_7GU.8kJ7S7uHCVTwU_lvfcw.ZHcQwhoqNbN9FmAHsLJ16HV4dCy_J.yg7lKA7u1rAhd2h..UDGINRLsN6ihvMpU3Sg_w9lZ1.PKpcb3WCNnf4hhah2DlXlwTPF3oLQXOCi0ZfylibZ65ncDvRF85KkYSopwLylJ5VcXIivB9EtUeD9uhsmV.Y7UXYzp5l_V57M7KXDQ0ryIn3S1H4MgiMI66eA4e2f1HN876IM439kCv1ALiDAzaGMjQOtj..1.5VGyCmvlEjUae.z8jMeaPFyMsNEJ5xXP5M81LOrdEzF.KDDfmwt5C6y_K4cj2jK7UpCtXCOuMVJFjFVLGcp61H1Dpn21Z2YfC8qAWCuzZTiZezWVWTAIzcCW8RBAiIU_WdEuYint6Ie2XH3t4Yd5bQMJ2NccaVb499nXVceSqRLFgiFWarIWrBvy2DZB5B_UFMMEeWmrpz6qY2EMYlMPoiccJKGn6dKCZmymL6_P4eo7H305YCddFD.NF0jW_W_X8wrwcPEf1_lMbTbschl5tGoCc5dsEnbudrjrCrB3LNIE43LYmLWlrJB2cSeVfdaDrwbaOHXjnneQpg0x9Q702n38Z7bMIEJfqnpLlF_tnQrD1d0l1.oA2_Hrf2XpZ6eiWLbrYCH4oBW.AhbuYdARJeuCX49JoITfO7VuDQVOQ0DHUCBxZiYqeKXw9db.JNWwUkiCXXV2jZCvK9XjbDzk1nFCl7M4BheBjeYoj2vou_5oG19JreU2CfAiPkO5WmDRfb.SqLPonb.Ij8SJcJRSa2mzHItFUwPPjtC5EvOZvfY2lQ0GR6KjgotV5jfBiDYYEKNogDVEkbsi_7wyYwcY8pCYv.p8l4mI.AG93G8Fg1zh1zrR0X0YxNNN7mbQaaiR.XgltfhkhyF9arP7EJ42vz051KvA6LZW7DauSm_41DQLyL2UIfSUSYdc1JIlwhhiWJgMkQI8BBwkxB1AoBSZmZ.zPriIB10vc8qz_1ca3qTe8W9tlOFfM48s3b6h1xQvC1Uf4erV30E3nXQKE4YNXLK_bqqusF50Z5kFApIsU0uPUw.m_QWNRB4UKn6Ac5cT_pvWFcB7BSIrj5VRhq5DNaxvTR5pHAbcc3tKktH7V3P7i_B4nAjZYnvmM6DBm.QIedNccmaPJfATL5mLwP9LDjt9wFw_hbqowb5c6TbkqaRWzJ5d7hVPxtZ45sPcI7bHzseTREbbKeS8LSmoT7rH0Fl.vImF1Ppb.LywReQpZml7yWUPkMiwk3p2ZugZYoWws9XBxRmNZl2sVQY1itBnKAcU36BYBOy2jFGhX0jzcMpFfnwIBx8HRCZa0FROVAuf33qNKNMsckoiwq.zpVbXAv8vFO8FanStoU0r0tZXfhBA.MC4cJ114y4bw2zgTBG1PTpF6g7.J..AuTazq2d_tAyxz7KyGhV0kydmEh.lJrNPUxbC4uHcMxp4xZKldbejfbYbbg0Kn1ySzs.3Da78Y84TGpmcH7ud1AZsyzsviyW7eZK7Cyf8tDAtXXryC7ytVxJJf5cb53YB_h8kWEQ"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e91e48c3d1791c0';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/publication\/255703431_Artificial_reefs_as_fishery_conservation_tools_Contrasting_roles_of_offshore_structures_between_the_Gulf_of_Mexico_and_the_Southern_California_Bight?__cf_chl_rt_tk=BAA3TFgLHM_Y4xHmjBZIXh8vOj1beBmJroRC7BRk9OI-1732708144-1.0.1.1-horpsOGzi9K94EjiXIpIHNMtBxfdi_ewGGzByGntZwU" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>