CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "philpapers.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e93323d9c1b895f',cH: 'OR5apl6_bF22RN80rTvvVSK1IsCda0StJJAc9UWZMBc-1732721812-1.2.1.1-QE7umRWx4QuqU.lT.X9nmVD5HMBXqsEYWvOY24nW9.INywQ6NlhKdztQe5e0n_8u',cUPMDTk: "\/sep\/al-qudat\/?__cf_chl_tk=_GYvb4rWBR0KFKqtL3ixAmX9Q.BLhW46idyG2P6WopY-1732721812-1.0.1.1-7CfY6oY2DR08KYpZN13ugp4gywEyErJPm3npfjBe.2E",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1732721812',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/sep\/al-qudat\/?__cf_chl_f_tk=_GYvb4rWBR0KFKqtL3ixAmX9Q.BLhW46idyG2P6WopY-1732721812-1.0.1.1-7CfY6oY2DR08KYpZN13ugp4gywEyErJPm3npfjBe.2E",md: "f15uJmKaZGvS426mVcLuAMnTT6xSPnJ.FYzbUdKJDUg-1732721812-1.2.1.1-..H67ow8EML0jnPAfNP4hOnBpHK7CmPgdD2KVNgXWCwGZHmXhMlc01Ua5X9gt907jHyM9edtcDwes44bBzwkZzKj70YvjYzaW.UnuLOkJx84s.m8PI7iI5k490eJkeW9pdpFvCu7b16g75csuI34UJxeJLf4pMy2btHVCUaKrGbYkXyk2XbRewf6tPk7sjcKdrv83DWlgUie6REII1gqYmCz4P6GbKNfN_BZTMs9wYj.dLIb27JMrM4jT0saK6kB3z_aHZaMHsbqbhlnFa6rYFGNt8ctMQ4PKFJXpce_myxCa0Tdc5EZerL3H76LL2KauhPLcABbPPIFx3MgC.jKxFdyH4y6Mo7dSbfFFKsi05fHliXe3TnfpyWD0BdtExGTHbJLtZlvLg7hEhO8.wntAKKX5JK3ekD.clTV1mJzIzYThVwALIoS2KdG29EKd6JhLU4QrLxq5.TkRXBAB9341CVrlXWjBon.iiwl67uKrJY505kv1A5XGwM1iDd0sM8vfVjYhkL1w4YP3fvdpGUbtiqC_QNr71_qg08wLPHu3YYY1xcrWN6WfVgH2Y.hnkJ...o4CSdOcxM0iHw.Nf0m_UBApkwVheBLSuqt5ZAhGDyiA5i2_z0F6JSET3lm8EqIFIVgtdcfWjWjN7RNUj.DmeEFdjyEOwHSdFzhZQ9dke4a7fJS.BXvGG5VgDWKqmIS5cEBUn1vIpGwaBwH0840UM8TORrt.Qg5CY6iFDb1cMDnHfwaOEA0n4gNEKNuj.7OBVm.qOqdySQe7DFUZ...XkZw8SpFd.b16q69AY.bNjz20zFKIwXpgPlUPklFXINwKIN9l7agfTkvnC39fUHw4GHXHwRjIbHM0pz2NDdsPEXSPZSubjgpeyFSIGTkEPSkk4PBmBPq.BT8lPJ3dCStnJs1hk4Sam1mHL4ORVs_xe.yJJ2h5FCdkKlNNwz6PEbzFDlDo7RGSzjLbL_aRAWEq7Vn.xqGZtHH.oDQ_r1Ud4ldjiTJVXAClM8Vc_BbwYTfc1afNRkpUAl.RMeTuAZMwVJkFCgcmqUwSsGKszW6ua7c8tCaLPsfDmZ1ezlHksYs6xvSjSA.iTUfiuRiSynXDF2jW42Qr_BkNuwCfyk76TGK5odK7BmY9PF57N2ohOuGB4I3ehsSlIjDaPYuBxI2VBPE1LsdVqMQ9326OufHbzz77sWXrBQYNX1vwIaYnCFJccf8JOvspdLU5gzxoEicFL2BIZRwOvlH0vtmxSijmIA7DzP0eIGEPbXng5MDVyTTOm2_NU1SrrOzAUKrQNvZk3F3THmEO7jH9mNb2T8WH6Oot15wEMKPOJNrHozu2HSIrvwp__5Nl7bHADfRFQWChQQM.BDmJPq1FixGTC3Kqd_asymkMFgrMh_FUAg7o9mQJUPqfOOBQtIKDb2KDUPZp8RU3XfTohz4nORO3uVHaO0cEM17TYHqOnyAJ.2o4QZ0LT9gUF5OcriEiUZg.U2TlfqZKw6sC61_VMvRBNaBahDG.4dexO1_MTm_mXU2jhnF5.C0TjifS46stEP0Lt8KMiqH8b4bTLvz65m5m57JzVhhpXqC4JIgVaZb9Z055szx3ve1t00n2sWnA3NUHYnpKQPUWXpNFjUARZGm5rT1npRxNV_laoEDp2pCWjduE1K0Ye9jQaeyJewh_cQJE02bvLH47uTZiMhOSdmo3LejZQR3uaH8ph5flUfCvoPbNlsIcCzfHNxg._S7Tuxly_FfIgX1o7T9mwKFYP5NOSlL_iL3HZlADMEhwHPo2meG0C9WiZSVRAI_ZFF12rAbDCXQSK4daaTIeU9gTEFlfbu7qauRaNAymPWMaG9R15JTRPrH_z7Bu.h9d5TrnpvChu5vFvLLSkQBQFhUpup3nPmD7_CJswcJReo9n5ZRNhr..LOPyMKopX7L26gUn9Ef7g9gW3FjaMYNPZI_XfLVoAPs4wvTk5MGZlN6zLPQIQ1adOq84t7YQVLjk1Z0UzGjV2fnH9rC9XFLSVXo2V4MqPgZAQV6zXeRSEvrIgp0ewai0KkwVcDfcAPPVBo9SJUKIBF.2O49m702zfaT6UHfJWtZIExmugJPoARIQk6d8Ox7yxChNRoBDqh4ZeL4gCJoiu6AgfZLttRzFlhvdxA_7rjFWynCzpPVzU9lS1h0bM_wcg2hNj_RA0bMA3o604.evPRF1IeiBBWUEwUtTmFxThl7FTAxQduc3le5xf3uObL6H_18h3H3pdhEfC9EjiIpmAoHhC8EoBzaWldviWiRtdpbJqW9cfl37lkGoSQf4jtVgtmHDNglfRS0.D9R3hCOZg3L04qI80IzdZ4O6bzYrCU3NSQZ_Uz1e.qpKMyIG278CqUakh52XCIwAKwVl1AgoqaXgyI7O9xYrSmJIOlTVfj7w1DpDz4XBI4RAGrPOHYQ7eNSZFw0yZnhYK0KWlYoax1STkQ_uzcOdKjNxoPP5J.z43rxVgQZ.QDO5ytUTn2UmnXO4Q7kV9b8qFF3Lr1riz1i.gww5j6z9PQPMhILmm3PToK4gqxMqcCqpohCHlM_up1f5UJ_OYkNCTddnksNkH3.fXjcHxvYV.uxOu08lbsAEHIGMfzX0wZ7TOeGsDaNNiffWRguA.XwoceJn6NXyWpz7b1PBQVrgSoyo4JbzHysnQTb0dHvsDz.m2hZtT83QvJeut2ci26C6i44XFZKeEjD4Kia6EF7XO9oErg9CuZMrbmo0PS8A.HBPL0JNXZcbVGuTtGV2YzLtL1uVfuAJ4R4eO0ibbH6XN8mHyLeEND8MFJ0wWCqWQ1dV.ra6tVGSON3a0JgjuH2DV814NPgA5h8e4kA68SVlChyJXZ63JGgl2tgcjvMh3qrkE87boGQeBMkv7D1mivy5BM_pfJlJQNJghaiIakz3u0JZI2YaBMTeOc",mdrd: "yMaYYYSPMGrH8hcP4gz9wNaAv7INUQps.VVncgx88cE-1732721812-1.2.1.1-0yxhC_c43pC45zu8JoKHAs.icY7bD6MNXdMC7xM.r1Ncw2ZOvUW5DRfOIP12X_U1kRZjVnkrC4mULY20GpbACXH2_FmXopZT_o8DeOCkFr7jCHMT_akUpKlBrWV3h7PGk7qsanu.nHpflNwNHUb4jVliIIg6ZtQUbMEop9Me8P7gl6YDwP1gNtXYkW5VUgWsjF8Npy_BMUiXRDPh6JAjTUgPuUoI2PS_7EhzB7E_QJZgSR211NxFq4g2afJvOKiWqlkWKcL45sHzN6QmQSAEmBTGilv0FwuhR5UqZ3YYlNzQQis6iGIUyz4LCsKV.n8WlxNi9Jkp4l2PiuybIqKfxxSwc4LDs1MZ_vpntKebUv19XZV9lNxsatw9w1KcFNd0PXQOtgR4eIcwKqk_ZOzgDSOfDje.u9BCv92ysOFfz53Gz5Fbzo6nh9BpBS6iNcVhMOo3dZM4FaJUkXTX_TrXqVlKFXLxau3L5HVZi4UlMd8lXN_cQZJ2delNHhVqsYPic_NwQzaDfl01FXkhbyDeJ2R9I.DxpCx4c0NmZCPwV.LAceeDyMNKwpqaHXWeJ90NLpGPZD1zIC3yPWRm9VsFmKXWEOqsSe56888eFxWPYXuNF9cguXNvJl8j1yu6yOcVLlfQajpX1RZ4dpFVzBByZ2wCKV2sk5LXk23XJqJaznBwQgEFXVplRXSJqaIsWA8qBrdsJbcp3oheNzc2Uq8ylN3o4eCNTHzEUy5UrPXOq6VuYWbwrxoeSBHWNTTjUMDQg3ZdIbb7vzafhtoZPuPKMQPeDbhi3R0stOMzE3ttGfHLCSA3tpiXXz6z1S.LMq9kJXlXlXU6MDWhFppAwdnW3HBxH81WWpsOwZULCx2eZfnybvXMDcxG3NuSV.hZDxl4FEgMGv07iu9DEvB6Qr1v3inCQU2D2ILykBy6dnLE9q6DOkzsXEHtEZ0Dn5_fYWMepBn6tFA0YRVipFlVy7SNv8F7tM9FfpZ245yY8UDoiV1yN39TeU629CpYPdrYhKhiNNdLdfIIDfHBTRKQ5BsK3_KsF5oH.zEYvcpZS7IO54.tofo0MevU0TYp5iyeEVeD4iabf7JGnCCloyvd38nEab7e7qULFyDCb60mH2URET34eCYhzRDG3Lw7Gwobs4xAl_TraEyyIAkhPCM06bEBg_TuwjGj_dDzAD1BvUBKY55mUu0LGhfMgkOPy.rxyw.nVSSpRFqe2STdhnYp_p5u6zFjFlghZeiog0q012VlyUE8w.pofdYoBZ7mPg1x2.q8_4RLNknbyH_dCzycvy7UVWwg69SHYl7QsR7CcELtyBAZT0kMRtriGRN2PMMPFj4NzbjttAS_baAjQM_9ELnFTpQ64q2ce4b9RdSYlkSJcsRgOMIPkbtffVkm_luDo3Qtzh7zPGwgP1JqMFQOB1f2R68XkC7kzIw9K5UC2sCsWkcb0lojk0iI2e9_EhD27615QEgTeZfY9.HeQsw5KEH28RC48AgJFFBvdSEBgEXv7HvIrSzcCfXjqNi3TvkY3zo56PXJ8w1f3Qrp1qx0bPYGMMUu1Tr0ZkCnNRfAjH3GieY3JXsQXKxtrzRvIyz8h6ntzuKf2BAhX4Yjz5G6k3ws6bsJXmEOZpksKKhrVnvBiGpJtZW_E5dKikEs2ZIqolNeyZ.vzav9IX.ijLEMmTY.hrGguofDwfSo9.iIv5ERb6bUN16civLc6K.YY5IEKUSQO8kFHAOdYKlZ9Y73qZTeyV0FZSzlrKBVnkBCljkEF9RFoFGRqTMV6pIz9IHFOdBXPJjAD1LmOvm77DlA9mYHBzQ.dA1hLcXAEXXXRhWrAJDfEHlDNaaazzc9UKdbjeBWsT46HETLtXJgq2Y.8ErcLaORUZ1KS4Xwvq4BJJa.mKbhsU5gDbcOkM4K8V_7aznJln8YNdXeZCAc34bWmvaQR.pYrE9WQifts_UbnT6belTIQDuPHKhsYXEH8e4n03uP"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e93323d9c1b895f';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/sep\/al-qudat\/?__cf_chl_rt_tk=_GYvb4rWBR0KFKqtL3ixAmX9Q.BLhW46idyG2P6WopY-1732721812-1.0.1.1-7CfY6oY2DR08KYpZN13ugp4gywEyErJPm3npfjBe.2E" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>