CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html> <html lang="en" dir="ltr" xmlns:og="http://ogp.me/ns#"> <head profile="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml/vocab"><script type="text/javascript" src="https://web-static.archive.org/_static/js/bundle-playback.js?v=7YQSqjSh" charset="utf-8"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://web-static.archive.org/_static/js/wombat.js?v=txqj7nKC" charset="utf-8"></script> <script>window.RufflePlayer=window.RufflePlayer||{};window.RufflePlayer.config={"autoplay":"on","unmuteOverlay":"hidden"};</script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://web-static.archive.org/_static/js/ruffle/ruffle.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript"> __wm.init("https://web.archive.org/web"); __wm.wombat("https://publicationethics.org/case/there-time-limit-submitting-critique-published-article","20220403045827","https://web.archive.org/","web","https://web-static.archive.org/_static/", "1648961907"); </script> <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="https://web-static.archive.org/_static/css/banner-styles.css?v=p7PEIJWi" /> <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="https://web-static.archive.org/_static/css/iconochive.css?v=3PDvdIFv" />  <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, minimum-scale=1"> <meta charset="utf-8"/> <meta name="google-translate-customization" content="eb72a345cfbd8c11-875276fb43ddba8c-gcbdce10568327e2c-16"></meta> <link rel="shortcut icon" href="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827im_/https://publicationethics.org/sites/all/themes/custom/cope/favicon.ico" type="image/vnd.microsoft.icon"/> <meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=edge,chrome=1"/> <meta name="description" content="A letter to the editor was submitted to a journal with a comment referring to a study published a year previously. The reader raised concerns about the study and interpretation of the results. The edi"/> <meta name="generator" content="Drupal 7 (https://www.drupal.org)"/> <link rel="canonical" href="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/case/there-time-limit-submitting-critique-published-article"/> <link rel="shortlink" href="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/node/53296"/> <meta property="og:site_name" content="COPE: Committee on Publication Ethics"/> <meta property="og:type" content="article"/> <meta property="og:url" content="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/case/there-time-limit-submitting-critique-published-article"/> <meta property="og:title" content="Is there a time limit for submitting a critique of a published article?"/> <meta property="og:description" content="A letter to the editor was submitted to a journal with a comment referring to a study published a year previously. The reader raised concerns about the study and interpretation of the results. The edi"/> <meta property="og:image" content="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827im_/https://publicationethics.org/files/cope-logo-social.jpg"/> <meta property="og:image:alt" content="Logo for COPE: Committee on Publication Ethics"/> <meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"/> <meta name="twitter:site" content="@C0PE"/> <meta name="twitter:creator" content="@C0PE"/> <meta name="twitter:description" content="A letter to the editor was submitted to a journal with a comment referring to a study published a year previously. The reader raised concerns about the study and interpretation of the results. The edi"/> <meta name="twitter:title" content="Is there a time limit for submitting a critique of a published"/> <meta name="twitter:image" content="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827im_/https://publicationethics.org/files/cope-logo-twitter.jpg"/> <meta property="og:locale" content="en_GB"/> <meta name="twitter:image:alt" content="Logo for COPE: Committee on Publication Ethics"/> <title>Is there a time limit for submitting a critique of a published article? | COPE: Committee on Publication Ethics</title> <link type="text/css" rel="stylesheet" href="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827cs_/https://publicationethics.org/files/css/css_lQaZfjVpwP_oGNqdtWCSpJT1EMqXdMiU84ekLLxQnc4.css" media="all"/> <link type="text/css" rel="stylesheet" href="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827cs_/https://publicationethics.org/files/css/css_u6TB3XWLPayXBzwlBUfV3OwtQW4YnXqI2uBEcqBydNs.css" media="all"/> <link type="text/css" rel="stylesheet" href="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827cs_/https://publicationethics.org/files/css/css_hzsrS9IdBPyinsa9F2l378Ecg5k15WN36krwm3N6KaE.css" media="all"/> <link type="text/css" rel="stylesheet" href="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827cs_/https://publicationethics.org/files/css/css_euYCKYbYdCcylNAiMPzIfKW_FRA_HaYCdWsaOUPdfFM.css" media="all"/> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827js_/https://publicationethics.org/files/js/js_zS-CmNFGyegtLYJmqFRpxQvvQrfPIFrOMq_3T3C8sZE.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827js_/https://publicationethics.org/files/js/js_TVTqjz8JHRb2KK9hlzuk0YsjzD013dKyYX_OTz-2VXU.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827js_/https://publicationethics.org/files/js/js_GiaQLCqRe4Vjou6TMlrF9-6J_PCyETNpIyi_xuujkX4.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript"> <![CDATA[//><!]]> </script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827js_/https://publicationethics.org/files/js/js_B3WfR93aABuceE137smkyQ-siUc2Nmq9fL6lqt74Xhk.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript"> <![CDATA[//><!]]> </script>  <script> (function(h,o,t,j,a,r){ h.hj=h.hj||function(){(h.hj.q=h.hj.q||[]).push(arguments)}; h._hjSettings={hjid:207952,hjsv:5}; a=o.getElementsByTagName('head')[0]; r=o.createElement('script');r.async=1; r.src=t+h._hjSettings.hjid+j+h._hjSettings.hjsv; a.appendChild(r); })(window,document,'//web.archive.org/web/20220403045827/https://static.hotjar.com/c/hotjar-','.js?sv='); </script> </head> <body class="html not-front not-logged-in no-sidebars page-node page-node- page-node-53296 node-type-case"> <div id="skip-link"> <a href="#main-content" class="element-invisible element-focusable">Skip to main content</a> </div> <header role="banner" class="header"> <div class="header__row"> <a class="header__logo" href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/" title="Home" rel="home">COPE</a> <input class="header__toggle header__search-toggle" id="header__search-toggle" type="radio" name="header__toggle"/> <label class="header__toggle-btn header__search-toggle-btn" for="header__search-toggle">Show search</label> <input class="header__toggle header__menu-toggle" id="header__menu-toggle" type="radio" name="header__toggle"/> <label class="header__toggle-btn header__menu-toggle-btn" for="header__menu-toggle">Show menu</label> <input class="header__toggle header__close-toggle" id="header__close-toggle" type="radio" name="header__toggle" checked/> <label class="header__toggle-btn header__close-toggle-btn" for="header__close-toggle">Close</label> <div class="header__menu"> <ul class="menu"><li class="first expanded active-trail"><input type="radio" name="cope-menu-expander" id="cope-menu-expander"/><span class="active-trail nolink">Guidance</span><span class="description">Search through our collection of resources which make up all guidance issued by COPE.</span><label for="cope-menu-expander">Expand Guidance sub-menu</label><ul class="menu"><li class="first leaf"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/guidance" title="">Find guidance</a></li> <li class="leaf"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/guidance/Flowcharts" title="">Flowcharts</a></li> <li class="leaf"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/guidance/Guidelines" title="">Guidelines</a></li> <li class="last leaf"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/guidance/Case" title="">Cases</a></li> </ul></li> <li class="expanded"><input type="radio" name="cope-menu-expander" id="cope-menu-expander--2"/><span class="nolink">Member resources</span><span class="description">COPE offers a wide range of member-only benefits and services.</span><label for="cope-menu-expander--2">Expand Member resources sub-menu</label><ul class="menu"><li class="first leaf"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/copeforum">COPE Forum</a></li> <li class="last leaf"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/resources/elearning" title="">eLearning</a></li> </ul></li> <li class="last expanded"><input type="radio" name="cope-menu-expander" id="cope-menu-expander--3"/><span class="nolink">About COPE</span><span class="description">Become a member, find an existing member, or read more about COPE and what we do.</span><label for="cope-menu-expander--3">Expand About COPE sub-menu</label><ul class="menu"><li class="first collapsed"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/about/our-organisation" title="">Our organisation</a></li> <li class="leaf"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/core-practices" title="">Core Practices</a></li> <li class="leaf"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/members" title="">Find a member</a></li> <li class="last leaf"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/become-member">Become a member</a></li> </ul></li> </ul> </div> <ul class="header__user"> <li><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/user/login" class="icon-user">Sign in</a></li> </ul> <form class="header__search" action="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/search" method="get"> <div class="header__search__inner"> <label class="header__search__label" for="header__search__input">Search our website</label> <input class="header__search__input" title="Enter the terms you wish to search for." placeholder="Search our website" type="text" id="header__search__input" name="t" value="" size="15" maxlength="128"> <input class="header__search__submit" type="submit" value="Search" class="form-submit"> </div> </form> </div> </header> <div class="hero hero--space-after"> <div class="hero__row"> <div class="hero__col"> <div class="hero__breadcrumb"> <h2 class="element-invisible">You are here</h2><p class="breadcrumb"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/">Home</a> <a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/resources">Resources</a> <a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/cases">Cases</a></p> </div> <div class="hero__title"> <a id="main-content"></a> <h1 id="page-title">Is there a time limit for submitting a critique of a published article?</h1> </div> <div class="hero__bottom"> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="page-main"> <div class="page-main__row"> <div class="page-main__col"> <main> <section id="content" class="region region-content"> <div id="block-system-main" class="block block-system clearfix"> <div class="content"> <div class="node-case node node-case view-mode-full "> <div class="node-case__left node-case__fields"> <div class="field field--short"> <div class="field-label">Case number:</div> <div class="field-item">22-02</div> </div> </div> <div class="node-case__body"> <div class="sidebar sidebar--offset"> <div class="sidebar__body"> <div class="node-case__fields"> <div class="field field-name-field-anonymised-text-of-the-ca field-type-text-long field-label-above"><div class="field-label">Case text (Anonymised): </div><div class="field-items"><div class="field-item even"><p>A letter to the editor was submitted to a journal with a comment referring to a study published a year previously. The reader raised concerns about the study and interpretation of the results. The editors of the journal examined the peer review comments of the manuscript and found that the aspects in question were missed out. The journal sought expert advice from an independent reviewer who commented that the article's results and conclusion conveyed the wrong message with respect to the study design and interpretation of the results.</p> <p>The editor wrote to the corresponding author of the article asking for clarifications on the concerns raised by the reader and the comments provided by the expert reviewer. The corresponding author replied promptly but provided no explanation. Rather, they referred to the instructions to authors on the journal website which states that comments on published articles must be submitted within three months and will be published alongside a reply from the original author. The journal policy section has a similar statement but without a time period. The corresponding author replied that no concerns or objections should be considered by the journal as the time period for submission of comments had passed.</p> <p>A second letter was sent to the corresponding author, drawing their attention to the fact that it was not just a matter of a concern raised by a reader, but a serious issue with the interpretation of the results which could mislead other researchers. The editor feels the article needs to be corrected, and action must be taken, which may be a correction notice, an erratum, or retraction of the article, depending on the nature and intensity of the error.</p> <p><strong><em>Questions to the Forum</em></strong></p> <ul><li>Is there a time limit for considering critiques/comments by a journal on published research? </li> <li>Is there a time interval after publication for retracting an article or issuing a notice of concern? </li> </ul></div></div></div><div class="field field-name-field-advice field-type-text-long field-label-above"><div class="field-label">Advice: </div><div class="field-items"><div class="field-item even"><p>The Forum noted that it may be appropriate to set a time limit for submission and publication of comments or rejoinder pieces to published articles, but concerns about the integrity and research presented in articles can arise any time, and it is always ethical for journals to investigate them. For example, eventual retraction of the flawed MMR paper by The Lancet took more than 10 years after the original publication. Another journal had a paper retracted 25 years after publication when it became apparent that full informed patient consent was not obtained by the author.</p> <p>This case does not appear to be about comments submitted that will be published alongside a reply from the authors, as indicated in the journal policy, but rather a publication ethics case where there might be reasons to retract the paper. </p> <p>The editor needs to decide if the paper needs to be retracted. Are the concerns raised sufficiently serious to warrant retraction? If the editor thinks the paper should be retracted, they should follow the due process for retracting a paper and begin an investigation. While going through this process, the editor might want to hold off on publishing any letters or commentary on the article. If retracting the article, the journal might wish to refer to the COPE <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/retraction-guidelines">Retraction Guidelines</a>. If an author is obstructive or unresponsive, the journal can still take the appropriate action. </p> <p>The Forum advised that the editor should treat the letter or commentary separate from what they do about the article itself. These are separate processes, although they could be aligned. The commentary could be published before or after the retraction, for example. The COPE Retraction Guidelines state that “If a letter or commentary that has been submitted for publication raises serious concerns about an article, an editor should not wait for a decision on publication of the letter or commentary to consider whether the article may also need to be retracted (or whether an expression of concern is needed).” The Forum suggested contacting the institution and asking them to intervene and investigate the issue. If the article is retracted, the retraction notice should be clear that it is the journal that is retracting the article, and that the authors have been unresponsive. The retraction notice should also summarise any actions taken by the institution if they have responded.</p> <p>The author may argue why the issue was not picked up during the peer review process, but this is irrelevant. The editor can express regret about the failure of the peer review system, but say that action is necessary. Once concerns are raised about a published paper, editors are ethically bound to act on them.<br/> </p> </div></div></div><div class="field field-name-taxonomy-vocabulary-9 field-type-taxonomy-term-reference field-label-above"><div class="field-label">Year: </div><div class="field-items"><div class="field-item even"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/taxonomy/term/4306">2022</a></div></div></div><div class="field field--classifications field--short"><div class="field-label">Core practices:</div><div class="item-list"><ul><li class="first"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/misconduct" title="View all "Allegations of misconduct" content">Allegations of misconduct</a></li> <li class="last"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/postpublication" title="View all "Post-publication discussions and corrections" content">Post-publication discussions and corrections</a></li> </ul></div></div> </div> <aside class="sidebar__aside"> <div class="sidebar__aside__col"> <div class="sidebar__aside__inner"> <div class="contextual-links-region"><h3>Forum webinar</h3><div class="entity entity-bean bean-editable"> <div> <div class="field field-name-field-block-text field-type-text-long field-label-hidden"><div class="field-items"><div class="field-item even"><p>COPE Members:<br/><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/copeforum">Submit your case</a></p> <p>The next Forum will be held in June 2022</p> <p><em>The Forum is open to COPE Members only.</em></p>  </div></div></div> </div> <div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </aside> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </section> </main> </div> </div> </div> <footer class="footer"> <div class="footer__outer"> <div class="footer__row"> <div class="footer__col"> <div class="footer__menu"> <h2>Useful links</h2> <ul class="links menu-site-map"><li class="menu-4141 first"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/become-member" title="">Become a member</a></li> <li class="menu-4140"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/contact-us" title="">Contact Us</a></li> <li class="menu-4137"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/events" title="">Events</a></li> <li class="menu-4139"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/guidance" title="">Guidance</a></li> <li class="menu-4136"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/members" title="">Membership</a></li> <li class="menu-4135 last"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/newsopinion" title="">News & Opinion</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="footer__newsletter"> <section id="newsletter_footer_widget" class="region region-newsletter-footer-widget"> <div id="block-mailchimp-signup-newsletter-signup" class="block block-mailchimp-signup clearfix"> <h2 class="title">Sign up to COPE's latest news</h2> <div class="content"> <form class="mailchimp-signup-subscribe-form drupal-form" action="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/case/there-time-limit-submitting-critique-published-article" method="post" id="mailchimp-signup-subscribe-block-newsletter-signup-form" accept-charset="UTF-8"><div><div class="mailchimp-signup-subscribe-form-description"></div><div id="mailchimp-newsletter-6eb8aec9d3-mergefields" class="mailchimp-newsletter-mergefields"><div class="form-item form-type-textfield form-item-mergevars-EMAIL"> <label class="element-invisible" for="edit-mergevars-email">Email Address <span class="form-required" title="This field is required.">*</span></label> <input placeholder="Your email address" type="text" id="edit-mergevars-email" name="mergevars[EMAIL]" value="" size="25" maxlength="128" class="form-text required"/> </div> </div><input type="hidden" name="form_build_id" value="form-Sg3jVXxqN8tcKtWSRMEp8Uqvpesm1dlC7W0-DNa0yOE"/> <input type="hidden" name="form_id" value="mailchimp_signup_subscribe_block_newsletter_signup_form"/> <div class="form-actions form-wrapper" id="edit-actions"><input type="submit" id="edit-submit" name="op" value="Sign up" class="form-submit"/></div></div></form> </div> </div> </section> </div> </div> <div class="footer__social"> <h2>Connect with COPE</h2> <ul class="share"> <li class="facebook"><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827/https://www.facebook.com/publicationethics" target="_blank">Facebook</a></li> <li class="twitter"><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827/https://twitter.com/C0PE" target="_blank">Twitter</a></li> <li class="linkedin"><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827/https://www.linkedin.com/company/committee-on-publication-ethics" target="_blank">Linkedin</a></li> </ul> </div> </div> <div class="footer__row"> <div class="footer__col--full"> <div class="footer__menu footer__menu--divided"> <ul class="links menu-footer"><li class="menu-15926 first"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/cope-newsletter" title="">COPE Newsletter</a></li> <li class="menu-1698"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/about/governance">Governance</a></li> <li class="menu-1949"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/about/press">Press</a></li> <li class="menu-1946"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/cope-position-statements">COPE position statements</a></li> <li class="menu-9651"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/about/subcommittees">Subcommittees</a></li> <li class="menu-4426"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/about/cope-alumni">Past Council Members</a></li> <li class="menu-1753"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/privacy">Privacy Policy</a></li> <li class="menu-1755"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/termsandconditions">Website Terms and Conditions</a></li> <li class="menu-9671"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/about/trustees-reports-and-financial-statements">Trustees Reports and Financial Statements</a></li> <li class="menu-1697"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/about/history">History of COPE</a></li> <li class="menu-24086 last"><a href="/web/20220403045827/https://publicationethics.org/about/work-with-us">Work with us</a></li> </ul> </div> </div> </div> <div class="footer__copyright-container"> <div class="footer__copyright"> <p>Registered charity No 1123023, Registered in England and Wales, Company No 6389120, Registered office: COPE, New Kings Court, Tollgate, Chandler's Ford, Eastleigh, Hampshire, SO53 3LG, United Kingdom</p> <p>© Committee on Publication Ethics 2022</p> </div> </div> </div> </footer> <script type="text/javascript"> <![CDATA[//><!]]> </script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://web.archive.org/web/20220403045827js_/https://publicationethics.org/files/js/js_Llgek5Zasqh0wiimoKH-uIdmSIEO0i9Cbi7UdXEdRgw.js"></script> </body> </html>