CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "pubs.aeaweb.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '91399e05b81e4422',cH: 'CHz5iZvI7fxsKWX30qor_gq78VlqU7s9fDGna7MLCFc-1739835572-1.2.1.1-JgQu9pPwFxq202z_YwP8anvkyZRBL3_CtEOtx25adNkxFQ_kC_U3JxTfB1xTDILM',cUPMDTk: "\/doi\/10.1257\/pol.20190758?__cf_chl_tk=KomBEROuuOUuSUzMKcxgEPLmdVKLckNeHPCaEFyH6I0-1739835572-1.0.1.1-TAqSwNW3j6KsTor251BGKngKobC.X9Ya9uy.YP2Qpsk",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1739835572',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/doi\/10.1257\/pol.20190758?__cf_chl_f_tk=KomBEROuuOUuSUzMKcxgEPLmdVKLckNeHPCaEFyH6I0-1739835572-1.0.1.1-TAqSwNW3j6KsTor251BGKngKobC.X9Ya9uy.YP2Qpsk",md: "tfUd3toUZsXJoi612jX2kkz3UVDAexRv3BN7jPsNAOI-1739835572-1.2.1.1-CwyfHGluTWl_EmDCh211_kIXi8ESxuVW2.lkU.SPCQF93HTf6RS8SX8QKy_9_CHsw7eEWtWaiWPyNPrU74AS28LxQ4zII7yvu3sLIobAgAivKbklRmafSK0j1mReEh1IVrFMuoQKMjX3tyWbhMyMe7.mBUjEaz88NwEEaF7aVwHacwa_wHd0M8Bg8HJS4KT.tzJ7NIUKLWctVVsmdjMbg8LsbWFxE5xAjFNioxORgJhYHcnPlK_ZGN09LJb7Rfx7hz2_rq8X39lHFK0.c1s3NK4i.3uwbwZUm6Hm2pnyAXUb4D.KOGWHd7cbCD8T1eT6KjlxNfmV.D1dz5nu9c81BrnRQUrybnROB_POUbxIHM2RhtqcLq_mX0nQGjSYpRHhtA0HEIDBtrZK78RBdU.TZfonCVBocg7XeIhSokMWFzQqG1MHPR2b96DaGgWyyDbEDdKZzVH8L8z96wkZYdzRetuVNq4eCn2sF2aNTsaeodDK_epEkc8fUOnu1wsywf5CLikpfiPvcQuHSEXwVMfN3MLSmDl8oPfTkUgno1NFom12ZUxf7uxA9gVyLMmSI5kOYE44nhhbuxqxeu3pWHl4KgygY8vJdUupnB4PmD2M6rhYAHY_f8lH.Bf5eJJfriPme3TLNvTIrP5lSfCKprxiVqRmh34zEKkpX3cDrk1xcOzzd8pXCD0N9WXXBahuXyrI6WXkMkv8eW.0ruMa9Ge99tHYJND.EX0KWxU8fpk_qY8sqsn8f1rU7Q1FWLbiouxF9xbB.C3l8a_1oJM1mSmNMzl127EugCt0qOdKDaGv3jgTAiNh1UedlZsDzniAFmek2X5OdiaZbwje6KTL0RUJ2k2ykweaOJk.tly6NIqIPq98rPF61KCfbrSurFzne9a.JeZxIGgiEGZC6rSBtkN6IXIPe04wPf8AObCSiE8XBPYEyPas9YII9ZZfnUuifB6vFCFMt4k7y9wKupPsHdJSthIe7...uxSG7WyWRb4EedZqgkU11BwZe6o3J9dS9TSSQyshxp.Ug94SF0MP4o.JrwjFLLQfJpQhVzSui39eM7GmbrTrdzcQp346oFEdHNqmRkvAAFggc41nKBwMCHtzxMsU3C0WrnDi4_pC9lk6WwPxEPD0_78Z2M0lX0fmEdbdM8cZPpN_DI8mL91PqZ5niimqsk7TVuDSzXggB4vM0FP8L2eHGJwUvq.ctkodlCOJK6UasZ_5lrHMeB55OxKClR57Mf3BTSJv.mw5rd_LGEm7tLBQr8Tym3LlPiJ7yIoORdsviReZRFJlI9KHamHG.nPKnRNRo1VX8ItAHYHbkcR_gpN4zMHqxWYGLwKN4PufWrnXDjzIQTehOv4aY347Z.zFk3yoi9kc9Yo7WhZULHzmej8ByQdvdPwSmtYUfmClNHBJDhURzwLsLpfCuD4TBLhWl8dRaKqVvlt6Yr2Uo_L7UdLNtJa0zL8CKKSdFykSlAmBJEkRRd0PzTr3oia7B2Mf3y1Zb5abrslRghMxJh6AIe.EwGf74dFqSCCB0pSmzrJMJ9DcsyC..1gFNC6Jt0BAGQPXMT3GR0AK.88pUvlermGZQSEHXKqAWY7y_miyaQwJjuzgEjmPOQPUbBBAHN977_7rIgEc.sAWiZNHiSaZZ8510Am420MbmT3UJAqCsVHoBuRMhuAQUnUV._NRK2LDJMMnlpYq1tR4or0Zv_O45.AJnT7c2I9nEeNRsCVn2E_EvS8ZFLyZBQMotnFU4cVfMXrTprUaJTGA8f5CFSMOP3FPlSMsaX54gcJvHCRN1ReMTpk6zOxy627XCC2NB1VV._4koebj625TvBeP2.y2akMms0rMN_bKcBbpUHFgEsvbCfTUI0Mz5dkNbKKiN1Ic4iD98lkdrW4d3_ok12wD08xLSRya8edh_.KIkA4HrrUSu6F0QnP2t1y9g6Se1tIbK_ce92Nx7c2RltCuRr.upc99VSJ9AwjLzSMeGUzvrIN9gH5dHzFagwuDQMVCeh0wgNDKs5hRVA40_gZLTSd027D9sNZG3QH.NIGhoFpXF.6x3VjwJVQdgCloElVk3CYgnXHRkZLchFmHqkwgMVJhLHlpE7odeKPNASISvy8S0cMVFrKtjI..BfvEh0YVEWb8bPsoS6MIoxCm3JJ97DBddIW7.SISdTErC8mRBjO2MuGcF0aG3MleIYo29AZexUmhd858ViyKM3sW4E.5YZpBJ7ap4yn1tSVQIZCl.JE1.vW2Vf9T0E2H6Han6cwAuFEi1FCrlP5B4UMUiUUGQ34DZXgAaIwOgGPqffc.tDCkwOeyKLoMyuzI1WqeX5AIKmN1yGXGlfv40KOyVz0WjvZd72o5.2LjZ_w9WDulO_VvVRV8qTdo.l20DWzdljqPuJqWapIXFCaBCqE64LZk08PplIN7aP3AFFixfn50TloZJ8_stQ_EP3Rrqh9h2iWBSN9FNBmDpwjduCgYU8eqryMPb8Q28XJZCm550KCbY3EWLmm_fz3F4A2zer_a3ot8An_.luOugL9asvY6tucoRuHP8wdwz1LxDPwX2OjN706k1sPAs.zjGJCOvJNqg8yhFQ",mdrd: "3igsTdi5aFoCBwK227hlpDmf4nYyE_JqxXNfBppgUZs-1739835572-1.2.1.1-baz6Ccfnt_rGHTiTZx3gdGl0eV4HsKG4PQMOF9d3.sjBAHZqzZAy76mBBISERARiu42pv18QhfTa9LNsgKhl.3xHRph04Lxrc8tl8aJcUPhSBWxTL4O5XmDURNXW.OxQ.lv11LGNfphVedO33faGD0zujpxAgXDIkvu7cVYnfN_wviKgVBoMPa0zUNmvF6.OeCNWM4tWS1ulwhvitVCsFytqbiO82tYzm2uSGlizXNpeI9OwGVQ72KqLBvW.agrfWKRn0GPjPDkBRE4tKzYhNcr6ey6zIodQoEscET8jiesQbJgDSNlbNT.MUScFxh8jBM6EuV3whBL0_H0k_k4dIPBzC_tFwwtv64raoi4wM7_ptqJz0T.T.7dFIY6WIRiGRWP4bHKst5lNX61SPyZyfPSwo7uhT9QWLpX9f4vz9zYRq3McA5_wBMIDftnR0Z98I9ZoejjD9mS1bWBBH9wtrcsrJ5rkzDtnTj32.viEHTFBuFMkDvANCXVTw..v_cGeYCiO22X0eF9meyq4vrN.3HbTz0UOCUUiwXorZoOfaFGv5ePfb2bupsn5FO_5dyS.DrAt7iaR5XCiJEtdfhPU8vOHC4O4JgHTS86KWVo.qJ1Iamh3pSojAZz.68cAw9dQdMWxHRPPkVGi9kiEHyYwZrOT916UscgNJcexUDkAQ8bFVW2PNcFB0B8EANqWq6JxLxNLQhG_ez90YpIj95ViDrE7l4Iz8Bx3LfeFQk8LUGDTdk5JfpUer6fynABKdsrTzAuL4UH5lKPADXaljkGQ8cW.zL3Ge2ye9ziFY0Coe1k9OrjGfkzlmI0JWH.chPQSipaCqavIsPpy90I.nWFWG_ReUWELqSz7824nLCYH0BkseCy6Bc0qSf8IItnQhEvaZ6rZxLIAWrPl85JXTmpPcjIfNY33yviY42_X6gSP_9xftsYLS8rmRM4WHJdLJeXFQwPClQ.kDaW5pLcqv5xh4Bd8Js7H.dnPB86FT8pz5HzQyO4sDUPxqWLWzRlFlOvQ5LooJ61extFhn5gfHEtwIi4AsHS9dmMxLM1Q9B9gUNBSYdwqJglS7tvLvtHC.F3MB7hxTBet3eseumLtntaNJIEFKivzBajEDZFGc49zFirPPELQJC6zJtYPOFwFuOlHI7RFn5N5tcpqHVBgZWTnfyJj3_OgyoP7rSAjVP_4p66WP3uc5CyTlPF.SFqGpKuvGE7omF9h54DGFDBKwyGC7_grOAQ3B3vyYmz0H1UJ5B_DNIBUp1729F9n7jBwd0pwyGHb6HueOvz2hBnqsoV5adftJx9KWd08OeJgyzAhL7K39ATvKBT36lUKs17iiL_ytKa3.tWg41pvBrlBEeU4Jpj43ymRSuEQSnxZK4X1mRNIKoOJP1.uGfDcunq.f3q45gqSIYvBKXPj.DoWjkVUDcBxxjnnyx.ky.8hKS9.l8UVNRkZ9yF1sgmQiakAP.9S81HNd8UQZVReu9BsDeYsiTjXMOf_kMoU7pM8Jym3yrRl8uRMjFbQSs_Dxw39KJ8kVhM3G8RPwPQ8lRAOyZYDHF2hjKuqj.lKZ_1.ZhIik6gGF4dNRE5rTqDC_zF3fMnWCT4FmGp3j0paHIMFUvsSp2Ru7XRXwc3_jCRiCZclfwP1N0J0dNn_ekLG18Q_vN6ku8CV4cr2R.TVYoTDFMKC38uTBMZ6Abc13HrJkzyUwJXV6wTsDHu4fmEq1RGk.KBtnBA4_cVb4J54bNHc0Ncng4N9hrke7FUUAMny5tP.GWXSlS4JqDyUbTn2FfaFb_oAw9cF_PNON5l5JeoHTypi2SYtCec.VMbna8O6Ww3EzHKyEZEW8JsykfS2QHZTThaTVGaxkNNh06c2T7yUsjqvreMmKUvt_DihYUvi470vgB4lbhVyymgntaKX0b6GBXfD6P.FTDnnX8N86z1taiPVipcGmraPos0M50vpzE6CCUsAetluHet7051kHNazrcw8"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=91399e05b81e4422';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/doi\/10.1257\/pol.20190758?__cf_chl_rt_tk=KomBEROuuOUuSUzMKcxgEPLmdVKLckNeHPCaEFyH6I0-1739835572-1.0.1.1-TAqSwNW3j6KsTor251BGKngKobC.X9Ya9uy.YP2Qpsk" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>