CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="120"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "publications.waset.org",cType: 'non-interactive',cRay: '9134ee669a6bf938',cH: 'tsdVwdJ9dsINiqshw21Vjgl8bht5pj6lrDlrgNgzyG4-1739786435-1.2.1.1-SPMIE_x8KSktdZuFWzKQOB9sIWQlJ_CfNM1H4Gmdo_8e.LmMqL5nF4FDxEWtS7QT',cUPMDTk: "\/abstracts\/163048\/music-education-for-blacks-africans-in-apartheid-and-post-apartheid-south-africa?__cf_chl_tk=gMzUSrgAovycfMLIp12rNSkRC86cqrSoRoi_5HxX.So-1739786435-1.0.1.1-dt1lsZzzAOZMB1lLf5efO9biC00JOzvngySmyg1nShI",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1739786435',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '120000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/abstracts\/163048\/music-education-for-blacks-africans-in-apartheid-and-post-apartheid-south-africa?__cf_chl_f_tk=gMzUSrgAovycfMLIp12rNSkRC86cqrSoRoi_5HxX.So-1739786435-1.0.1.1-dt1lsZzzAOZMB1lLf5efO9biC00JOzvngySmyg1nShI",md: "4syUJK9RZ5YkttXreBSkNOoTsfE_QNWEEuLzzF1eP7Y-1739786435-1.2.1.1-ilr79neo4O1ay6IGGGnA.75.fjGaHtPvkNhhZuH_DRjk3DfYaSyYpnwhhsPOhXgYUfD_vNGA_TFzFrl2Y_37pO7WesDzEVcaaeYD.ulmr_OxsgUB5W3nc8jjcD3xr1D4WbPGzucKh4ENRC3YhMYjvNpjG1eXjeqO50xin1XKuubwWtuBf1x1NlUYVhddVWHoaVWTzJQeiTlTmmIwobrdRKCEoiBCE8a6j4ldrRD6wvJ8I49WC.UydcIX.eU_QmGUidF84M2E.lIHVitU5JyOQMioD4HCXuFfeCuDRgfY7Ev39jPYriVbrQRfWbRihFbzDjy1YtGQNkRgW.13G8xAkvKNHAeUDB_H5DQYGxq2VhvDYkr39qE444ySFxgEq8J7_h_mBztbz7WpagJuUzMSdR6xRGQ59JDmYEUiSC.F1qunBuYHVQ_SyPfaoMbGM3m2AKDySIIBQIjKCpDUtGKNnMkY_FTZGyAqv55Ig.XFQdROhz8c1bOn_fPTCkb1D6nq0lKOH9EXvcdSdlIXNZqhWAuLluJY2Wo9a4RrFb8B3evQCkhSxBAWNXsBYpdndNkkCA1a8KUT46lTRniGWr2CtBOm6A0rgLmmbEbl0kTYDrewYSdQMVUGocQRx_08Y.L165IAgJ_yuLBE3JX5PbHGyvqd8p7oH_5uVsBYbIhnNYVApx5GZhuFGAMHTm_9Wey5Psufyw9ju3mMWsDdKtBygGMtunT9qVllpTLa7tRP1IdiuEZY7dOPRfBv.VIMNYJ_ECiDZGYRONEfXdz9DBOrKoolaGPOR3G3TuR0mj6AHFpMsc_aVDhDFPmDKU1.dcqt00TbXjYHyJSgcUfY00sCL39k.zqWKo3rQfaU0yF.cHAgmF1IuiIDwCJMOITtdradpT.rJILoOiIDGelZPuNfMO_852uyHfG5UgU8Rb7qz7jH4kk.7kpt9QfKUv4a15hc3klOAN3jjmvpqT6ocC5d.MBIXDc6gG307RLPcHv0cdQ6NGDkNokDZE9mP3vZz333lk74KaiynCK.QOqCjpIPpIpdhWRgRB1Ul9CF.G0k1JDW7rw.6Esx7tQUHeT2y.uAHeA_ype8iMc3.oZqYBiVFqqwT9uEgAARZqvLPzZZX.5ZRdBbu_wfGNqBzU5D2E2ksxdF.kVIVWwU4toQjcvSQJk37u60dKbyWXUdXOGxwjXKtKfr5RAtYoh50wzQjD7tUV7WcSDMQ3YAaVFsvm6SEb2Yfe6l4tGKyIQ9.dKwgc84L9wwfhh7PJiS7uxSPYG_7f3u8X_QcU4XldbYlzS.T15or54Q4gjpl1mG9rPmYh2dFpH97xSya.bKL9oB3xdIv2jfe2QaBym9Xt9vJNszgG5rst86w.t_nR5.PsJJre4noWnJn7ccjE4yLjSkEBn48lkC4y5F4J32xh1v_kw8ZUjZdEwgMkV1AmXUlrUzFfxWp1g0jQpvEl3QDNUJTgI4VqKsmIFsUv_31_BXQk3vNfMAmXL33jn61Nr0KJAzQWbLBCy4IzLN7PIyaLSCYVT9_GFjCVxuCDkb4sV2KdIBmg9f7DH96quxZIxAWU27x9HJpln7OqMnhLl.i0DvnSttiRX0vFHwx8hXvXoUxvujngThsUJiXoBou9OiAAu0y2HTtxssxPmYHP9b9us_U8xW.4SykcN4ySlZLHHiYOds8BVYkNSz7t0lm8i9dxj5wbQG9aMO_faodqR5nRJRec68iVgldf01Qo_PU1ckyOGyhVlAf0rtKyFpLdiA2Ygal85yVXa_uBUSQac4kYX0vCIcTpkw76XX7v9jfqhJKcywOmf8bYEzaeRrI_8kgO2IADS_Qv8wFvW9JRB5KpDOGXfVZwhzOnrW9kKGAU1ATsKZCnOkVjiCa5MKM5pnL2N9I1yCiLHk_aWu1jtbl7c0XkbLRHIxJgbBuDjReBM73fGfSmobbCFGpq1nMPi5OSg2Gvu.bEL9vvfXuBw6qpo3B8cSJb.jQySyBfu7_S6dg7amLEC7Y5QV5LWfCnoiHlwYIOma43QVz0Gn8S1b9r3pGqh7HhvwxFXC2BgHwa3qiEPSae9VNctkgfHvX2SNTSQPdIFOR3GtpI5dDPyzYTWvR0W9sHnHfljlr6jadFLIyqcNLg",mdrd: "ctiXWafZDRM08.2chej7bgOZsUG2uN1.XyEr7tIylh8-1739786435-1.2.1.1-_Ru7g0mYU9qb28OyV8OyFd6_GzndgB_Xnob0pIP9BbPjz2MqRYbdkJZSKLHKxOWjqbRCfxmvJAWque0Q2NR8QHNS2tIKk..UW2DlYWauRfGUHzvjW3T6fp8v5xnxe1147Fn6KfOesND3eUlz2nJ_6tO1tPBSKua_EUkG4Su1w8akxl0I5Ysuf2P3WXlMn1K8efw_nni1n.5h6iDxXwdsqPIKD8GOYUb7vSl378jYmf6vuafzgZxxs8yq1O3rBIrgwjICJuIQm2eSC.0P_LQ0dJFMUnSC4VPWQBrbhxde.pFjjNVK1uyUN7qZR.Xp3DHj2sRLc_RvZv1zf84v14JSjKcNnlbF9RLsAIb5RzePGYotHdXpW4NafTCPjQgDwRBrXjmXWlE2DtCdTnMJgUFjSBPfuOlSswEIzfBcczeFPKiesUwspBqA_AQDEeEJERw055TOQSf1hDLGEtHz_RXdbV4GFAGrRyx9lr4ZW0owTVY0pvau9.DfsejZa6FB.O4Gvq3F6TARxIPvb.dSrxTtst.UabpWCfUCoxe8kSxYz57mlawwmYd2dz.UdmNfv0L10Es4cVNrQrxhNjmj7e547CUOuBvYnWvmfWHQ4Vylt87SS8il_Bj6LVUoB2lMkDW2wyqkBLuoiDBhJ_kdHYi.ZhjQ1VzpBNIcCEyw11HQrlivJXBTDe9ppwTq12mWSspZemlU0TTKsoVY7kmnSlmC_aRSvlt9YDSzwdgwuEU5LMo8C0Td648r1P7KDasy_MIiCTyNDtchRs41ywLK00ensT7WZPt9kEpYvDUYAOnGem83fURpd731vbWH6ad5jCmOqLVyUbd5N7VzQoKyQ6jwNNGfZSmq5EHP06tFasGCIHr4mS7hITUnwK5ioHvKNZaCipHPbXfGt3DJqCmjkfnmf8DfAIaF1_y9CGgfxgqHMEvsdna7h5vJkVNSIznXs5kj.1.57mRd4vrnmAbzWUq8kWmZcSw9mvEeyhnFexHS8Do2LMhBMsWHgsNBwMvOk0Xk.P7erUeEd932w14gxJ5FV01fKgpvM19JUY.uTdiD7H_Ga_4tXtW47wJAV2cZm1XvOX_iVdctqk4F8yfT3djpfHF7kBiv2x0OkbuDX3dOrRPYYQ.tck.Fg_auwJYYSMhPS8taHd4WopDi.edDJrX7RiPC6tE.8agox63CHo3ZjaCEpXGMhZB4pTk_r.oyPE2AMwhSz3LSNUMPgBV45pFNQbBIY9pdA35AZTwibW5OIp.aaCmOYobdQCqKqIb3DMlv4.CIU34k0WPlOjTmGPRmhi2wayocC1zHsnQBnPvINT0NC8QWSOR.FRH9K_PqOZxelRqUX2a5L3ob1s8jB_FBFkwuJBUI_46cyebi2eBxI9wQ0JvdZq2WaA7g8EmnXmpkwlIAO9CiA6HxK28ewkrIE01S_3TxBIO3OnIChlmTXt4dqW0BTo.cdi33nhgP3rx0EVSX3cc.vDL3nRoCFGluE62oaLiAj.3gDmZ0n6hFJYkrq_keCFhNC1pnNTS0TXVBCfblmYEeLsXlvv.Jgkf8VrbPpOK6.sBM1ac39TbAUZm8vGm7.Q4mAwzg4OfcbGD7II9Kr67DBC1Al3E58Dp..SfZE3mCGEeBBmLrx6ns_hVu1w9hViyugYECMWaZjyiGe_NgoHHppR1ngrpDFDyiuBuKVAaICzFW29BxCQ2IMYmvnE3e8XnrsKHcGIhno10qtaXeUmHmVmFwKUrqlQDB47B8igWQYAWQrYHuA.c1Eo9NtOgzEHdFluNU3_e9QeUCBUuvcgFycxIBdNO0DfJkKVPeGv_8GoNfIjh.THi2Atj6uUdBXr9O7w2a_Ivtw6kK_N6YGw3_Mv9rghTIUL.lRDW.GklK8fmk9IF_5XvaKO.ZmM_x_7AjZHaC9dT1gX5kJnEB1xMKXrirZeBNcsFelrzOl2GHXSRTjJkEdE5HHV_DjK3iXUwzYMOO2EkwPs7D"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=9134ee669a6bf938';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/abstracts\/163048\/music-education-for-blacks-africans-in-apartheid-and-post-apartheid-south-africa?__cf_chl_rt_tk=gMzUSrgAovycfMLIp12rNSkRC86cqrSoRoi_5HxX.So-1739786435-1.0.1.1-dt1lsZzzAOZMB1lLf5efO9biC00JOzvngySmyg1nShI" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>