Case-law - EUR-Lex

<!DOCTYPE html> <html lang="en" class="no-js" xml:lang="en" > <head> <meta charset="utf-8"> <meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=edge"/> <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1"> <script type="text/javascript" src="/eurlex-frontoffice/ruxitagentjs_ICANVfgqrux_10289240325103055.js" data-dtconfig="app=47d4c64c3b67ec69|cuc=m097nmfl|agentId=7a9804ea9c6736aa|mel=100000|mb=null|featureHash=ICANVfgqrux|dpvc=1|iub=null|lastModification=1732292563811|tp=500,50,0|rdnt=1|uxrgce=1|agentUri=/eurlex-frontoffice/ruxitagentjs_ICANVfgqrux_10289240325103055.js|reportUrl=/eurlex-frontoffice/rb_39a3e95b-5423-482c-879b-99ef235dffeb|rid=RID_-1161314394|rpid=-410541375|domain=europa.eu"></script><script type="text/javascript" src="./../../revamp/components/vendor/modernizr/modernizr.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <title>Case-law - EUR-Lex</title> <meta name="description" content="Case-law of the Court of Justice of the European Union, in particular judgments, orders and opinions, plus views of Advocates-General"/> <meta name="WT.cg_n" content="EU case law"/><meta name="WT.cg_s" content="EU case law"/><meta name="WT.z_usr_lan" content="en"/><meta name="WT.seg_1" content="Unregistered"/> <meta name="google-site-verification" content="hl-zFNRVYTzOJ4xGdc2Wl9h6Ezs9rbbdMgFYLFvx6cA"/> <meta name="msvalidate.01" content="6F74BA769F6140EC354DF6BE33F86005"/> <meta name="format-detection" content="telephone=no"/> <meta name="war-version" content="2.16.2"/> <meta name="fo-db-version" content="2.16.0"/> <meta name="sl-api-version" content="3.9.1/IDOL"/> <meta name="app-relative-path" content="./../../"/> <link rel="stylesheet" media="all" href="./../../revamp/components/vendor/bootstrap/dist/css/bootstrap.css?v=2.16.2"> <link rel="stylesheet" media="all" href="./../../revamp/components/vendor/font-awesome/css/font-awesome.min.css?v=2.16.2"> <link rel="stylesheet" media="all" href="./../../revamp/components/vendor/roboto/roboto.css?v=2.16.2"> <link rel="stylesheet" media="all" href="./../../revamp/css/eurlex.css?v=2.16.2"> <link rel="stylesheet" media="all" href="./../../revamp/css/eurlex-dev.css?v=2.16.2"> <link rel="stylesheet" media="all" href="./../../css/eurlex-xml-editorial-content.css?t=1732118582000"> <link rel="stylesheet" media="print" href="./../../css/eurlex-print.css?t=1732118582000"> <script>(function(w,d,u){w.readyQ=[];w.bindReadyQ=[];function p(x,y){if(x=="ready"){w.bindReadyQ.push(y);}else{w.readyQ.push(x);}};var a={ready:p,bind:p};w.$=w.jQuery=function(f){if(f===d||f===u){return a}else{p(f)}}})(window,document)</script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../dynamic-js/labels_en.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../dynamic-js/WT_labels_en.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../dynamic-js/config.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../dynamic-js/const.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../dynamic-js/paths.js?requestURL=%2Fcollection%2Feu-law%2Feu-case-law.html"></script> <script type="text/javascript"> var legislativeUrl = 'http://old.eur-lex.europa.eu/en/techleg/index.htm'; var eurovocUrl = 'http://eurovoc.europa.eu/drupal/'; var interStyleGuideUrl = 'http://publications.europa.eu/code/en/en-000100.htm'; var sessionExpired = false; var pageUrl = ''; var queryString = ''; var sessionTimeout = '900000'; </script>  <link rel="shortcut icon" href="./../../images/eurlex.ico"/> <link rel="canonical" href="https://eur-lex.europa.eu/collection/eu-law/eu-case-law.html"/> <link rel="stylesheet" media="all" href="./../../revamp/css/custom-infinite-scroll.css?v=2.16.2"> <link rel="stylesheet" media="all" href="./../../revamp/components/vendor/ec/eu-preset-v4.1.1/styles/ecl-eu.css?v=2.16.2"> <link rel="stylesheet" media="all" href="./../../revamp/css/eurlex-ec.css?v=2.16.2"> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../js/survey/survey.js?v=2.16.2"></script> </head> <body > <script type="application/json">{ "utility": "cck", "url": "https://eur-lex.europa.eu/content/legal-notice/legal-notice.html?locale=en#5.%20Cookies%20notice" }</script> <input type="hidden" id="piwikProSiteID" value="0b5594a8-b9c8-4cd6-aa25-5c578dcf91df"> <input type="hidden" id="piwikProSummariesSiteID" value="46acaa7c-2394-428f-b054-103dec22b689"> <script type="text/javascript"> document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function () { (function(window, document, dataLayerName, id) { window[dataLayerName]=window[dataLayerName]||[],window[dataLayerName].push({start:(new Date).getTime(),event:"stg.start"});var scripts=document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0],tags=document.createElement('script'); function stgCreateCookie(a,b,c){var d="";if(c){var e=new Date;e.setTime(e.getTime()+24*c*60*60*1e3),d="; expires="+e.toUTCString();f="; SameSite=Strict"}document.cookie=a+"="+b+d+f+"; path=/"} var isStgDebug=(window.location.href.match("stg_debug")||document.cookie.match("stg_debug"))&&!window.location.href.match("stg_disable_debug");stgCreateCookie("stg_debug",isStgDebug?1:"",isStgDebug?14:-1); var qP=[];dataLayerName!=="dataLayer"&&qP.push("data_layer_name="+dataLayerName),isStgDebug&&qP.push("stg_debug");var qPString=qP.length>0?("?"+qP.join("&")):""; tags.async=!0,tags.src="https://analytics.webanalytics.op.europa.eu/containers/"+id+".js"+qPString,scripts.parentNode.insertBefore(tags,scripts); !function(a,n,i){a[n]=a[n]||{};for(var c=0;c<i.length;c++)!function(i){a[n][i]=a[n][i]||{},a[n][i].api=a[n][i].api||function(){var a=[].slice.call(arguments,0);"string"==typeof a[0]&&window[dataLayerName].push({event:n+"."+i+":"+a[0],parameters:[].slice.call(arguments,1)})}}(i[c])}(window,"ppms",["tm","cm"]); })(window, document, 'dataLayer','0b5594a8-b9c8-4cd6-aa25-5c578dcf91df'); }, { once: true }); </script><noscript><iframe title="piwikPro0b5594a8-b9c8-4cd6-aa25-5c578dcf91df" src="https://analytics.webanalytics.op.europa.eu/containers/0b5594a8-b9c8-4cd6-aa25-5c578dcf91df/noscript.html" height="0" width="0" style="display:none;visibility:hidden"></iframe></noscript>  <div class="modal fade EurlexModal" id="myModal" tabindex="-1" role="dialog" aria-labelledby="DemoModal02Title"> <div class="modal-dialog modal-lg" role="document"> <div class="modal-content"> <div class="modal-header"> <button type="button" class="close" data-dismiss="modal" aria-label="Close"><span aria-hidden="true">×</span></button> <div class="modal-title" role="heading" aria-level="1" id="DemoModal02Title"></div> </div> <div class="modal-body"> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="Wrapper clearfix"> <a class="sr-only sr-only-focusable SkipLink" href="#MainContent">Skip to main content</a> <div> <header id="op-header" class="ecl-site-header header-refinement box-shadow-removal" data-ecl-auto-init="SiteHeader"> <div class="ecl-site-header__background"> <div class="ecl-site-header__header"> <div class="ecl-site-header__container ecl-container upper-header-border header-width-override"> <div class="ecl-site-header__top" data-ecl-site-header-top> <a id="homepageLogo" href="https://european-union.europa.eu/index_en" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-header__logo-link" ariaLabel="aria-label=European Union"> <picture class="ecl-picture ecl-site-header__picture" title="European Union"> <source srcset="./../../revamp/components/vendor/ec/eu-preset-v4.1.1/images/logo/standard-version/positive/logo-eu--en.svg" media="(min-width: 996px)"> <img class="ecl-site-header__logo-image eu-logo-size" src="./../../revamp/components/vendor/ec/eu-preset-v4.1.1/images/logo/condensed-version/positive/logo-eu--en.svg" alt="European Union flag" /> </picture> </a> <div class="ecl-site-header__action"> <div class="dropdown ecl-site-header__login-container"> <a id="MyEurlex" class="ecl-button ecl-button--tertiary ecl-site-header__login-toggle dropdown-toggle login-lang-text-size" href="#" data-toggle="dropdown" aria-haspopup="true" > <svg class="ecl-icon ecl-icon--s ecl-site-header__icon login-lang-image-size" focusable="false" aria-hidden="false" role="img" "> <use alt="Log in" xlink:href="./../../revamp/components/vendor/ec/eu-preset-v4.1.1/images/icons/svg/all/log-in.svg#log-in"/> <title>Log in</title> </svg> My EUR-Lex </a> <div class="dropdown-menu MyAccount" role="menu" aria-labelledby="MyEurlex"> <li class="dropdown-header visible-xs-block">My EUR-Lex</li> <li> <a href="./../../protected/homepage.html?url=%2Fcollection%2Feu-law%2Feu-case-law.html" ><i class="fa fa-sign-in" aria-hidden="true"></i>Sign in</a> </li> <li><a href="https://ecas.ec.europa.eu/cas/eim/external/register.cgi/"><i class="fa fa-user-plus" aria-hidden="true"></i>Register</a></li> <li role="separator" class="divider"></li> <li> <a href="./../../my-eurlex/my-queries.html#recentQueries" title="My recent searches (0)" id="myRecentQueriesLink" ><i class="fa fa-history" aria-hidden="true"></i>My recent searches (0)</a> </li> </div> </div> <div id="op-header-language" class="ecl-site-header__language"> <a class="ecl-button ecl-button--tertiary ecl-site-header__language-selector login-lang-text-size" href="#" data-ecl-language-selector role="button" aria-label="Change language, current language is English" aria-controls="language-list-overlay"> <span class="ecl-site-header__language-icon"> <svg class="ecl-icon ecl-icon--s ecl-site-header__icon login-lang-image-size" focusable="false" aria-hidden="false" role="img" "> <use xlink:href="./../../revamp/components/vendor/ec/eu-preset-v4.1.1/images/icons/svg/all/global.svg#global"/use> <title>English</title> </svg> </span> English </a> <div class="ecl-site-header__language-container" id="language-list-overlay" hidden data-ecl-language-list-overlay aria-labelledby="ecl-site-header__language-title" role="dialog"> <div class="ecl-site-header__language-header"> <div class="ecl-site-header__language-title" id="ecl-site-header__language-title"> Select your language </div> <button id="languageButtonClose" class="ecl-button ecl-button--tertiary ecl-site-header__language-close ecl-button--icon-only" type="submit" data-ecl-language-list-close><span class="ecl-button__container"> <span class="ecl-button__label" data-ecl-label="true"> <svg class="ecl-icon ecl-icon--s ecl-button__icon lang-panel-close" focusable="false" aria-hidden="true" data-ecl-icon> <use alt="Close button" xlink:href="./../../revamp/components/vendor/ec/eu-preset-v4.1.1/images/icons/svg/all/close-filled.svg#close-filled"/> </svg> </span> </button> </div> <hr class="lang-box-divisor"/> <div class="ecl-site-header__language-content"> <div class="ecl-site-header__language-category" data-ecl-language-list-eu> <div class="ecl-site-header__language-category-title"> Official EU languages: </div> <form id="languageForm" method="get" name="languageForm"> <ul class="ecl-site-header__language-list"> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('bg'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="bg" lang=bg hreflang=bg ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">bg</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">български</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('es'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="es" lang=es hreflang=es ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">es</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Español</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('cs'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="cs" lang=cs hreflang=cs ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">cs</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Čeština</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('da'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="da" lang=da hreflang=da ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">da</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Dansk</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('de'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="de" lang=de hreflang=de ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">de</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Deutsch</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('et'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="et" lang=et hreflang=et ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">et</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Eesti keel</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('el'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="el" lang=el hreflang=el ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">el</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Ελληνικά</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('en'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="en" lang=en hreflang=en ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">en</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">English</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('fr'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="fr" lang=fr hreflang=fr ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">fr</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Français</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('ga'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="ga" lang=ga hreflang=ga ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">ga</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Gaeilge</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('hr'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="hr" lang=hr hreflang=hr ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">hr</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Hrvatski</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('it'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="it" lang=it hreflang=it ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">it</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Italiano</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('lv'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="lv" lang=lv hreflang=lv ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">lv</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Latviešu valoda</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('lt'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="lt" lang=lt hreflang=lt ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">lt</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Lietuvių kalba</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('hu'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="hu" lang=hu hreflang=hu ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">hu</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Magyar</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('mt'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="mt" lang=mt hreflang=mt ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">mt</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Malti</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('nl'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="nl" lang=nl hreflang=nl ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">nl</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Nederlands</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('pl'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="pl" lang=pl hreflang=pl ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">pl</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Polski</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('pt'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="pt" lang=pt hreflang=pt ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">pt</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Português</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('ro'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="ro" lang=ro hreflang=ro ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">ro</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Română</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('sk'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="sk" lang=sk hreflang=sk ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">sk</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Slovenčina</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('sl'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="sl" lang=sl hreflang=sl ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">sl</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Slovenščina</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('fi'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="fi" lang=fi hreflang=fi ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">fi</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Suomi</span></a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-header__language-item"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--no-visited ecl-site-header__language-link" onclick="$('#langToSubmit').val('sv'); $(this).closest('form').submit();" id="sv" lang=sv hreflang=sv ><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-code">sv</span><span class="ecl-site-header__language-link-label">Svenska</span></a> </li> </ul> <input type="hidden" name="locale" id="langToSubmit" value=""> </form> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="ecl-site-header__container ecl-container header-width-override bottom-header-padding"> <div class="container-fluid container-width"> <div class="row"> <div class="col-xs-8 ecl-container-padding-removal"> <div id="small-vertical-blue-divisor-with-label" class="ecl-site-header__site-name site-header eurlex-text-size"> <div> <a href="./../../homepage.html?lang=en" class="header-link" id="authenticationRequiredSignIn" > EUR-Lex </a> </div> <div class="site-name-tagline"> Access to European Union law </div> </div> </div> <div class="experimental-feature-tag"> <div class=" col-xs-4 experimental-feature-wrapper radius5p"> <form id="disableExperimentalFeatures" name="disableExperimentalFeatures" action="./../../experimental-features.html?action=disableExperimentalFeatures" method="post"> <input type="hidden" value="collection/eu-law/eu-case-law.html" name="relativeRequestUrl" /> <input type="hidden" value="" name="queryString" /> <div class="input-group input-group-sm experimental-feature-div-position radius5p"> <span class="input-group-addon FormHelpAddon" id ="helpTooltipEF"> <a href="#" data-toggle="tooltip" data-placement="bottom" aria-description="<a href="https://eur-lex.europa.eu/content/help/eurlex-content/experimental-features.html" target="_blank">More about the experimental features corner</a>" id="expFeatHelp" data-original-title="<a href="https://eur-lex.europa.eu/content/help/eurlex-content/experimental-features.html" target="_blank">More about the experimental features corner</a>"> <i> <svg class="ef-questionmark-icon" focusable="false" aria-hidden="false" role="img" "> <use xlink:href="./../../revamp/components/vendor/ec/eu-preset-v4.1.1/images/icons/svg/all/questionmark.svg#questionmark"/> </svg> </i> <span class="sr-only togglable-screenReader"><a href="https://eur-lex.europa.eu/content/help/eurlex-content/experimental-features.html" target="_blank">More about the experimental features corner</a></span> </a> </span> <span title="Experimental features" aria-label="Experimental features" class="btn btn-sm btn-primary popper experimental-feature-btn radius5p"> <span class="hidden-xs">Experimental features</span> <span class="visible-xs"><i class="fa fa-flask" aria-hidden="true"></i></span> <label class="experimental-feature-switch"> <input type="checkbox" id="ef-checkbox" data-toggle="popover" data-placement="bottom" aria-label="Experimental features" > <span class="slider round"></span> </label> </span> </div> <div> <input type="hidden" name="_csrf" value="e6437227-dd4e-4a45-868f-91828f470431" /> </div></form> <form id="applyExperimentalFeatures" name="applyExperimentalFeatures" action="./../../experimental-features.html?action=applyExperimentalFeatures" method="post"> <input type="hidden" value="collection/eu-law/eu-case-law.html" name="relativeRequestUrl" /> <input type="hidden" value="" name="queryString" /> <div class="exp-feature-float-box popover fade in"> <button type="button" class="close" id="experimental-feature-close" aria-label="Close"><span aria-hidden="true">×</span></button> <div> <h5 class="text-center">Choose the experimental features you want to try</h5> <hr> <div class="homepageMessage experimental-feature-disclaimer hidden-xs"> <p>Do you want to help improving EUR-Lex ? This is a list of experimental features that you can enable. These features are still under development; they are not fully tested, and might reduce EUR-Lex stability. Don't forget to give your feedback!</p> </div> <div id="exp-feautre-js-warning-box" class="alert-danger exp-feature-alert-danger hidden" role="alert"> <span class="fa fa-exclamation-triangle" aria-hidden="true"> </span> Warning! Experimental feature conflicts detected. </div> <div class="experimental-feature-list"> <fieldset> <ul class="browseTree " id="experimental-features-inner-items"> <li> <ul class="browseTree"> <li> <label class=""> <input id="experimentalFeatureCheckbox_EF02" name="selectedExperimentExperimentalFeaturesValues" autocomplete="off" class="exp-feature-child-checkbox" type="checkbox" value="EF02"/><input type="hidden" name="_selectedExperimentExperimentalFeaturesValues" value="on"/> Replacement of CELEX identifiers by short titles - experimental feature. It replaces clickable CELEX identifiers of treaties and case-law by short titles. </label> </li> <li> <label class=""> <input id="experimentalFeatureCheckbox_EF03" name="selectedExperimentExperimentalFeaturesValues" autocomplete="off" class="exp-feature-child-checkbox" type="checkbox" value="EF03"/><input type="hidden" name="_selectedExperimentExperimentalFeaturesValues" value="on"/> Visualisation of document relationships. It displays a dynamic graph with relations between the act and related documents. It is currently only available for legal acts. </label> </li> </ul> </li> <li> <ul class="browseTree"> <li> <label class=""> <input id="experimentalFeatureCheckbox_EF01" name="selectedExperimentExperimentalFeaturesValues" autocomplete="off" class="exp-feature-child-checkbox" type="checkbox" value="EF01"/><input type="hidden" name="_selectedExperimentExperimentalFeaturesValues" value="on"/> Deep linking. It enables links to other legal acts referred to within the documents. It is currently only available for documents smaller than 900 KB. </label> </li> </ul> </li> </ul> </fieldset> </div> <div> <button id="exp-feature-btn-apply" type="submit" class="btn btn-sm btn-primary radius5p"> Apply </button> </div> </div> </div> <div> <input type="hidden" name="_csrf" value="e6437227-dd4e-4a45-868f-91828f470431" /> </div></form> <a href="./../../experimental-features.html?action=confirmFeedback" class="eurlexModal btn btn-primary btn-sm hidden" id="link-give-feedback" ></a> </div> </div> <script type="text/javascript"> $(document).ready(function() { var conflicts = {}; initializeFloatingBox(conflicts,$(document).find('.exp-feature-child-checkbox'),""); var expOriginalTooltip = $('#expFeatHelp').attr('aria-description'); expOriginalTooltip = expOriginalTooltip.replace(/(<([^>]+)>)/ig,''); $('#expFeatHelp').attr('aria-description',expOriginalTooltip); }); </script> </div> <div id="horizontal-blue-divisor" class="row blue-divisor-padding"> <div class="container-fluid lower-header-border blue-horizontal-margin"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </header> <div id="op-header-pdf" class="visible-print-block"> <div class="ecl-site-header__background"> <div class="ecl-site-header__header"> <div class="ecl-site-header__container ecl-container upper-header-border header-width-override pdf-logo-img-container"> <div class="ecl-site-header__top" data-ecl-site-header-top> <img class="ecl-site-footer__logo-image pdf-logo-img" src="./../../images/eu-logo/logo-eu-en-01.jpg" > </div> </div> <div class="ecl-site-header__container ecl-container header-width-override"> <div class="container-fluid container-width elx-container-rows-pdf"> <div class="row elx-container-pdf"> <div class="col-xs-8 ecl-container-padding-removal"> <div class="ecl-site-header__site-name site-header"> <div class="elx-label-pdf"> EUR-Lex </div> <div class="elx-label-text-pdf site-name-tagline"> Access to European Union law </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="row blue-divisor-padding"> <div class="container-fluid lower-header-border lower-header-border-pdf blue-horizontal-margin"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="op-site-subtitle-pdf"> <p class="subtitle-extraction-info-pdf"> This document is an excerpt from the EUR-Lex website </p> <div class="subtitle-url-info-pdf"> </div> </div> </div> <script type="text/javascript"> var home_lang = en; $(document).ready(function(){ svg4everybody({ polyfill: true }); ECL.autoInit(); }); $(document).ready(function(){ $(".ecl-site-header__language-link--active").removeClass("ecl-site-header__language-link--active"); $(home_lang).addClass("ecl-site-header__language-link--active"); }); </script> <div class="left-right-padding"> <div class="row ecl-container ecl-container-padding-removal"> <div class="col-md-8 breadcrumbs-padding"> <div class="SiteBreadcrumb"> <span class="sr-only">You are here</span> <ol class="fa-ul notBootstrapBreadcrumb hidden-xs hidden-sm"> <li><a target="_blank" href="https://europa.eu/european-union/index_en">EUROPA</a></li> <li class="breadcrumbPathItemWithArrow"> <a href="./../../homepage.html" title="EUR-Lex home" ><i class="fa-li fa fa-angle-right"></i>EUR-Lex home</a> </li> <li class="active"><i class="fa-li fa fa-angle-right"></i>EU case-law</li> <li class="active"><i class="fa-li fa fa-angle-right"></i>Case-law </li> </ol> </div> </div> <div class="col-md-4 ShareBar breadcrumbs-padding"> <div class="PageShare"> <ul> <li class="hidden-xs hidden-sm"> <a href="./../../content/help.html" class="PSHelp EurlexTooltip" aria-description = "Help" data-toggle="tooltip" title="Help" data-original-title="Help" ><svg class="ecl-icon ecl-icon--s faq-image-size" focusable="false" aria-hidden="false" role="img"><use xlink:href="./../../revamp/components/vendor/ec/eu-preset-v4.1.1/images/icons/svg/all/faq.svg#faq" /></svg>Help</a> </li> <li class="hidden-xs hidden-sm"> <a href="./../../print-pdf.html?pageTitle=Case-law&currentUrl=%2Fcollection%2Feu-law%2Feu-case-law.html" class="PSPDF EurlexTooltip" title="Export PDF" data-toggle="tooltip" aria-description="Export PDF" data-original-title="Export PDF" > <i class="fa fa-file-pdf-o" aria-hidden="true"></i> Export PDF </a> </li> <li class="hidden-xs hidden-sm"> <button data-target="./../../collection/eu-law/eu-case-law.html?print=true" onclick="window.open('./../../collection/eu-law/eu-case-law.html?print=true','','scrollbars=yes,menubar=no, status=no, directories=no, location=no, resizable=no, width=1024, height=600');return false;" target="_blank" class="PSPrint EurlexTooltip" data-toggle="tooltip" title="Print" aria-description="Print" data-original-title="Print this page"> <i class="fa fa-print" aria-hidden="true"></i> Print </button> </li> <li class="shareApi"> <script type="application/json">{ "service": "share", "counter": false, "css": { "button": "myButton" }, "link": "https://eur-lex.europa.eu/collection/eu-law/eu-case-law.html" }</script> </li> </ul> <script type="text/javascript"> $(document).ready(function () { let observer = new MutationObserver((mutations) => { mutations.forEach((mutation) => { if (!mutation.addedNodes) return for (let i = 0; i < mutation.addedNodes.length; i++) { let node = mutation.addedNodes[i] if( $(node) != undefined && $(node).is("a") && $(node).hasClass("myButton") && $(node).find("i").length===0){ $(node).prepend("<i class='fa fa-share-alt' aria-hidden='true'></i>") observer.disconnect(); } } }) }) const target = $('.PageShare').get(0); observer.observe(target, { subtree: true, childList: true }) }); $(document).ready(function() { // Function to check viewport width and execute code if it drops below 991px function checkWidth() { if ($(window).width() <= 991) { $('a[href="#share"]').html("<i class='fa fa-share-alt' aria-hidden='true'></i>"); } } // Check width on page load checkWidth(); // Check width on window resize $(window).resize(function() { checkWidth(); }); }); </script> </div> </div> </div> <div class="NavSearch"> <div class="row"> <div class="col-xs-2 dropdown EurlexNav"> <button type="button" class="btn btn-primary btn-block" id="EurlexNavBtn" title="EUR-Lex menu" data-toggle="dropdown" aria-haspopup="true" aria-expanded="false" aria-label="Open Navigation Menu"><i class="fa fa-bars" aria-hidden="true"></i><span class="hidden-xs">Menu</span></button><div class="dropdown-menu MegaMenu" aria-labelledby="EurlexNavBtn"> <div class="row"> <div class="col-sm-6 col-md-4"> <nav class="MenuBlock "> <p class="BlockTitle" role="heading">EU law</p> <ul class="MenuList TreeMenu"> <li><a href="#" class="has-arrow" aria-expanded="false" id="treaties" title="Treaties"><i class="fa fa-angle-right" aria-hidden="true"></i>Treaties</a><ul class="collapse"> <li class=""><a href="./../../collection/eu-law/treaties/treaties-force.html" id="treaties-force" title="Treaties currently in force">Treaties currently in force</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../collection/eu-law/treaties/treaties-founding.html" id="treaties-founding" title="Founding treaties">Founding treaties</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../collection/eu-law/treaties/treaties-accession.html" id="treaties-accession" title="Accession Treaties">Accession Treaties</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../collection/eu-law/treaties/treaties-other.html" id="treaties-other" title="Other treaties and protocols">Other treaties and protocols</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../collection/eu-law/treaties/treaties-overview.html" id="treaties-overview" title="Chronological overview">Chronological overview</a></li> </ul> </li> <li class=""><a href="./../../collection/eu-law/legislation/recent.html" class="no-arrow" id="recent" title="Legal acts">Legal acts</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../collection/eu-law/consleg.html" class="no-arrow" id="consolidated-texts" title="Consolidated texts">Consolidated texts</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../collection/eu-law/inter-agree.html" class="no-arrow" id="inter-agree" title="International agreements">International agreements</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../collection/eu-law/pre-acts.html" class="no-arrow" id="working-documents" title="Preparatory documents">Preparatory documents</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../collection/eu-law/efta.html" class="no-arrow" id="efta" title="EFTA (European Free Trade Association) documents">EFTA documents</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../collection/legislative-procedures.html" class="no-arrow" id="procedures" title="Lawmaking procedures and EU Law Tracker">Lawmaking procedures</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../browse/summaries.html" class="no-arrow" id="summary" title="Summaries of EU legislation">Summaries of EU legislation</a></li> <li><a href="#" class="has-arrow" aria-expanded="false" id="institutions-intro" title="Browse by EU institutions"><i class="fa fa-angle-right" aria-hidden="true"></i>Browse by EU institutions</a><ul class="collapse"> <li class=""><a href="./../../browse/institutions/eu-parliament.html" id="eu-parliament" title="European Parliament">European Parliament</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../browse/institutions/eu-council.html" id="European-Council" title="European Council">European Council</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../browse/institutions/council.html" id="Council" title="Council of the European Union">Council of the European Union</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../browse/institutions/eu-commission.html" id="European-Commission" title="European Commission">European Commission</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../browse/institutions/justice.html" id="Court-of-Justice-of-the-European-Union" title="Court of Justice of the European Union">Court of Justice of the European Union</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../browse/institutions/bank.html" id="European-Central-Bank" title="European Central Bank">European Central Bank<i class="fa fa-bar-chart" aria-hidden="true" style="margin-left:5px;"></i></a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../browse/institutions/auditors.html" id="Court-of-Auditors" title="European Court of Auditors">European Court of Auditors</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../browse/institutions/eco-social.html" id="EESC" title="European Economic and Social Committee">European Economic and Social Committee</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../browse/institutions/regions.html" id="Committee-of-Regions" title="European Committee of the Regions">European Committee of the Regions</a></li> </ul> </li> <li class=""><a href="./../../browse/eurovoc.html" class="no-arrow" id="eurovoc" title="Browse by EuroVoc (EU's multilingual and multidisciplinary thesaurus)">Browse by EuroVoc</a></li> </ul> </nav> </div> <div class="col-sm-6 col-md-4"> <nav class="MenuBlock "> <p class="BlockTitle" role="heading">EU case-law</p> <ul class="MenuList"> <li class="Selected"><a href="./../../collection/eu-law/eu-case-law.html" class="no-arrow" id="case-law" title="Case-law">Case-law</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../collection/eu-law/eu-case-law/reports.html" class="no-arrow" id="electronic-report" title="Reports of cases">Reports of cases</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../browse/directories/new-case-law.html" class="no-arrow" id="directory-eu-case-law" title="Directory of case-law">Directory of case-law</a></li> </ul> </nav> </div> <div class="col-sm-6 col-md-4"> <nav class="MenuBlock "> <p class="BlockTitle" role="heading">Official Journal</p> <ul class="MenuList"> <li class=""><a href="./../../oj/direct-access.html" class="no-arrow" id="direct-access" title="Access to the Official Journal">Access to the Official Journal</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../oj/daily-view/L-series/default.html" class="no-arrow" id="L-series" title="Official Journal L series daily view">Official Journal L series daily view</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../oj/daily-view/C-series/default.html" class="no-arrow" id="C-series" title="Official Journal C series daily view">Official Journal C series daily view</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../oj/browse-oj.html" class="no-arrow" id="boj" title="Browse the Official Journal">Browse the Official Journal</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../oj/all/auth-direct-access.html" class="no-arrow" id="auth-direct-access" title="Legally binding printed editions">Legally binding printed editions</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../eu-enlargement/special.html" class="no-arrow" id="se" title="Special edition">Special edition</a></li> </ul> </nav> </div> <div class="col-sm-6 col-md-4 col-break-sm"> <nav class="MenuBlock "> <p class="BlockTitle" role="heading">National law and case-law</p> <ul class="MenuList"> <li class=""><a href="./../../collection/n-law/mne.html" class="no-arrow" id="mne" title="National transposition">National transposition</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../collection/n-law/n-case-law.html" class="no-arrow" id="n-case-law" title="National case-law">National case-law</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../collection/n-law/jure.html" class="no-arrow" id="JURE" title="JURE (Jurisdiction, recognition and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial matters) case-law">JURE case-law</a></li> </ul> </nav> </div> <div class="col-sm-6 col-md-4"> <nav class="MenuBlock "> <p class="BlockTitle" role="heading">Information</p> <ul class="MenuList TreeMenu"> <li class=""><a href="./../../content/news/index.html" class="no-arrow" id="Themes_in_focus" title="Themes in focus">Themes in focus</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../content/development/index.html" class="no-arrow" id="developmentsEUR-Lex" title="EUR-Lex developments">EUR-Lex developments</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../statistics/statistics.html" class="no-arrow" id="statistic" title="Statistics">Statistics</a></li> <li><a href="#" class="has-arrow" aria-expanded="false" id="eli-register-nav" title="ELI (European Legislation Identifier) register"><i class="fa fa-angle-right" aria-hidden="true"></i>ELI register</a><ul class="collapse"> <li class=""><a href="./../../eli-register/about.html" id="about" title="About ELI">About ELI</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../eli-register/technical_information.html" id="technical_information" title="Technical information">Technical information</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../eli-register/implementation.html" id="implementation" title="ELI implementation overview">ELI implementation overview</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../eli-register/resources.html" id="resources" title="Resources for implementing ELI">Resources for implementing ELI</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../eli-register/index.html" id="index" title="ELI highlights">ELI highlights</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../eli-register/testimonials.html" id="testimonials" title="ELI testimonials">ELI testimonials</a></li> <li class=""><a href="./../../eli-register/legis_schema_org.html" id="legis_schema_org" title="Legislation in schema.org">Legislation in schema.org</a></li> </ul> </li> <li class=""><a href="./../../budget/www/index-en.htm" class="no-arrow" id="EU_budget" title="EU budget online">EU budget online</a></li> </ul> </nav> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="col-xs-10"> <div class="EurlexSearch"> <form id="quick-search" name="quick-search" class="DistinctiveForm QSF" action="./../../quick-search-form.html" method="post" onsubmit="showHourglass();" autocomplete="off"> <input id="editscope" type="hidden" name="scope" value="EU_LAW"/> <div class="QuickSearch"> <label for="QuickSearchField"><i class="fa fa-search hidden-xs" aria-hidden="true"></i><span class="sr-only">Quick search</span></label> <textarea id="QuickSearchField" name="text" class="form-control NoBorders AutoGrow typeahead autocompleteField" data-provide="typeahead" placeholder="QUICK SEARCH" aria-describedby="QuickSearchHelp" rows="1" autocomplete="off"></textarea> <button class="btn btn-primary QuickSearchBtn" type="submit" title="Search" aria-label="Search"> <i class="fa fa-search" aria-hidden="true"></i> </button> </div> <div class="DistinctiveFormMessage EurlexTooltip" tabindex="0" data-toggle="tooltip" title="Please clear the other quick search options before using this one"></div> <div> <input type="hidden" name="_csrf" value="e6437227-dd4e-4a45-868f-91828f470431" /> </div></form> <div class="QuickSearchOptions fade sr-only"> <div id="QuickSearchHelp"> <i class="fa fa-info" aria-hidden="true"></i> Use quotation marks to search for an "exact phrase". Append an asterisk (<abbr title='Asterisk'>*</abbr>) to a search term to find variations of it (transp<abbr title='Asterisk'>*</abbr>, 32019R<abbr title='Asterisk'>*</abbr>). Use a question mark (<abbr title='Question mark'>?</abbr>) instead of a single character in your search term to find variations of it (ca<abbr title='Question mark'>?</abbr>e finds case, cane, care). </div> <button id="QuickSearchClose" type="button" class="close" aria-label="Close" onclick="closeQSHelp()"> <i class="fa fa-times" aria-hidden="true"> </i> </button> </div> <div class="QSMore"> <div class="col-xs-4 text-left"> <a href="#" onclick="showQSHelpAlt()" title="Search tips" > <i class="fa fa-info-circle" aria-hidden="true"> </i> Search tips </a> </div> <div class="col-xs-8 text-right"> <span class=" ">Need more search options? Use the</span> <a href="./../../advanced-search-form.html" title="Advanced search" >Advanced search</a> </div> </div> </div> </div> <script type="text/javascript"> $(document).ready(function() { var quickSearchFld = $('#QuickSearchField.autocompleteField'); typeaheadFld(quickSearchFld, "./../../autocomplete.html", true, 'QuickSearch'); }); var quickSearchHelpAlt="Use quotation marks to search for an "exact phrase". Append an asterisk (<abbr title='Asterisk'>*</abbr>) to a search term to find variations of it (transp<abbr title='Asterisk'>*</abbr>, 32019R<abbr title='Asterisk'>*</abbr>). Use a question mark (<abbr title='Question mark'>?</abbr>) instead of a single character in your search term to find variations of it (ca<abbr title='Question mark'>?</abbr>e finds case, cane, care)."; var quickSearchHelp="Use quotation marks to search for an "exact phrase". Append an asterisk (<abbr title='Asterisk'>*</abbr>) to a search term to find variations of it (transp<abbr title='Asterisk'>*</abbr>, 32019R<abbr title='Asterisk'>*</abbr>). Use a question mark (<abbr title='Question mark'>?</abbr>) instead of a single character in your search term to find variations of it (ca<abbr title='Question mark'>?</abbr>e finds case, cane, care)."; </script> </div> </div> </div> <div class="left-right-padding"> <div id="MainContent"> <div class="PageTitle"> <div class="row"> <div class="col-xs-2 col-sm-1 visible-xs-block visible-sm-block"> <button type="button" class="btn btn-default btn-sm btn-block visible-xs-inline visible-sm-inline" data-toggle="offcanvas"> <i class="fa fa-ellipsis-v" aria-hidden="true"></i> </button> </div> <div class="col-xs-8 col-sm-10 visible-xs-block visible-sm-block"></div> <div class="col-xs-2 col-sm-1 col-md-12"> <div class="PageShare pageShareMobile"> <ul> <li class="hidden-xs hidden-sm"> <a href="./../../content/help.html" class="PSHelp EurlexTooltip" aria-description = "Help" data-toggle="tooltip" title="Help" data-original-title="Help" ><svg class="ecl-icon ecl-icon--s faq-image-size" focusable="false" aria-hidden="false" role="img"><use xlink:href="./../../revamp/components/vendor/ec/eu-preset-v4.1.1/images/icons/svg/all/faq.svg#faq" /></svg>Help</a> </li> <li class="hidden-xs hidden-sm"> <a href="./../../print-pdf.html?pageTitle=Case-law&currentUrl=%2Fcollection%2Feu-law%2Feu-case-law.html" class="PSPDF EurlexTooltip" title="Export PDF" data-toggle="tooltip" aria-description="Export PDF" data-original-title="Export PDF" > <i class="fa fa-file-pdf-o" aria-hidden="true"></i> Export PDF </a> </li> <li class="hidden-xs hidden-sm"> <button data-target="./../../collection/eu-law/eu-case-law.html?print=true" onclick="window.open('./../../collection/eu-law/eu-case-law.html?print=true','','scrollbars=yes,menubar=no, status=no, directories=no, location=no, resizable=no, width=1024, height=600');return false;" target="_blank" class="PSPrint EurlexTooltip" data-toggle="tooltip" title="Print" aria-description="Print" data-original-title="Print this page"> <i class="fa fa-print" aria-hidden="true"></i> Print </button> </li> <li class="shareApi"> <script type="application/json">{ "service": "share", "counter": false, "css": { "button": "myButton" }, "link": "https://eur-lex.europa.eu/collection/eu-law/eu-case-law.html" }</script> </li> </ul> <script type="text/javascript"> $(document).ready(function () { let observer = new MutationObserver((mutations) => { mutations.forEach((mutation) => { if (!mutation.addedNodes) return for (let i = 0; i < mutation.addedNodes.length; i++) { let node = mutation.addedNodes[i] if( $(node) != undefined && $(node).is("a") && $(node).hasClass("myButton") && $(node).find("i").length===0){ $(node).prepend("<i class='fa fa-share-alt' aria-hidden='true'></i>") observer.disconnect(); } } }) }) const target = $('.PageShare').get(0); observer.observe(target, { subtree: true, childList: true }) }); $(document).ready(function() { // Function to check viewport width and execute code if it drops below 991px function checkWidth() { if ($(window).width() <= 991) { $('a[href="#share"]').html("<i class='fa fa-share-alt' aria-hidden='true'></i>"); } } // Check width on page load checkWidth(); // Check width on window resize $(window).resize(function() { checkWidth(); }); }); </script> </div> </div> </div>  </div> <div class="row row-offcanvas"> <div class="col-md-3 sidebar-offcanvas"> <nav class="Sidebar"> <ul class="MenuList"> <li class="Selected"><a href="./../../collection/eu-law/eu-case-law.html" title="" id="case-law_menu">Case-law</a></li> <li><a href="./../../collection/eu-law/eu-case-law/reports.html" title="" id="electronic-report_menu">Reports of cases</a></li> <li><a href="./../../browse/directories/new-case-law.html" title="" id="directory-eu-case-law_menu">Directory of case-law</a></li> </ul> <ul class="SidebarTools secondaryMenu"> <li><a href="./../../redirect-advanced-search-form.html?DTS_DOM=EU_LAW&DTS_SUBDOM=EU_CASE_LAW" title="" id="search-case-law_menu"><i class="fa fa-search-plus" aria-hidden="true"></i>Search in case-law</a></li> <li><a href="./../../search.html?type=named&name=collection:eu-law-case-law" title="" id="recent-case-law_menu"><i class="fa fa-clock-o" aria-hidden="true"></i>Recently published</a></li> </ul> </nav> </div> <div class="col-md-9"> <div class="EurlexContent"> <h1 class="SectionTitle"> EU case-law </h1>  <div class="EurlexEditorial"> <p>In this section, you can find case-law of the <a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=LEGISSUM:eu_court_justice">Court of Justice of the European Union</a>, including: </p> <ul> <li> Judgments and orders on: <ul> <li>cases brought by EU institutions, EU Member States, corporate bodies or individuals against an act or failure to act of an EU institution, body, office or agency </li> <li>cases brought against EU Member States for failing to fulfil their obligations under the EU treaties </li> <li>national courts' requests for preliminary rulings on the validity or interpretation of EU law </li> <li>disputes between the EU and its staff.</li> </ul> </li> <li>Opinions and views of Advocates General</li> <li>Opinions of the Court of Justice on draft agreements between the EU and non-EU countries or international organisations. </li> </ul> <p>You will find these documents accompanied by a rich legal analysis and links to related information (e.g. legislation affected or interpreted by a judicial decision, instruments cited in case-law etc.). In most cases, summaries of decisions and references to related academic articles are also available. </p> <br> <p> <button class="btn btn-link ViewMoreInfo collapsed" data-toggle="collapse" data-target="#AdditionalEditorial1" aria-expanded="false" aria-controls="AdditionalEditorial1" onclick="$(this).find('i.fa').toggleClass(['fa-plus-square', 'fa-minus-square']);"> <i class="fa fa-plus-square" aria-hidden="true"></i> <span class="VMIMore">More on case-law</span> <span class="VMILess">Less on case-law</span> </button> </p> <div class="collapse" id="AdditionalEditorial1" aria-expanded="false"> <p>The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) is the EU’s judicial body. It ensures that EU law is uniformly interpreted and applied through its 2 courts: the <a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=LEGISSUM:court_of_justice">Court of Justice</a> and the <a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=LEGISSUM:general_court">General Court</a>. </p> <p>The Court of Justice is mainly responsible for: <ul> <li>References for <a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=LEGISSUM:l14552">preliminary rulings</a> on the interpretation or validity of EU law (<a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:12016E267">Article 267 TFEU</a>) </li> <li><a href="./../../summary/glossary/actions_for_failure_to_fulfil_an_obligation.html">Actions against EU Member States for failing to fulfil their obligations</a>, brought by the Commission or another EU Member State (<a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=LEGISSUM:l14550">infringement proceedings</a>) (<a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:12016E258">Article 258 TFEU</a> and <a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:12016E259">Article 259 TFEU</a>) </li> <li><a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=LEGISSUM:4494242">Actions for annulment</a> (<a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:12016E263">Article 263 TFEU</a>), brought by EU Member States or EU institutions and other EU bodies, to annul acts by the European Parliament, the European Council or the Council with the exception of actions related to Council decisions on State aid, dumping and implementing powers </li> <li>Actions against the European Parliament, the European Council or the Council for failing to act (<a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:12016E265">Article 265 TFEU</a>), brought by EU Member States, EU institutions or other EU bodies, with the exception of actions related to Council decisions on State aid, dumping and implementing powers </li> <li><a href="./../../summary/glossary/appeal.html ">Appeals</a> on a point of law against decisions by the General Court (<a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:12016E256">Article 256 TFEU</a>). </li> </ul> </p> <p>The General Court is mainly responsible at first instance for: <ul> <li>Actions for annulment (<a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:12016E263">Article 263 TFEU</a>) and <a href="./../../summary/glossary/actions_for_failure_to_act.html">actions for failure to act</a> (<a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:12016E265">Article 265 TFEU</a>) by EU institutions and other EU bodies brought by individuals and actions related to Council decisions on to State aid, dumping and implementing powers and actions brought by EU Member States against the Commission </li> <li><a href="./../../summary/glossary/actions_for_failure_to_act.html">Applications for compensation of damages</a> caused by the EU, based on non-contractual liability (<a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A12016E268">Article 268 TFEU</a>) </li> <li>Actions related to disputes between the EU and its staff (<a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A12016E270">Article 270 TFEU</a>) </li> <li>Actions based on an <a href="./../../summary/glossary/arbitration_clause.html">arbitration clause</a> contained in contracts concluded by or on behalf of the EU (<a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A12016E272">Article 272 TFEU</a>) </li> <li>Actions related to intellectual property, brought against the European Union Intellectual Property Office and against the Community Plant Variety Office. </li> </ul> </p> <p><strong>Specialised courts</strong></p> <p>The European Parliament and the Council can create <a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=LEGISSUM:specialised_court">specialised courts (Article 257 TFEU</a>) by using the <a href="./../../legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=LEGISSUM:ordinary_legislative_procedure">ordinary legislative procedure</a>. These courts can rule at first instance in certain matters. </p> <p>The only specialised court to have been created so far is the European Civil Service Tribunal. Established in 2005 to deal with cases between the EU and its civil service, the court was dissolved in 2016 and its competences transferred back to the General Court. </p> </div> <h2>How to search in this section</h2> <p>The left-hand side of this page gives access to several search tools.</p> <ul> <li><strong>Reports of Cases</strong> gives access to a search directly in the official reports by the jurisdictions of the Court of Justice of the European Union. </li> <li>The <strong>Directory of case-law</strong> contains all the documents of this section organised in 9 main domains and several subdomains. </li> <li> <p><strong>Search in case-law</strong> redirects to an advanced search form that offers many options. Searches will be performed only within the remit of the “Case-law” section. </p> <p>On the top of the search form, you have the option to: (i) limit your search to documents published in Court Reports; (ii) include or not case-law summaries in search results. </p> </li> <li>The <strong>Recently published</strong> search gives access to all the documents published in this section in the last 14 days. </li> </ul> <br> <p>You can also search using 4 basic criteria:</p>  </div> <div class="panel-group mutuallyExclusivePanels" id="WDGPanels" role="tablist" aria-multiselectable="true"> <div class="panel panel-default PanelA hidden-print"> <div class="panel-heading" role="tab" id="CLPanelTitle"> <div class="panel-title panel-title-widget"> <button class="collapsed" data-toggle="collapse" data-parent="#WDGPanels" data-target="#CLPanel" aria-expanded="false" aria-controls="CLPanel" onclick="createDocPartCookie(this); return false;"> <i class="fa fa-angle-right" aria-hidden="true"></i> Direct access to case-law </button> </div> </div> <div id="CLPanel" class="panel-collapse collapse" role="tabpanel" aria-labelledby="CLPanelTitle"> <div class="panel-body"> <div class="directAccessEuCaseLawForm"> <form id="searchResultForm" name="searchResultForm" action="./../../collection/eu-law/eu-case-law.html" method="post" onsubmit="showHourglass();"> <div class="row"> <div class="col-sm-3"> <div class="form-group "> <label for="naturalNumberType" class="">Court</label> <select id="naturalNumberType" name="naturalNumberType" class="input-sm form-control NoBorders " aria-label="Court"> <option title="All" value="all">All</option> <option title="Court of Justice" value="naturalNumber.courtOfJustice">Court of Justice</option> <option title="General Court" value="naturalNumber.court">General Court</option> <option title="Civil Service Tribunal" value="naturalNumber.civilServiceTribunal">Civil Service Tribunal</option> </select>  </div> </div> <div class="col-sm-3"> <div class="form-group "> <label for="documentSelect" class="">Document type</label> <select id="documentSelect" name="genericValues[DB_TYPE_OF_ACT]" class="input-sm form-control NoBorders " aria-label="Document type"> <option title="All" value="ALL">All</option> <option title="Advocate General’s opinion" value="advGeneral">Advocate General’s opinion</option> <option title="Attachment order" value="garnisheeOrder">Attachment order</option> <option title="Judgment" value="judgment">Judgment</option> <option title="Judicial information" value="judicialInfo">Judicial information</option> <option title="Opinion" value="opinion">Opinion</option> <option title="Order" value="order">Order</option> <option title="Third-party proceedings" value="thirdParty">Third-party proceedings</option> </select>  </div> </div> <div class="col-sm-3"> <div class="form-group "> <label for="docNum" class="">Case number</label> <input id="docNum" name="number" class="input-sm form-control NoBorders null" aria-invalid="false" value="" size="4" maxlength="4"/>  </div> </div> <div class="col-sm-2"> <div class="form-group "> <label for="docYear" class="">Year</label> <select id="docYear" name="year" class="input-sm form-control NoBorders " aria-label="Year"> <option title="All" value="ALL">All</option> <option title="2024" value="2024" selected="selected">2024</option> <option title="2023" value="2023">2023</option> <option title="2022" value="2022">2022</option> <option title="2021" value="2021">2021</option> <option title="2020" value="2020">2020</option> <option title="2019" value="2019">2019</option> <option title="2018" value="2018">2018</option> <option title="2017" value="2017">2017</option> <option title="2016" value="2016">2016</option> <option title="2015" value="2015">2015</option> <option title="2014" value="2014">2014</option> <option title="2013" value="2013">2013</option> <option title="2012" value="2012">2012</option> <option title="2011" value="2011">2011</option> <option title="2010" value="2010">2010</option> <option title="2009" value="2009">2009</option> <option title="2008" value="2008">2008</option> <option title="2007" value="2007">2007</option> <option title="2006" value="2006">2006</option> <option title="2005" value="2005">2005</option> <option title="2004" value="2004">2004</option> <option title="2003" value="2003">2003</option> <option title="2002" value="2002">2002</option> <option title="2001" value="2001">2001</option> <option title="2000" value="2000">2000</option> <option title="1999" value="1999">1999</option> <option title="1998" value="1998">1998</option> <option title="1997" value="1997">1997</option> <option title="1996" value="1996">1996</option> <option title="1995" value="1995">1995</option> <option title="1994" value="1994">1994</option> <option title="1993" value="1993">1993</option> <option title="1992" value="1992">1992</option> <option title="1991" value="1991">1991</option> <option title="1990" value="1990">1990</option> <option title="1989" value="1989">1989</option> <option title="1988" value="1988">1988</option> <option title="1987" value="1987">1987</option> <option title="1986" value="1986">1986</option> <option title="1985" value="1985">1985</option> <option title="1984" value="1984">1984</option> <option title="1983" value="1983">1983</option> <option title="1982" value="1982">1982</option> <option title="1981" value="1981">1981</option> <option title="1980" value="1980">1980</option> <option title="1979" value="1979">1979</option> <option title="1978" value="1978">1978</option> <option title="1977" value="1977">1977</option> <option title="1976" value="1976">1976</option> <option title="1975" value="1975">1975</option> <option title="1974" value="1974">1974</option> <option title="1973" value="1973">1973</option> </select>  </div> </div> <div class="col-sm-1 caseLawSearchBtnAlignment"> <button class="btn btn-info WidgetSearchBtn" id="directAccessSearchEuCaseLaw" type="submit" aria-label="Search" onclick="addPiwikParamsFromDirectAccessForm();" title="Search" alt="Perform search"><i class="fa fa-search" aria-hidden="true"></i></button> </div> </div> <div> <input type="hidden" name="_csrf" value="e6437227-dd4e-4a45-868f-91828f470431" /> </div></form> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <br/> <script type="text/javascript"> $(document).ready(function(){ loadDocWidgets("CLPanelTitle"); }); </script> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div>  <footer class="ecl-site-footer"> <div class="ecl-container ecl-site-footer__container ecl-site-footer__container-override"> <div class="ecl-site-footer__row"> <div class="ecl-site-footer__column"> <div class="ecl-site-footer__section ecl-site-footer__section--site-info"> <a href="./../../homepage.html" > <picture class="ecl-picture ecl-site-footer__picture" title="Back to EUR-Lex homepage"> <img class="ecl-site-footer__logo-image" src="./../../revamp/images/eurlex_simple.svg" onerror="this.onerror=null; this.src='./../../images/n/eurlex_simple.png'" alt="Back to EUR-Lex homepage" title="Back to EUR-Lex homepage"> </picture> </a> <div class="ecl-site-footer__description">This site is managed by the <a href="http://op.europa.eu/en/home" title="Publications Office of the European Union" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">Publications Office of the European Union</a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="ecl-site-footer__column"> <div class="ecl-site-footer__section"> <h2 class="ecl-site-footer__title ecl-site-footer__title--separator">Need help?</h2> <ul class="ecl-site-footer__list"> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="./../../content/help.html" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link" title="Help pages" > Help pages </a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="./../../contact.html" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link" title="Contact" > Contact </a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="./../../content/site-map/site-map.html" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link" title="Sitemap" > Sitemap </a> </li> </ul> </div> <div class="ecl-site-footer__section"> <h2 class="ecl-site-footer__title ecl-site-footer__title--separator">Follow us</h2> <ul class="ecl-site-footer__list"> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="https://twitter.com/EURLex/" title="X" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-link--icon ecl-site-footer__link"> <img class="ecl-icon ecl-icon--m ecl-link__icon ecl-link--icon--twitter" src="./../../revamp/images/twitter.svg" onerror="this.onerror=null; this.src='./../../images/n/twitter.png'" alt="X" title="X"> <span class="ecl-link__label--twitter">X</span> </a> </li> </ul> </div> <div class="ecl-site-footer__section"> <h2 class="ecl-site-footer__title ecl-site-footer__title--separator">Legal</h2> <ul class="ecl-site-footer__list"> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="./../../content/legal-notice/legal-notice.html" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link" title="Legal notice" > Legal notice </a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="./../../content/legal-notice/legal-notice.html#5.%20Cookies%20notice" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link" title="Cookies policy" > Cookies policy </a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="./../../content/legal-notice/legal-notice.html#4.%20Accessibility%20statement" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link" title="Accessibility" > Accessibility </a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="./../../content/legal-notice/legal-notice.html#3.%20protection" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link" title="Privacy statement" > Privacy statement </a> </li> </ul> </div> </div> <div class="ecl-site-footer__column"> <div class="ecl-site-footer__section"> <h2 class="ecl-site-footer__title ecl-site-footer__title--separator">Information</h2> <ul class="ecl-site-footer__list"> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="./../../content/welcome/about.html" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link" title="About EUR-Lex" > About EUR-Lex </a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="./../../newsletter/newsletterLatest.html" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link" title="Newsletter" > Newsletter </a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="./../../content/links/links.html" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link" title="Useful links" > Useful links </a> </li> </ul> </div> <div class="ecl-site-footer__section"> <h2 class="ecl-site-footer__title ecl-site-footer__title--separator">Other services</h2> <ul class="ecl-site-footer__list"> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="https://data.europa.eu/euodp/en/data/" title="European Data" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link"> European Data </a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="https://ted.europa.eu/TED/main/HomePage.do" title="EU tenders" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link"> EU tenders </a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="http://cordis.europa.eu/en/" title="EU research results" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link"> EU research results </a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="http://op.europa.eu/en/web/who-is-who" title="EU Whoiswho" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link"> EU Whoiswho </a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="http://op.europa.eu/en/web/general-publications/publications" title="EU publications" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link"> EU publications </a> </li> </ul> </div> <div class="ecl-site-footer__section ecl-site-footer__section--separator"> <ul class="ecl-site-footer__list"> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="http://n-lex.europa.eu/n-lex/index?lang=en" title="N-Lex" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link"> N-Lex </a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="http://op.europa.eu/en/web/eu-law-in-force" title="EU Law in Force" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link"> EU Law in Force </a> </li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"> <a href="http://law-tracker.europa.eu/joint-legislative-portal/homepage?lang=en" title="EU Law Tracker" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link"> EU Law Tracker </a> </li> </ul> </div> </div> </div> <div class="ecl-site-footer__row"> <div class="ecl-site-footer__column"> <div class="ecl-site-footer__section"><a href="https://european-union.europa.eu/" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__logo-link" aria-label="European Union"> <picture class="ecl-picture ecl-site-footer__picture" title="European Union"> <source srcset="./../../revamp/images/logo-eu--en.svg" media="(min-width: 996px)"><img class="ecl-site-footer__logo-image" src="./../../revamp/images/logo-eu--en-sm.svg" alt="European Union logo" /> </picture> </a> <div class="ecl-site-footer__description">Discover more on<a href="https://europa.eu" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone"> <u>europa.eu</u></a></div> </div> </div> <div class="ecl-site-footer__column"> <div class="ecl-site-footer__section"> <h2 class="ecl-site-footer__title ecl-site-footer__title--separator">Contact the EU</h2> <ul class="ecl-site-footer__list"> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="tel:0080067891011" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link"> Call us 00 800 6 7 8 9 10 11</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://european-union.europa.eu/contact-eu/call-us_en" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link"> Use other telephone options</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://european-union.europa.eu/contact-eu/write-us_en" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link"> Write to us via our contact form</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://european-union.europa.eu/contact-eu/meet-us_en" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link"> Meet us at one of the EU centres</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="ecl-site-footer__section"> <h2 class="ecl-site-footer__title ecl-site-footer__title--separator">Social media</h2> <ul class="ecl-site-footer__list"> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://european-union.europa.eu/contact-eu/social-media-channels_en#/search" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link"> Search for EU social media channels</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="ecl-site-footer__section"> <h2 class="ecl-site-footer__title ecl-site-footer__title--separator">Legal</h2> <ul class="ecl-site-footer__list"> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://european-union.europa.eu/languages-our-websites_en" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">Languages on our websites</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://european-union.europa.eu/privacy-policy_en" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">Privacy policy</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://european-union.europa.eu/legal-notice_en" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">Legal notice</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://european-union.europa.eu/cookies_en" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">Cookies</a></li> </ul> </div> </div> <div class="ecl-site-footer__column"> <div class="ecl-site-footer__section ecl-site-footer__section"> <h2 class="ecl-site-footer__title ecl-site-footer__title--separator">EU institutions</h2> <ul class="ecl-site-footer__list"> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="http://www.europarl.europa.eu/portal/" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">European Parliament</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="http://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/european-council/" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">European Council</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="http://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/home/" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">Council of the European Union</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://commission.europa.eu/index_en" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">European Commission</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="http://curia.europa.eu/jcms/jcms/j_6/en/" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU)</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://www.ecb.europa.eu/home/html/index.en.html" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">European Central Bank (ECB)</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="http://www.eca.europa.eu/en" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">European Court of Auditors</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://eeas.europa.eu/headquarters/headquarters-homepage_en" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">European External Action Service (EEAS)</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="http://www.eesc.europa.eu/?i=portal.en.home" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">European Economic and Social Committee</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="http://cor.europa.eu/en/" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">European Committee of Regions (CoR)</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://www.eib.org/en/index.htm" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">European Investment Bank</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/home" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">European Ombudsman</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://secure.edps.europa.eu/EDPSWEB/edps/EDPS?lang=en" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS)</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://edpb.europa.eu/edpb_en" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">European Data Protection Board</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://epso.europa.eu/en" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">European Personnel Selection Office</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://op.europa.eu/en/home" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">Publications Office of the European Union</a></li> <li class="ecl-site-footer__list-item"><a href="https://european-union.europa.eu/institutions-law-budget/institutions-and-bodies/institutions-and-bodies-profiles_en?f%5B0%5D=oe_organisation_eu_type%3Ahttp%3A//publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/corporate-body-classification/AGENCY_DEC&f%5B1%5D=oe_organisation_eu_type%3Ahttp%3A//publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/corporate-body-classification/AGENCY_EXEC&f%5B2%5D=oe_organisation_eu_type%3Ahttp%3A//publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/corporate-body-classification/EU_JU" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link">Agencies</a></li> </ul> </div> </div> </div> <a href="#" aria-label="Back to top" class="btn btn-xs btn-primary EurlexTop"><i class="fa fa-arrow-up" aria-hidden="true"></i></a> <div class="panel-footer text-center switchToDesktop"> <ul class="list-unstyled"> <li class="hide" id="switchToMobile"> <a href="#" class="OP-Nlex" onclick="createCookie('desktopModeOn','false','30');window.location.reload(true);" > Switch to mobile <i class="fa fa-mobile" aria-hidden="true"></i> </a> </li> <li class="hide" id="switchToDesktop"> <a href="#" class="ecl-link ecl-link--standalone ecl-site-footer__link" onclick="createCookie('desktopModeOn','true','30');window.location.reload(true);" > Switch to desktop <i class="fa fa-desktop" aria-hidden="true"></i> </a> </li> </ul> </div> </div> </footer> <script type="text/javascript"> $(document).ready(function () { var switchToDesktop = "notSelected"; var deviceDetected = "desktop"; //enable switch to desktop view for mobile devices if (deviceDetected == 'mobile' ){ if ((switchToDesktop == 'false' || switchToDesktop == 'notSelected') && window.innerWidth<992 ){ $("#switchToDesktop").removeClass("hide"); }else if (switchToDesktop == 'true'){ $("#switchToMobile").removeClass("hide"); } } }); </script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../js/jquery.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script>(function($,d){$.each(readyQ,function(i,f){$(f)});$.each(bindReadyQ,function(i,f){$(d).on("ready",f)})})(jQuery,document)</script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../js/eur-lex-sanitizer.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../js/eur-lex.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../js/experimentalFeatures.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../js/machineTranslation.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../revamp/components/vendor/moment/min/moment-with-locales.min.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../revamp/components/vendor/bootstrap/dist/js/bootstrap.min.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../revamp/components/vendor/bootstrap-3-typeahead/js/bootstrap3-typeahead_customized.min.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../revamp/js/ie10-viewport-bug-workaround.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../revamp/js/metisMenu.min.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../revamp/js/timeline.main.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../revamp/js/jquery.autoresize.min.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../revamp/js/eurlex.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../js/compatibility-table.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../revamp/components/vendor/bootstrap/js/transition.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../revamp/components/vendor/bootstrap/js/collapse.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../revamp/components/vendor/gasparesganga-jquery-loading-overlay/src/loadingoverlay.min.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../js/popupWidgetTitle.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../js/piwik_functionality.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script src="https://webtools.europa.eu/load.js?globan=1110" type="text/javascript"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../js/cookieConsentKitUtils.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../js/d3/d3.v7.min.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../js/browse-by-collection.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../js/d3-timeline.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../js/url-dynamic-util.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../js/pdfjs/build/pdf.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../js/pdfjs/build/pdf.worker.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../js/pdf-infinite-scroll.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="./../../revamp/components/vendor/ec/eu-preset-v4.1.1/scripts/ecl-eu.js?v=2.16.2"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://unpkg.com/svg4everybody@2.1.9/dist/svg4everybody.js"></script> </body> </html>

CINXE.COM

Case-law - EUR-Lex