CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "help.foreignpolicy.com",cType: 'managed',cRay: '9148f2e448736b99',cH: 'i22WjKgQEj4wsAuZ3rAvl84FmiP9wERekzeA1KblDEE-1739996334-1.2.1.1-yAcaKeWcOHBi0xVl94AQ3EQ62EBh53GQuTsvZddZqs7jWMVmDgGvIIzU9xRBE8nR',cUPMDTk: "\/hc\/en-us?__cf_chl_tk=rJeHwouqK85eWC7GKN2AUZarxE8go_N7s4jJ00aFR.g-1739996334-1.0.1.1-Bkn6nRllV5LdHdRey_Zkcy1s2M3GBQUeuGE6T.TlGg0",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1739996334',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "unsupported-browser",fa: "\/hc\/en-us?__cf_chl_f_tk=rJeHwouqK85eWC7GKN2AUZarxE8go_N7s4jJ00aFR.g-1739996334-1.0.1.1-Bkn6nRllV5LdHdRey_Zkcy1s2M3GBQUeuGE6T.TlGg0",md: "kign9UIKdA_1wuhh2LmmsKrODKs6OnWrcYCI.LdGFGI-1739996334-1.2.1.1-jOuhdzDoGbC7v2bd9VK58BIp3XTe2n6wViF62mwfErB2i_G_mBkySgdHpHdk2X8WfAYQgPBcscqlb_pvCYM1wV6z7Vy4MFbRCu05nI3CclE5j5hljkPThGShmk6HmDpdtW35T1604vW6bzV5ywU9yIgWO2JrTBNT33YqFNNbu8KGfMmFydu3sII8N1Rn1L.2LV3JRT7ZRGFS8MB1LWCH.gkZIUQqx0HbJlv.jMWhtVDFP2d469G6qAFcKuQcSFkxesgWvmE9nQ4eBcRqql4KvHOnEHyzZxKuzehr7gUVeIFUTiX8YskYqmzJ3zdBEAzau1PUVeeS3KFIpn.q6mxrNag0Spq8K9dXvnO0LZqXuKP.AbBrbTcWTXVcZMeOFKoFG1g.ksk4G8uk1brpujkP3gfKWZ7rxis7lUExQlW39.YRpdl1zVqhj8.6X1eFT4uinfRLN8FIrEZQpY1hYInsIkGhdxsOpDJb0YmyaNbd4z2QAQSCtjkY2TzigJHxIYaQ9npIMPymA9QPT9nZhwUY2U_5StO1KV7A_WkubKz9n1xWcctBR5fZ5TS_kNBAbhNlUrdyFEvmROlxAdVWCe10tcQy4aMRn9ThiA0wYCx3Z9B7D2w1NLPI1vUcTkc3lfnO7oOsLxOQo2YGHGyqTQyNF8qCVugKMYQG4OGzHaB4JU9nCafXwWv9evsY1db1nBSINhNJz0de01mKRkfZMgV0FO3OGQfSRc1Zlthh8F97tEdPRUFOQYSJFzHyLQeP4PmYwk075w1M1ES1sJj8Y.NoKgTXxhkThMs7IFxuQ.T3nyvDWf.yLx_Qi2lpuZyU8MtfY5DZ9tsKvUyqN7Ch81JwWS4AiImeGX8NS5QBwDYhhzEoPJ3lKTiBXr_D1ESoKwC8V1jSkvfJW3M53wqMZrAH4CNA6VJpk3LFUIR9FFjm.VQTDM_kKOD_KmH_LCZwRhbZGIRwd7.66TgEpjE7qZJrWid7SGC7D6p8a4tJeXofXHGC1B4Xy2B8XdsBlyaVyoBt2WFyKhnw0dCqeW4FIpZXcCFsq_sFko47GEoR4q.7eQ_GX_YyRx1yLiM_296k.qqPV8vgyyZ5xb4mHIyCXQKrNlCIVL8rsSp_tE5igEKXIHTLEhP9TXJZY_GTtml9szTjVS7nwTlqexzZQBX3pGYqPHwaEmAjMzoQQeaVDmMeRXYEaLjaNsaBvO6AMFnl0Y_ss53ZSRn91UlU87x4w_6mRRw1MsCBeYx9F3wDjPDOJiwWuq0xZVQHGAx3u4US.UTg7zDoc7tmsYTnp_zwpofcXKJs2yTwOJ3c6n3TwMuUAMCSbANeHj5c99Y8hILsuHU7LpDoPqPBvOVWVKGxeiUXphJ3Wb6PnEQUJd_4UcYv1VvMxVKqTT9avdUar5ZARwyFWGE0uhfR_hVaNcU6_QSO7Ux2D8jl5ZFbkIcEE0rGbhuiMz0mAqlXwi1v8dAkVHWsci1DEbnaMzokgvvhLRl8_3QPE.c5E8gYPX3YYQ.rKgxpqxIG15hIw2np9GxLUq5z0kt7ZB6.GkX5x3NDvBn.12Tf06b1C8oXbr7OL9LCa_NIshTYSOb7Bk7SnV0C2BJKPF9mTqq2G35uUxibKWtp4n3yXCAgdVsRQbpKiGl53_G8EFk_HoxeZ3a6cHWR3hmNhXrsRjNkgIznOlbLrCbm4XxJP6DRB8m4j_Gl.Cgw7WO.wFHj.j96bJ_C8pXIhT33AddA2fyYjz3e1hDDyfsUea42yejP14ZdPfcCYjo40hfLCbmk2NO.Hv24blkHI1iwERZzBQMzReyblEY9gNILYuIJQeGhK4C6WmwZkL8oDQi3J8kIxHG8FW0IzJG3qA4aan1CEsFnpZfF7PmtX85cx0kdYyMd0yo9OsNrpCftt9IWhwYFyoO4v6nnFH_D4JzwIL936fXLHBIZZk4m4kZ4nM53XGvq1fEUKH16CUZX4UVN1xSPrnCWaS30o_JhqNMGPMRDvZhJ0rU4d2ZM6NLHIAVnMrLVWnprbDzb8a7VHDvmno_4E.C.YpyfwxymoPxt0zljUsnLPpfUhgwCkTupOgbeIdXk2vVhfh2vAuzPI2BrcucMMQbBq_9S80c22o.mdryr4JDqpKhLe.R9v12B9fqmtZphRHvwkecFzsybkPIamicBnB5md1DElGGBnNtzuprN7K7QuyOypL7Xrc13PeMm.vChmSg5rsBLeSQWuefb7hbo9Xu5._UMJM9oGUEXwprPvQmJvUm7XqmevcdQqNSO5BPCYhg7LuPq2u.d51zBxI2VPPgtTBqydlFMhYkAls3gGT5QKJ3NBDDQUopr3S.F64aab1E_X_M6hs9stcF0eJZYWm9ZIH5hXaAG7kRCayB7juqcHwsbLCeWKnVrDoVX6qb.aHBiFhFjWvsNtZyW1_y9RsJTVKLFUex7c_NUwwTMaxuoN523oF0bO5tYaTxR6GmOHwI7iQfXWQ9PnZla6gOCfWSgVyka7iqzFIT_E3bawblWeFLStaOZAfugzw",mdrd: "tk0b2uXbDxtH7QtS_ZAFkylRTF17qvv2ZZyYVsPzprM-1739996334-1.2.1.1-VLnvtw5jyFQq.Kv9Om7.dB8IkTYUBrd70ebyRMsAbt8glPnk6HKvy.4Mc9C4X6I73nL1YMvh1y4Pdela7YIIBVvFxYEOOKnnvmY4nGqICKHLBN2tcAkD8Sj8C9Z7441fXVjSWPlVktcbifi1V6agcCXS_lx1FiqXo9L.Ir7zSwSH0jkS5xC_MYLHNM4iSpLADwVXNA8ivTyBFwgFZCfq0xoZLdDcXxR6vi9yWgVQ2qQzClB3yyIVw6rAeKOYatOGznoETGI.3AJwlglmXQzlLnWHQNrGT_olMGlPTJ6t8aJaH7ldBpb1BgceumYLOjXB7PMDA4eBIloAMVYfGfXg8BYWN615ljeM1_ZPsvME1NE.eKXdtxHOdW3vvstZ6xdBNDO0JH0JM.MBWWfPZVs4fm9d508AbUqL_RGTWY2v8kZfXqf6f6A1MIjlj65Gh6ABASiGmoJkHXGxOR7hMMIUBuYji_qpXdD_5DsSqH7nBlcmPy5Su1xOw19WCS_ahspYTALJOMK3u3gmGPp9EIG0wFbiF1.SK.dO.zV9.w5HUR4iBUhwMIkpIuvQN1TVSWtck3Yz3Oq5kMq3pyzX12HXauQauloavboB1hn3QzL6_k5gV24yFMLPrQFP15yPAhgomSWV9JMRp.bdQsI8r.TdTOeEs73BZXhIMMlkgMy0aj2VR4qbTUhGzrdlJA7PeLSAZLmNp5ezeTYytRy76VcEJmBtfjWT.e4oQdS9tWas6GgOzFr1ZsyECwO3P3o348S_3aRCSYSHihocX7XwPFLSF9RDAVFgZ1oaEgt4NZJqvcBeCDYV5Zq8QoryncFi5LHxD_sJIng9F2I5ALEqR7un0P3iQK9TnK3oOufPzthWPZBUtSmov1x3UdhRv7Dpm5KddcYLRoWRRxkQyuSOYd.ORMINECvFUqNO2UoZ6es3fy4tWmWPCUmSSRDI4b7dbFq_hq1VLdDAWM.X4vyUqt5v2HXeu.LUlfTZnJDOQYaRPWkePm_FeZ6Utw3osAx6WmLt_qIAbq9NHauk7hC1jjwmPrRUQRQQom7c7s5JcmntXl3MQSrJqJHC1sNo54HFesWscPnjZZh8JlpRFQAhF2Av1FZEgHVufe_dAXjvNeVe_ILVqnV3TySDXNiMIFGz_u23dbf.S3UMEBLFZzCPEyORWA4_oMS3NJHISuzPnUxFLxP5.Rs9LKTE4QSYqL.pLpCXKjM61hcwDxF8zd5.k2XqgVx8xuTnAf.UaWK.USZar6lKaeCDmf1Sc3P1IBudohT51o7kAwPejgLFB3OjzUxFF5hY1R.TSekSOPu9GwrCW8mqWZ7TIW4c9_ESxH8.nvrgv2EwchqbzTheoYXB3yWFBkOdSgLugbGHzgVECytoHYaGmLR9a_3UGsBTcoVIRIqnHAdjvZA3TGyb6KkTMfVwSNkFqBs4WnURKscymZ5cvQdiVwStzhIQ6YmNKgK1lY67m0x1qgndcu18IweKvKJkeuY_tnb5s0CC8d3_m4cru9O2rDEAePhBFzhRJeq3g2N7.NTFI4z8gbfFg9isuFHK379dMzNeTeCSzBZN7irm19nrRoNf5QflK57bgj4PoV2F3oHfmwhidslC0dYOQ1667We7_Ql4dlmeNvcswxCcOSjnruLKTjPimiulHo4fqECzyvwMfXTNXyiXL8NmXer3N6Q1L3sKWaV7q6bJZRtHbNbuUR2zNkG44Ziwib1Ursixd5Q3DKklPqD.Oms.WH4fGSBHycRsmoi7dV9nmHd7OZ4"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=9148f2e448736b99';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/hc\/en-us?__cf_chl_rt_tk=rJeHwouqK85eWC7GKN2AUZarxE8go_N7s4jJ00aFR.g-1739996334-1.0.1.1-Bkn6nRllV5LdHdRey_Zkcy1s2M3GBQUeuGE6T.TlGg0" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>