CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "help.foreignpolicy.com",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e8114ed5e169b8b',cH: 'ZdCoHeTATlZE7MCwbeX7LzTvweldWGxax06XBU1W1hE-1732531867-1.2.1.1-6aKenMbc1eOP9mcODzAMpqVP6QXVn5u5Rpe5B1_1h.mr.D1ECLcAKGQwlKybgynP',cUPMDTk: "\/hc\/en-us?__cf_chl_tk=g91Kha1V8nEEGRS87ioKILS.r2Tif4B4_rrAxxLYc_E-1732531867-1.0.1.1-V3pw36Oj81hE.xtPHGwTIDNVAJudz0Il2pIAfm2dTVY",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1732531867',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/hc\/en-us?__cf_chl_f_tk=g91Kha1V8nEEGRS87ioKILS.r2Tif4B4_rrAxxLYc_E-1732531867-1.0.1.1-V3pw36Oj81hE.xtPHGwTIDNVAJudz0Il2pIAfm2dTVY",md: "DWZ5numO_KTgQsmmunPoQ9nMhvX0VxJTFrNNVeFaRyw-1732531867-1.2.1.1-eOoYNIRvfZ5KGa04fqs9kpiiqmG1zmJQ4TDd3aM38Ct6J_r8nSx6MgeXZ13jYD1GcygiPF.8UbMXS5hAKLeqpJQQpjRITMhuxznZsCxZxELGPr4cLGlSHhwVWvESkrlkBQpaTFUmTlsLBB4EoBsRKe2OGJ3dEHtd4su8WK_V09HlNBOIOU6fECpLlurPmn4QA1SL3.guSg9qrD8CVSf3JczdIlbY9wG8LzGuPSNjgA0Ax30uET883Vn44NqiUBo1s9E7Gl7UFTx5PFCytCGZsANPJ2l8G4MUgXVKgnWG8Qls9MGKn9L4CmhFv_i2WSH2Et4aVUvj1EzU.kkAuqV2204Yx2rcWbT7XpazpUTTcbN0xOMlOIlQC3dzAPWaU_aOCbr3Eg6r3Dq7eoqKgZuZlWMqXKejiS8IuF3bwosDroZlUfhw3d5IuXq9zssz1RPHplNawv2pboqlLeeaBc8I1gvuDehv9YLGr.D4gWMc._rVIJJdNv6jLMsHMurzTfjIKCQKMba_BGNEYCE2vEuPTP7.9PF19vEKYJkx7RFbpUxhbYDaje2hsdcBoHkHzvqMdDLtv7mvVO6kx1AMk6YsNzbPYzXo3XH_mJbBXvCYnmQTWqtBxgerALod_.T6Bz6gyjwguM1KBLkBGalz89TO6S6SruJ9jacdazcBgW2e.hvIdYz9yzk2w7n5pvN7Jf1k6L.P6U9hca9LXFi6Zj8Z.n96e6MTDh3u7upMLfKzrk6QIswtO0Y3.5HdYXSB2o_jO60.XnY9Yz4nkw4Y8DXZ8CZw3Rbq3.vMgsCRJ25FfFVtq.7pEGmsfWD7NqnANEyz54WkRKWp4AEKcpMKUF3cOuXuxupZHPdENbRMKhJFCRKpl.NctirYhiyd373OXIZq1Tn9xDgu6TPIGpSB737iaykSqaF_4QobACrbJ0mj7ZmObkbmrgs91JswNJXm9viCmNO8xKf8svDX8SWxLQdtSxs1M4OaKFoTfGYezqvuQoFNPZgzcSPlZJ6kwcjeZAh_uA8OCkXeh0YqU2kXG.TBQLeVXGYnb5CfXCNdYOoF3OW.KzUt0qYDk7Ag.Gres1ZHd7PFM.tG9W7n9AbHr8WGneAPe0vD4wZrbf88I89w2iWrgR8Aqki9MfoMEAa_ewRGLEhFomnR9GCqo31LjQCvibW9AQC0LSVekFLd7Ehfqc5tATBQkBmgCJp42QcbWvZZM_8s_K6.T6L8wy7dI_PCWjX1mRP4MEG0tDScI0AUAmOxRqCzsOrWpR.1ZQ1iMgIGEhm6rX7ec8XL2d2JnwtBASH8D2NcHHbNKy4GENwttC9vlZLmtfg7cl_pW0OeFDCEQUCacl58qXq6uK2HVzT7nrRyEgo.SAMrkXchSWqsMz4MtvD9Q43ceJ7pgk3Klp689lZTxeZmUFME_Spoc9IEDSDI_z_BjJ.1hdmqSf5eRfdX3kuiZKsBODE_iCQ2a3AZrPhNZ0xRQ8o_dFxsj3qH.U8LOXEpvLh889QzJxDVp_dJ22GXRyH2sAxNgbyL2z.NJl4XRT6eZUshpPw_QWgdFiQAsmfwNDuvDgLeHLDE2nP7.2m37r631XNJL0exWAiJMojxNVitlAI.yPq5JnFx75O.jDilL.wZyhUqpjaEAJVt1Y1xE25f3ijdrTIE1pLqrHGKb.V236YWBPafMScnXFLeehiVNq61PrD6ZfnCPYbiQ9xTS3HjcWenXluDGwKhV8ydqJSrvDGpSDqE_Q.0GDmPINAoUXqBh0tJTssjPOKK9Jm4O9Y4YF6D7g3cRPwy3xauZ1z6kxxT8XEu4_3rQdp73y1K7WzwaNo7qXNsIpa1UDv_WHHQdhAF.5Jys4nQC_mb_kStOi_M7qvNRROzH0M3HRAh_cunlKOWy1JIN6H6arCoJC_q45hyKethu37zKIlmfzxUhbdth0O3m_1gSkXRodkpwhfn2kQ6MCiqbr7f5msEbTDIlNPRlGlFH3byDOJL2peyxMxdcxthAqTvzphAFUHkrDCFNBEgBOqjmxrQOH64F9TqHzLvEj7FGW_a_NSe5y8gFx_IPluiKw.YWGrUycndCjXEkI773WyttUF0BT893ZrCToGV50qgQkKh37xrc8w3Ty.sxjaOEFb03IOyl.i8sJKsuv4iR6nvoo9.WB.d26FTzye037.I9uNTOnokrX5dpxInEZ07dZp9VlPE1xSCgc87PNVcfl0zGiDfSlvUcqpUQlQikN7P3doduQkg.Mgcs6oR3xB_IQSObk8XVSSKIwlnKshuT7iROss5AWr7Ptrprx538iOpSpswH0UCx8BQYDZh8bjcUNYBtNp9pPQCt_ZgSom33jUU97eHwbbTkY9N_yzJe6ITAe8rDcZKBqCZgPO_qRDvNDb3KLgZ_GfX9NV1Up9F0kcC2sCvI7alyroPxPEPfmAQOdvIdt_dxWPSZvVXbp711o0K_m6Ti94564DBg9znmMXOGpwosLYC1Pr7zsg6ueCpTDy5zcbr98YwOhEBd.0YawGINijyEKw3OHiR8pLqewYI6xFdXiWh7qhw6NPtywmz63rq.mTsBpe9yQ5JZBbxerzqlr9BFU3ZQau_4ztM1oJNc9MQsoOEK0NUqOpDT2JR4WQIxq6GAKcnad86j9fXS6ohUQwsFZPHHzZ4QDydMBXSWXmYThNrpT85CaO3KOC5wzEpouUUtwWpNZm2.ATe1nadCwMPMorAjWFuIgVRjVfnjpxUdDb550p0XAQ06RkqqpZN32rO_ww6JPpe8eraT2PKAOQ0tUtVkCUxohz4oAfnGa0har_feco1luhnE6XEJbNO.tFoOE3.zp7WrtLtSkpQ9f7iIRvHsEQwwh7mYVtK2WYFogoR6lD.vGA631ZkzLCL7GmhFh._mBbUQIFO9qZgHGHfaItXH1q7uIs5gXWOdMI",mdrd: "5T138Rb0CWFarV_8ZNI76PZFNvVUNSl2M9O7maPN8BA-1732531867-1.2.1.1-jowt80yjuvI0uWyxxt0awlMLGnjf.diub8y.mM9PlT2eZgF5IKKxyo5MYSmaK1R95BFQwGl3nUY4T7a8nIUIf4MslJTx2oieuvcGa173WFJQSSd83wB9ybrIfs_JYXwo3Wyv0ssx1PlHnhk9fQ7YDPaGRSPvWrYWOjg38FwvmZyG4gETv4_0OQY2tuFqntRsbE._F0.pO4xtcSYP3lrqZJ8QiTxNi.6RX7J11QqftHyiXPtvEWlyApWoIq0Ft6akyjS1stek9IOKNy2HDPR7X2QF7KE_k_vOXdDHCbi5bbkgL8ZbGTaCv0y.8uQuUCpbce0.vzb3eusLvfOdU_ts29m6buWAG.hOdIPudPyrXTzrJO57EV7VvMxz_HZUGhjnJMYxM7bRg5ds8kydVQQHU6.Jxt5tNm3Uvkne1pve280b0S7jDNsfGVaVPmpw7sca96geUULs_RkYPNnkq7jeCyLD84d6Aswjfxe6.w27SB_5BAlu67mzvK.c7wyuavywz5evgKv8uAtpsCCsDUL54WrJP9.hJT43aDKTEmzqwhLQig5InB0pNf2yVZJTRsWzH0ReJr0R9.VO0N_5lIA5gY3gifDRTw66zy2ArBE7EEQkLvGULP8t_e0MWAHxuiiMbyoHW3smjKuh8856KlVFwUWqFKfrH9Hz8hdW3RpUpIrS78UlSc72R0gwFkmqzzRMnXYIKqFiw0IhTWASIMkp7z6gKvs.zPYwQNPI2aAqmFdDICumMtKDyMypzXUsVosH8CmTv8Ur6BEt9LkgQ2WcCBZou_ve9Oz6rRCQTz0DUgKe6qI_dSxMqXE9gUYYewrZjDMW41MjH6gfqeQunvlLZjgDMMxNvOAgFee3ganuMJL46wlKFlvqPfug4p1dkKHZ3hyn_LNEd9bE1dmkvaEhsKe9turYVBzpIbQIfo61IRUXs2ephAp6e5ucPqe17HrPTINMcPYDn1NGFWiJAMuqJkRVgkv3vTPlSaOSanhFWU5NEnZUK3CdIfbBuWhMCCfK_N389d5Ay1AfTGES0yiEdInaWXo3RtyBcv9NqpgLJWQibwuUCaQay1C_NbCwfWYKbQoh7pzR67KVdj1LFRDPv_dyVGJ75eVe4SUKjcYYrNCpF8GYqfx28MAvrjH9Bqhgu8xgVfUEKm2TfX76qnxUyyP4PDWklYFECO42VSOw2uO.3gzhIv0kZxznxzTv6prVh2CbAnM0g78U9tatbbBgpKtbZpGKfVWJNDJaQe4OXj3boZPodnZy1wF4p1g7bS8k2vOg9mYqprHxdoNNXS4UlTbdogaAs6ZI4mjWdJJ2iaRADBIRmbDNrkE6A9Y4LaiwJ2Ppc9d8zE_z9qtyqv9OYmH6Fw8las7b2XbCxNmyre9o6I.NCiWxXYQ62pwbIZMfYEVQKgwOrcfmtH9G6TrxBW4OOPDT0zsBNff.MoRguIweSOITLa2gtOvOwZtPu7Z2nnZvOhLheSCY8YR15.2BpdNSPBckRFbQLBkXesZcEvIl1G0oNBJcLWUjtr8_S91jzpkFw4OUa5X7i.5SNEkypBNWnGWrWwVijBO0o9Mm3Vh_C0JT.Rv3kFSliyLRn_On9eWH32ooOVjIa4RaMQnC7bdk0RjX2ke_EuN5bU1poc0pJHxZVhuBiHY4r6MG.cO.vM7qFV6DKXyHhBsmrHvEtN4gUUJtpJWXfVrE76WnQBK8naKBzWHrB7IKL3adD6mKazWu8R_OQaDN2pQVcwbecSTxMGTetY.Rp7yLPRj15Rs"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e8114ed5e169b8b';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/hc\/en-us?__cf_chl_rt_tk=g91Kha1V8nEEGRS87ioKILS.r2Tif4B4_rrAxxLYc_E-1732531867-1.0.1.1-V3pw36Oj81hE.xtPHGwTIDNVAJudz0Il2pIAfm2dTVY" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>