CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "caselaw.findlaw.com",cType: 'managed',cRay: '913a254a59155d38',cH: 'E_ONM6nL5yev5kEqewu2EUlaPCsqnF6MbdLAegrpgzk-1739841112-1.2.1.1-XVYCcTLDNByzydX4BFAPn2wjkhxbezpTkKNgC1ke2YaPGB_q51d_kGwpZvvI9u22',cUPMDTk: "\/us-11th-circuit\/1089768.html?__cf_chl_tk=NHx0rTR1HKnW1PHreiUQ4tcmFgpcCveCLG8wo84BLoU-1739841112-1.0.1.1-mijPbomdVXCmVVsuM1ZMvNcxuAA265c6tLy0nyyBfaY",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1739841112',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/us-11th-circuit\/1089768.html?__cf_chl_f_tk=NHx0rTR1HKnW1PHreiUQ4tcmFgpcCveCLG8wo84BLoU-1739841112-1.0.1.1-mijPbomdVXCmVVsuM1ZMvNcxuAA265c6tLy0nyyBfaY",md: "Qcoa3fzHwYWf3S7DLTHGel5azlsV99QhmuD2IEPcG0E-1739841112-1.2.1.1-ZiNoPSjy2ujZSbmJEH7CJxkj9AU.26dDrOg1SvpZahMcYblhoSv0PYo1KHxN2_syogdNGD2JHh3.HJ6jRsydrG20No6q1EtX6W6PMeRs4h8V._OjO8OknoFip7Mok8BO58aV.NKfBf12gEik7lwxFmUnTxohscoRVRlADrOZoIWIixRCvT6zDKtIbU90ljDtQHuOlpne2LBqxVHPnP_o4hnBceKdvcHCpdhaqDBKdbwcINgjdqmGHbvoOxcnxmWoPQ4G36RB0oHs0YN2zLAcsQm3IhB7eSpl1VLPadnMQnmlOO2uP0zlijDJysfSA2VGcye_EKoXQhIyCKmkJ6X0iJ5v3eVofWOE4nH8vW_vQFSrLMAzfhwzKH_AAa1vCoQiimVGVwJjS58JYvSP.g_nl2cYCobE3qmCSbUctcMU3mp3bHXvMmGIkIipmvvSkt.0M2cbsM.pKHJPaxpQX7YHOYA8p_YZC.3NYV1QNs4MVSzkqAX5ciaELpzEdNq0GMDtBI03A3OntqV3oUSE8Tq.YIo91wykHh.WYpXPVxpd9OtKPmtNds7KaFdXZ0hcX1OAWW.aw8A4UkV5EL4qD1rC_x0LgLdeJTW5y.SZW9XlEM8YY4NrtLIiEj8_5QI8kRbx6Q9nfYevrnGy27041buVPC2OK_fMfbAgJ_DrI55jk94tEbjOrsBRNPzegoPY2vPMJEDcqrd52qeBY8wZMjq69tbVLJ5p0DzKez7GosKU8K.JF7R05ISaXZn43xQyQ3hmO41ppA_4ZwYfG_2CZKterB8.erbtI8bmzRbIbxY1eSafAyWezJZ.vYPtoPEjLmYUFUH8rCjZo1MJT9wVmDGFWv_HrERQZP_W57JDYe_JQEOnLi70ANZrowq9WvskfzShafJPtvTPFofH6HXNrmlOAfCZNppKv_BuRiYA6hRkqFpqkJqDSyyfrr2NBqenoxDftvI7coSwY7Tj7Td_Qlhn8CI20c2gDYXGPziwWQ6Syhn_bUYpptkHmyjsBYoX1ON0._uyk.y9VKPp1shZ.XxKWA1uV89JjSyf1YOFUZSsa2GjKUBHf8ryzkzvaOJBxXiUoxPspbO8899bhHl1oSQGCE2_G8OqqM3_thzykdJWhkZN2vokjIa32nPo8AGIzJBb7vh.N1a4wno7xETlwq5IRqErLBOEnNPfST_k7753mgsk6Qtm.RoAWe.iUzU4o9r4qxgaygLvUrSNjtWZWZvcQTbVH1NKg_4ZwoW3NDgLi8uEwh9MogixZC_GEqd7tyLLBpjfsnENEeDD42gV9A_RzrYRYKfvafAi7bxCRBhghms6tPuxCn9ZFfMPbbfWNyGpURpl.mA8c4_tGdooFK0YXYLJD7y9FsgfhafqiVEhbhzWKkcSlRMCVFXI.c1PX522Sxnh.gf91UavafurZBTLxANvn46iyWlEDgT_cFZSSKH7Fr5e5okSIMA5G78FujBb_babUzRGy_lboSA42zUdq3JjGV8Un1WbWgw1yZ9LJ8vCEXJiulhgfOvdjdj8uGbZcbYL5sZQIWr1mqdQ8tttKDeyaVvtjo4gFNWFfwumd11_8rL2uRTXhfSOSbnQMYmNJGLXEGGuMrZPPjY2BCpj4aUIqetn4Omz9Ux8aLDjpuaGop5fN8R7E7Qw8ESWIT2a0bJEPHquOHodLI1Rzp_A4xkEWLYraT8MiiNYlUXHlSoPegrSpthVUHF_3oSEEsj9worWX_bsswR4UULpagXrenscYKJpSQylUBSwLsa3zuphBr7WPL9hibgq0kg7uE6ovBdLaaNixQUfmfJJegwPCf6DCDuCSEfoPRIO65YcghhMqkFmqwCvihEu6hP0aheQIPjTh9.A3CWGuz4zqAtYYQpubQnsL0DKwYz9DD4QsrHMeX_7qttb8cDSapmv7b1A2_29sZ2GzFEsJWw7WJ699WwIJ6flzpkBkGxmaGqAyFn1CiAqiEyH1f6S_dalEZq8mm86jl330WZOQrKjyvSERlF3f.Xyf_ZPrI_ryJeATWEx4ccoVyhwMPM6nlPivtDA2sB3TJYP7pON0_GZ_dvKTFTrcS5j.SBKg13hkMxff893HOVOPQAWhMQRhkkaS5zW95kOUVdfqbw7ZhJdcHhptpeQ48k5D6aXa_MCiriiY9Q.ceB_njSWOFBuJCJ6.Abn3hl3RL4yRItWTEco6IQKmPYEeQbDyJvPzNQDfktgvwzChQMrk46w.PcA9c71ChIA840gozwTPdsWTnOnEaz.0NvzntVamerON1vnnHrrw195E5EbmIHOqVui7xNNdi2wMAwVS92GWtAqYWaLWHjNvmtJAtNalFctNJiXv13lyJGLUdS9XtVbDmeH1Xam0LfKMrJ3.rb9CmQDkmt9MS_nLq9rF..lyHEsnxgb2FcYLCHVTcV3kpp_biMTZaLUyaJBrqUTZJVLj..YVOtU3PB_CpAwzby7HLcl9YOHm_21MQI8YRlNN06.QwPhIVzSd0hyIlx0yNbNV03pmkq2XJOYgxPXoP0o2rvlAB7uXrdAIni5BaUSC9T9i2796xXKJpmb",mdrd: "P7BTSvUv6w2aGDc5MgX0pztQ8Zu2p4tbgo8dm8F5LBE-1739841112-1.2.1.1-m9KuDh_Z9GxedtnSF3NvSMCGoOkBrpo6ajaFbtQDfbbiyyrFrs8pWMIMCimhKaFSrbTicNTARpi7JjEUR3me4o5M0.YhrLBO5zHEtURVmgrJhdxWYeH9AXb1nsViPxmSWMHDSdFGkxHC1ZvD9S4CN2hKMlirCsjRSsPgCh_rlA2HkxnfNg003AtUhcXvzeHREZehJSEfkYCBqb.hUKh_KgRRizvwmUa59Ep4mBDNhCcGwdvDW23GqVreNT4wEcFmezsZ7TrzdfTjzZsfWLhGeQnz2FSKzK8xGpEfKq1imznfFnFZdzRgTy7Qup3JtkHFCz0ilWVKr00JXWJKZUf6wjqK1ofkcTR1L2g11Uya0EVQOsq2cX3vY0warSUaNlRNTMWpnILzo8_i6JvPaG6hOSKh4QTcUv.zzltbnZg0gyQ3gkdd1rg1ifrCD7V1lTAWwQ9FV5qb.hZK6XiKWT.PLbshf9wzSQPOAWdWOZ3QoVNXsqrEpG0VzA6MpmNX2jJ2VyJpPR5Lxur9LqTN4GKnkb5xNt2frMo6bhf7cPpL73G_8EojgPTG7xqo4gj7HvtzNGFNBAOFh.IAZp0AEG8LzOTvy.U.5fgMQEJuccgEhZ9u0xNEXOD9wQRgk_FW1kJctxgzsOXWUwppgkCTnLlnzNhlkS8SEXrOvQbrzRz4u8yDrQnBRabMHXoGyqQZp2Vc8sLS1JjBVtlow.L1XaXUO.GHBAmDiE.jvoSedP3X7gBn3vJ9qeroPJL12KHJxMBs68z2GsVZLBMT6M37_tgciverYLrdjk2HTM5eBqsNOc8ED2FA0k90ds0FPj2K32el.Komm.dwFfB62nO5llqPEWVyBtN4odVS7kxAL4m.v7yfJJsVPaOMeqGonXeSYqly7FH.FsRlT4kCRuNhyZx0MEuEXnCUzWJQSV5bQDDvZ3ZMPmspo4epiEGx6BYM_mEUA23_gsW6kYW8.7LqtzX0QqIYCKvPVfDvrPdIm8s_F4LAirw6ZF5DdMCGnfLb_HOBG1W7DQdVGSgDo108rY_ewlNGlby8Q8W9ggDxSsdIuAkiaKTCTuPXnVDR_7hw9AND1NLCvI3DMv6QogOv_IMHBhKH8rXfSqDncsKYpBGNqk7eCVGW879A26SdgbaDi9Mfm.rMABla2YSAszGV7s8D2WaqpkqbIpIkVRCcsCVYoDIRKdGYdGaJ0fyPc2xFHXyNeJHgRSyaGyj_VJ1fnuE.FFdIlRE5RJZD_mLjeZTSNPi6bA.KZZ91OCQloe3560p6hePriVf4nvwoklmB269LTQrAxZXudrQw.hny63Q_Q3OygOZsMLAWkZCNlmKKqVJLTgXy5LWaldqNQVLpt3s6m4nuJNxTv4E9tVyoFcfklrcA7TzBbCDcW16jXD3mK4FNfMxcKSQlYyhm2aJuoymePuiJPPoDS_qwCSlS4rBUQH2a7A00WMYKGNGkXzUBxvsEblcthANq7cCh5s.9ljnWtMO7_k1JJoVxgoeviHLCh55uTgZ31zwdxL2yZ4DXkyBV1jfpvcf11qFKlobpYnX4Ly6VgTb7Rze.59rAVE9BUEggYm1ALxBoEE6.Ce3395_x8dCCuSA3oILH9RYYScwo_uX58Ln.6NBQjWDQ4iGEK__ucN0DS89iQFgIV3HrbPGRxqm57XtpZ4gi.GVVcK6WAp7mZ63ik9juPVkraAYlvooEgWC1IKn3VpR8Oy4kfpCT9B31YUxSVQAwkaCcwbgOKacEKWK_HZvP0q0EVE5FEYmyD_b1u8kvs.qbVDTk4xNBBOhS5HWjGv.I0nVfg8XjXhHhCmvpxji8yffpL0oB5fG2qRvZj3Vf_gxQ19hlK.vi3CXTu2VMIK2IEyWE21sNBlDrHvkzpEl7DQp_CkIrqhziFwt8BMIqizcPA4YjZTJ.5zzFrOzuWUmQ6c8CgMV20jx8z5C0QVXQLa_5aFeFfjiKAsup9XD5A310fndGqAQM"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=913a254a59155d38';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/us-11th-circuit\/1089768.html?__cf_chl_rt_tk=NHx0rTR1HKnW1PHreiUQ4tcmFgpcCveCLG8wo84BLoU-1739841112-1.0.1.1-mijPbomdVXCmVVsuM1ZMvNcxuAA265c6tLy0nyyBfaY" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>