CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "philpapers.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '9139ec5f0fc4a071',cH: 'x_rynVpgZr8BOJwl4EKnTcUQGvDldLeoEL47ecrGRXQ-1739838781-1.2.1.1-tjFKzEZiVMH2O_GprDpUDIyeOFzmnNfFAKdHGhYMv.MBqJrrSPltu879yjFCGQQo',cUPMDTk: "\/browse\/theatre?__cf_chl_tk=._ES6xhOsurQjCU9kZzFHqrwnUUx5FP_XSgJDENz5yc-1739838781-1.0.1.1-jutErHMih50gFQr12jOXjYlcHr2hYhTf5rmH5dlPMAw",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1739838781',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/browse\/theatre?__cf_chl_f_tk=._ES6xhOsurQjCU9kZzFHqrwnUUx5FP_XSgJDENz5yc-1739838781-1.0.1.1-jutErHMih50gFQr12jOXjYlcHr2hYhTf5rmH5dlPMAw",md: "TA1az9vuo0y193B4h1mATd_kM9vjfpgBQOuIz._X7vo-1739838781-1.2.1.1-yw2tNsnrvCtuInCjW4HM2CHHVNc3IDwcoW6inQmkruEXHbon2jNbsJcny1iXpUYPe0fvBiAuND..hYsor8Kkd5kK6LlnIz5iVzno5G4DYGjfotm7L1coeIa7YyKxykt3frcfpODqx0kvPA_.hQ0.AA.ffbh45IduSjMdB24Xf3CUwA5QVe1rEIevlIQ3tHjDADhBYUKWyolx1hBR_.CHu7Vr9vKx3GvsTbvACY41OnQBhEwvxRtLl2eUcOrunAY5.WsiT4F9_ybJ4t3W1oJq.4bv9cPnTL1wrT4JHpdq64AbbzDr845xk7hyKtoQD0TR_RZpnNX2pBtC98gEkwIA2jT5Bhsg69G9rr9DW8XPbIwTGpOquAqg3p5.2BERMRM6r0i5rZ9FIJN0WiFuIhmiNHaAhBk2WI.K54cfrhEK_ZzNtwd6UPeKMsoblzJcGRzx8bGte_LaveKNeqMFsZlMqv5HDN5hSpScprSlO0T7sL3hjazanpZtwqJXLFQduNevtAT1Uf1XopKEF_di9TOeKQmuRe5J_9XxPY4WFG1DUkXdjPG.ekg3VAVQlIutURfkvUjBn9YuSdW4olPHQTNnnuHt.A0Jv0Ea16DWl2qX1YbQwu40o76_yRs9tt85xpBibSNiMovYTsHjWbpjFWhB88Ib5yACBmXcgWebq1gQ_414hjdDLzKzRVe4ldmDYH2f4thSmgQShbeTQAnDY.9SGeOHwDFYKDIC4QCDAHIMsl8YzT9AJYxAWrLAWhYoy2AagN4FOiKqtymI5Hxu7bCKY7OB__huk4.NasEN4l.XKsKqvJXnErBseO_xbfIJXASMErohLbbpCXaGvFhtN1hJAw1Cx9BUVxTrORe66VrnOrcSwT9uoble7GtmnBNrhZlistkHlO9bf6RlsrWjvOajktaubLsYXARDf89zOdSdXVca5VlmJkLEqzkcarZMb6HrVoVlAn1yL5_KhwWgShczSYnQKMHtAPGtTgPrfBdZnXsYelXw8y7Dqtkdb2rkEj9b35pcWCxQf7GQYF83.eDUDtZ6NSOpu4.3_lUlMKFta1P27jM5cLsQnN6k332mj_JXL98nqsYPTk.JVWYv5IjZbd0Ul2ky4JtYKziPEjaTWnROPTw1CuRAS3dbtJ3nNyYLlHrmO31BMqn7eBBmVqv5E0OVUZ6WlAjX8UE_2hkIh9uUkgakd6iNW2zMzNNJSOM_rarNk6IcjvetKv_4yMGdftKij1Z.3oi1y1dae_nXX_dz_jN56qbKCKQwSmJo4NkdIQA7CbiCpo2bjdqCKwYO5uikqXhSOIOaKRfSV74JKNGXMUS2ptatTQ1RtEm8Wtfi7mGDpKqVzGgRn8ODHwIaDJLn0cW.Bz5P1pmVUgpXr0zJq1wsmLcDtr92JpeZ3s2ZafN.cZ2b4DMtRrWefAw_HT21sN3vPKtrMrIbxUOBgDck7Zr8p1oSrIcXvOfextESU5fnM.DGgcZ7jkePnBPFdItRorlG4zY7KMV9jSEiUVzjFuf9cdJqdNEdFsIVu1FjLCglJHj5m1EFRJDc_QGEbcwdd5Rtf8gul5phcOQzzfCDaUucLLoTSa2rtDEit.B6s9irR8SYnSRe9cAaWqAGKvOJ7rMunRcL7M_MTSk7SeETgxdRs1AHGuKIDI6Vhda3fuYAVZ.JGVvdDSlPTG7iRcO1NwY3QSIE0P86EbK91GKKcOB6GURqkXG6HwSZu7yFVYD85Wn0q_ngdMiy_jxtnHvFiRqXENaLWZk.bkeZ9jDO6DnbqWrKRepDBMxsSVOKaHN5nizI.YBx15xMCbGL0HqLrJnK3M8.goUYpKJii0KRWRX_sRcOilErb1ePitSyej24aOMJFNUwUO6xrBniwbfooVKGD7joB1EX67FKGk9FvJGclJNWAag5FFdo3SpyYN_a84bBT2XJuCSf1Pz9oDYoZYtHqQipPhNMjjGeejgITle8UepUtVWkzxmafqrgNILIyd5JGI6StB_64Og2CeuIDZEUhT3Tpy4va6HI1umeaJCwPYbkTgNFDJ3niNsiufP87HpO7_uO6mZKGF2l6uept1fPhU0IOO1px04kXrVDRhZGjvIb36ITG3P8x_BBmRO1X9w0llBBBg8yluruA7M4h5BNCqx3.0Q1IGGQGJjyfebm5zQc0XZkGfJ3o8HR94qX4af9C6Cyz90g7tT3wDZWxZSQz_5CCdT9917B3rWGxn9eXU8LVkmEI9zoylSWjHTJl89uvhDw6PuT9DQ0dFVFMF4Uqm38r27Y5xabxFwsPNWnPaZjNpVxC44TYrxbqMO3F2PEo8GFPrbHnYL3upgux7tQeiz84EDMCkQi99TPHFI2rM8iXpPve4WLl8wLIJrzy27mXGhVD6ALhxQTqg.Cgbx57a2UUXoe0DAw56R30BbIEbuVotSIYwOzkRPRXr9LICYhB0uINMudTywzqput3HnecIdm4wlMMEXpUacPp_xEN4TKp8uuHj1DQul6taykID8Uui7YHTt1mM9v1g",mdrd: "BAVQa6ubipAuGBjAYx0WSyUaFjjmpVN7CFypZVhE2Vs-1739838781-1.2.1.1-7YuCMrBTi_1NTNW48TVKQOxKILA_Ox4WKUK69YS7OsIeWebYc4JWn8d9Ih.zNJYyti4Fh5rOZJ7w4VUXcFdJ.54CFEummMLAdkaNHqbl1Quhqr8.oMp36EFYgytfTq_sZNrCOBTwAmjOl1OeMErFSYHnr3qUjMDslTX34FJX4sR6DejmTEI_.9tpsYDRjnLEx2qGh8tN.pzfbw2FQDMtLECbGBJn9i8i4mpYjbvV0yb6nmmoikQPCgbgoX5G5NraHwLkcIKiSX7SjI.DQ4iQcU.YtwtQzYOwm3N8xLueIGtvOTfiTZlgz8J8L7UVkDrYLw0l46o9F7vf.WE6qqpyXxK0sD7mznEAA9anuC0GVL2ULCeEPSIaDB1.VxcHZI4tstcYEX63ojZAMLXfSmj9VpGU9RmrK3o60L3Fa31pcNTjFhy.A2fHbRWQ.rkk6YvzLqfK4lscujtJxfPSbFeL4I.hxXsnF9FrM..AdlMPsBAWGQYn_7L4hcxmKM4hBcty6llzyU1xp.sNcQaemJh.k6G8nQ0XHnGO65pH5hcelvdh7ZVgO4GpYP.BARakpUxZJKMevkY6M.iiM6hh3YdZpjmqwbaQsSlnodxkf3YQsaKtLlDY3B9E_fenntUXv_Og3_LaCl1DdjBGD9kdHgVmaqSDHDG1PJ9RJcGRUvm5Rv9tX_hy9Zj1uws3yl8FAHleRYsLiaH20JmA3mC7iSNBMPwmKUT87bi20msARxWjUHuZzsoRd383Zu2SDJ8UDcm2OTOlkHTdW57Sef3Wle4A8.d2fN.vx5E1USVd31LDngcV4HkYglNFjlYq14ldRHoMc9ttV64pw7Qf8Fp0rtD1bNBBM4YsdYm.MX6h0fZwSIJ6IkNdJPK1dA1uRmk_407_h2G3d1458OI6zvWpf2HN36xxTGtSL2Xwbnc7c8U0gIELHT698J1EWYXS3T7E1WnB.k2jAcmFQFv7HpYPSIF2nYnvrPXZGOEBfipPHFcFblOeL1eazp6gB73jpMwEnP4hqAUdgs3YM4IMOiLTvJ5R7UPvzVRNlFG_nEtKNS19GmIyBsDi0UkYIGVaASGPQSk2wOpg1PNqdMg1XNr1daFv8v5FC9AiqmQK2gSsuEBFalyV0BDyrNne1tust6zEty5fQ6gG0gtgv.A75DiR4OFFQDNZUlDEuuxNl9KkOa4xhCXjEosUJIFai4Ipm20E1wjhj55UBVya9IXtFUH5e2UO9k8t62BtPEnZm0Kq8JESUd4W0.UZkn3VypF1gAkYSRln8ghOpmH7OwFh8PAb4UOYEugBxVakDMhBI9aKBifrRGJdkXWxnDwiaOEkMcrewd7FpCQdo9b46eyGAy570z0FNLCzR6IXjtX.ESe22JCZ3gTCJUWQhp0oUplhZbvQ1HAupkmZVaJbPM.VxvPJe76BOWWYp1rCoT_49GDjuV4FWEWMUoQQHVMitOOVU6tIxEElCzGh.npoEXzlTEtc7JlBVbezKsBditXVqxDKC.qtyuRHPE.nu30gNffcwYZNx42oh0u.uZntyfa83a0H_6gQWeKpYWM3T0fb_A189weexLf88j3j5EhwjmsWbWAi8Fjt5Pd5q7uM8d2NNeINTVgoyEOE4dRVCmbSvat.Z6ImaNDVSPlxq8HoH7oaoK4KiWTLfvNUOjSgp3NGjI6P9Y2AU5YNXDLqm_Ud.cgWqmeCuwhPlagN6vJ3DokKN3l1BgN5utpsLN5RNLhFZbMPosec7KAbVyf7qSTSptWWTHRWSGeWvFyq403EIQZ3uVTd.507sN7vO98x002x8XBq_mMtvzQTXpb.hk01oZprcPGjtLZPAmy8Mw0xyNwfxcn0qFtejjA5DA7vFxEkauK7OqFYHvPUxcLKC4zfU6X5v0hiQFK8oaX4QccpYKTPuedYFmMik1SFirinLwxMb95SycZJKPOO.j6KnXynX.ZJ7OYv2Hg"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=9139ec5f0fc4a071';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/browse\/theatre?__cf_chl_rt_tk=._ES6xhOsurQjCU9kZzFHqrwnUUx5FP_XSgJDENz5yc-1739838781-1.0.1.1-jutErHMih50gFQr12jOXjYlcHr2hYhTf5rmH5dlPMAw" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>