CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "science.sciencemag.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e72e982ffd4a054',cH: 'WKa3bnlVqau3IxTW5gm3xdVRk6X229nCDteECEN1OSE-1732383288-1.2.1.1-80uINSZ_NtScnv53InMSJ_qKsEoXn42_P7mUEnwioOjcyPfjMXQjNW5ZI2zbfMvn',cUPMDTk: "\/content\/early\/2020\/12\/09\/science.abe3261\/tab-e-letters?__cf_chl_tk=z7PKtPqffhXTWW87vLvZPGQoLUlF4p1Z1WhzB6d3KCA-1732383288-1.0.1.1-8HWrYW.fF02tIWTpmgwrMDhx39NBeFhvxgCr3TMMIo8",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1732383288',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/content\/early\/2020\/12\/09\/science.abe3261\/tab-e-letters?__cf_chl_f_tk=z7PKtPqffhXTWW87vLvZPGQoLUlF4p1Z1WhzB6d3KCA-1732383288-1.0.1.1-8HWrYW.fF02tIWTpmgwrMDhx39NBeFhvxgCr3TMMIo8",md: "UCdhBxJW3nE6Yj_s8dtbm6vsm5U62Jrkmqk9HEJ.xoo-1732383288-1.2.1.1-ES5V3fVth_wH1radEk8pUQ5vs5VLUOL9dWYGFuJ6V7a.v8bC3lDBQOPzKb5tyfgLN8LfUfD6wFOa6rTjHt5OyuvwXMWbb4BecEUQ4pZiOCfnchBzemXEodLB8nfHaVjI.Zarp81.Cp7hAIIV17ZRu_I_a1IOFf1_NVWNVt.V0KhzodY86glu6CF1.N1xVhKwIVcTLK4pxQ.vjcicQs22Sbi6IdRXU30QziiHcHUQL.9WZF7WfHMndI566_4BaGHxHUoXZP.oc2WsAtODJ8z0PjCw7EmfEQr45TgFRJiKBX_0iJ190EXic.tj0SB8nvHKCqVTroD1y66_LNN42ZbZMZMaWWDL50b25r7G6dkAr6soKdEuDsGbzRaGPZlkEQElK1iyKFCK2peRSlFuvbCi9NJAO8jz_HJ5C2AWrTfy_oS_44h4oChcRgitAEdDVkTYUaVfOqeItpvrUQgOThix3p3NGBK79dJa1DdcGZnB2CLeDK3UR9fTUsVanPmLpnuCvTXazKb61qIl7HmTfD3cqQ1m_CUt.rxD.l6rEIy1ZUe7ttIQNJck.m0I2CA5C.dr9z0T0t60miTynkNNlDI_ossUveP8j453.mcenPAA.KmI6X5Bbreb9ye2KMuPxyR3acwlKOBnZHHvFNgmfelIFgvc5LtywlD7Y3_QoIMJ4NdStULEyYrGyIeryDkdGfMv3hNN21liunSt1Ojg6DH65wJTBynk2Ejzt11C3SXtjIMAhOy3EchflYup5SQnKwsZzLbSSa.aK9.kGP69bEVIvGpWmXkIWz4aQqkKz2DwViHcT2ufd4xaEZJhQnzi6YCNpJ51J4jsbHWUtI_5m3Z3xolKiotmdv6J3KRHy4v0oViWy20h1SYRJur1Kjj_uVDPHmGtjWLv3jsCSShByJUtRVxgoZ9rdG86n_0W37n0B3wGuIlRF4nj_NrecF7.XK9HrG6KAYGT_nz7Ry.vAR98AgzPXvdLTXliQTfWX3sZuF_l2tsI9RwejOZi43nIpCbqD_nhDi1fJy91goMEIuYdW1M.JWH5UIE_ZDadRzJL2NzuSzBF8L5PZP..DXyvRmPqRYYJALUtdBet1p5DDNdyNJRGnIYPhIJ6TpQK_83AyVGlI8olHEbO0RzbpahTYcp_mB8rpYKpg1ghk137b6_GKElpIZHAJnkbSAqKOvRMedttfZoqS9Gt99GoSwKBrHxA02hJDEvCAhMBxOCW69GzXXzK342ESvmo2DWr.Kf70e1Dud.bpZ3CNNQQ9vugk.ki.vd0fsxmXbbmrMc7xijB4e3e1H6ynnGQe.NH6B8VsQWsEhbr3fUSoOAy_DXaHjU2wMMvyp4RZm7ooVwNMjIG8Oev3vm12U_mf2y.ASUDQZ4dkM9gvpWBy6h1aT.EamOiJm51JJufhwRDn8Wmnf8bYxnX96gCrBOsqMKEUBqcENT1QixXp9NrYCoQmNaW5UdlCLdG3.aaYmDa1YEkqgdAQ9Q1oMQSK_TN8hbi5IXYYju9_KGSgMfkngRE3LdBng_JmxGt9.yoUEx0_FVZIT9CnyyNR4yiA9oWm7u4p.yVJhR3tJJLffuD5zMB1JULY6D_rai0Bt5.suCKAvo52UXcMJFziNq5tPp3wmSyraSTt77ttfaGJMWsfHd.9J8RLb4NhGYt7uBQFJQSLaeXjhhhsqvD2SEIyL.mCAAtSmYnsfEo5Vos3G1xH4xQBuBq5UWT7Xvqueqe7cjBDrMvmHCmEZ3V.Q4afJL2bKvQOHZoknpFipTUKuMefGIJ2M5IPwwzMEggTQqtN_qMEqozSeiGPytoMxt1Nf9QBwymv3THPMoZD61NGlEiQyZKRLLAeGY9TFazXNvTyGvXFJFXJb8Vm_WuGneglkTteI7NnjRU8U7RANFA_XJzQOHLpBjPS1c9g5X6fCMmxbBaBb7xxE_AEKyGqr6aTnkE7PdXSGS0g9QYabA4WFXeiW3ablXw7S1mG8XrvWgKv45Z17MkaPUdNu_NYmIy3g2lt9ibjMeLRrNwp65XrNK4TxRara5mFQyEslaiuQtW35BUShG5LbWeC_Mmy6H_vSyK_LKXj5fPo95N9Z09mhyLLYu1H74N49yzIodE38jRMuxmg4MC7829JRlxsUPsE9NA0RRGH.tLObqRJqkP8EeroIJ2woYc0IMuKg3o4SCweX6MA3qC6JtUHeJYqiol68ULGoITMWaN9.lNqAq4e5_Ff32TYu.HzqQf0JOqXx9sMfFRpnzkDLx2Hb9QLMTmIFqyr2FM6XgdaQMZmRtfdBO_vuGjz.NhDLgcXIWGlxMRUwNaP3x4f0cnAODLjXxi0fz.pYZZ5MT48D3Cud3Vr2ZtUFvO4bspUVVu9G9qMzesnCysfvdStrtsNwLcEI4dU0gSHuCZVKzjIYimiLmFZgiccMK83XRD06z3D96Ne9UlE6gHE1Z8Y3Yj8lym6tWRKClIGOUCB4vEcZiellORWVKReHmwJPVGhMt4UAvNJSqCvYId0mOVHQWy_Lcknr_cSgSx1xhS4DjGUWvrD5MlCdzQQbi2iYh4B2iBVjCQTtjKUdJulpt9XMfNGhHMPegfRZ_JRr4y_NIT4xSBU0Q7RaqG49uu803HLz1Xrk1yjCg79QE51eK7NiTHDgx9D8NAnGL3_g6JE6D2i1bM9ovpyphj_r9OR_VnNu3mA0K6dyZZfK9JwGbW1tlmqBWzRA2RMvboan1ZXeDeqwFnabWHZ.oa3P6TtuVSEngeJAGHRZZKTrp6yT_2jnRzqlnnugQuK9jN6HZHBtnIN9veGrf2vKE2iIhBScBOzJ9suUfjK_HI1ooJx1MtBsv_pnZfXDWI0.Bfv9UcWiOBY0f70FtVbNIwXSAhQdTl8dRytandTuEJCGziwxVdxL4T396S1fe1ZTv9JS.XtPTlfX2I9VSP_RTPQkSO_KdfpIjewJKbyFEHfO.2Or9GuVASXvNwpOgqRI6VCaD7jr5_B2TVft6P6nv807CbdBikOXeRS0qCe_ILQisdVB41B_1cKN8L4UaYXHMYRK0FyGQT9jK6vBHB_e2nEzqmkKepRB0b",mdrd: "pAvfXvFGmwYA8WO0woz5RLhIkANSejMrkxPOiRXRVpo-1732383288-1.2.1.1-929CV.tNtwbOX0r.lXUBPH1ZlXn.xg_3KwHzebtF8uOosmD8232ppiDeI7Z3ZbDLDPxHZ00yigY4UsB1YhX2gqoI2xZdaZSEJlsB5tPAGBznplU.BJTt7EjzGXsX4NIvvo8GFYg6uCtYv6LS6MlEqDDqNvVmUeuZS_fYi90j.TwZiWJeDMUPBjuyqU3vwlFFe9mEq5VC0lMkBq4IfuCrZG.xkLmbIJQsXLMcvQOABm63bztB9T8SzThHmpxvSCha5ee6y1RmkxpaetYUYzDJ9ETZtRQjIJg1YCh2dHcXH0ihb7vap9kMk3XDP7ZHlI51BPWaOu3zXy7JKBEC9Zun0w3SpF56A0r7nnKhkM9UcsqnIA8X8B1QpA_kQ5TWiv9staM.MzxNpToidRaxuRc9x3z7EwVbkEQxw93K5yIJVBDtwIt5XHfY4Q_V5igrKP6B.1aEBlNb.4rKSOy9MauPjJa6Hu5sB2wgHAG85tgqUfeysdGkLzLfEKjj5tSIdjSGqZhFQf1qPL4iBFuMSpjHAseZUncdAbEGxI6w7Ao19KPRzrvpIkaiSpXnUIx9vr3vBxXE1LKMdz7b47x.ALEzCnWfX_tNeZGJAOT_0CqTQucQ06OJgHJAI8UipQhodMMF0h9GNFHKq_97RC5TN7_sqmOVJZAn7r.ls4_CEikv_Na11Z5I.x36BEHQW4EjNCc87TotZtrPcCRdUXFMJrhOdISgwxu0myaXe5SEiC6ipY3IpuCxQdelJFXukqLdMrydX.vRlcCknremh0Y1_CvcknxgM7UpcZaja3suuo8b7SAp9A9Z1JsiHdwZaZZmvIinhaogaWq7ByHcFoGYEPv.gODRMzyyxxqv6yIoqRp2Nj9dVUg.m2Z3OOG0khkzdldDRMUjQmpFTKwK8C3PWnOyX7FTl15NMlS_maTIfg5StrozPJUfP1Vjl5whWVBrCShbb6t2JMNa09kqwhWJAs.npk4AGv7B_GqDYSMJKMvgnQgA33863pDbt5i9H1vVuO0ecE7FoXEvRE_0.MzKBttlr9Ql.ti3ysDVQpFvYN5R5KqXiI2uPa1RrwKoyB69gfgtrpkVTSgDUVzCln.T_NNpGRvNBNI2eEBJ3qEh0vzAWM0K_fV4V3kqCk0fvST8Mnab26XmTfw3trBBz3qWpWb77zvkutTdS0h_wF3kk0ERhk5GHGtTadeG2IRnkckKV6gPJ6o3ii2ABaU27RWXfz1DJUKdEfTNboiOxyIBo.B.Stiro7WzEhpMuBp7doNslE5WHgNdxUdcpnzdOS8abvMg_LyI9GKOlzXNSd0_txF7cY.i.hqSbBR.vWn40QI8UZ9e.DVgrXRjaJfLsBEnfa8KUjqYKmPMa.SWeHbuoCBElgQbmoq_JmdA7gQOcUGnHYmqctxM1RxxZgqADKUQuiIW6ociYb..u5fd_BJN3E__hZvITK4QhA2pGjD_cSXUoaIvZ8SX0UEs_YPyZHb2_qoCimf1fZcpEQ0R63qgJy5LuJsD.g01rYc.0KvK6iLr7ylu5vPSER6rHMvkOUi0l7jkA0KkzDhO6ziEnIqJ6g6hrj1KyuzrbB2drOH6HKy.ZMDSeF4eGBTWhnUkOqHiDLGDz0QFDSKnVkhe16QheouYPE2yTNEORCiAe8UosUWmAx.0.7m4LqJEQSLcZmBb8sy5033jsa7HkUXzQmkmG_f1DnwFIZ9ej0wpNZw4UjHM5bRO9wohjy57UpXDIir7y0t18ZZB72m7Cr_HmHWbBfs.WVZVYQ8cQjESY3Ghop.IgQrWnQQ3aAzKtlkJsCOdWpjG29.u9xYRzxJOafH.E5zoPkHzCCA.qVJJK6GyJ_8iBgRdffB3VKg8JO3f_G00o8A.TZ26Sm7N_PSVPlPKVG6e_rKOdwlYqedEGNEsqs9dRg.Y1_6LbwVd04oZMx9WumuNN7TaXoaAROGueyhzN76owYehq25GjkfcIbRZRfMj0He5"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e72e982ffd4a054';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/content\/early\/2020\/12\/09\/science.abe3261\/tab-e-letters?__cf_chl_rt_tk=z7PKtPqffhXTWW87vLvZPGQoLUlF4p1Z1WhzB6d3KCA-1732383288-1.0.1.1-8HWrYW.fF02tIWTpmgwrMDhx39NBeFhvxgCr3TMMIo8" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>