CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "www.brookings.edu",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8f4b56450c95f93a',cH: 'vztB4rIGSCcGHMd1qY6MnA5TADjgMbUhlwOTgxRlHzE-1734652667-1.2.1.1-DAPPf1Tm5LRGRIx96THDPmg6Ep_hL8kmSV9jEJ6QEwBkKbnspaeQcj.gYfqAspVP',cUPMDTk: "\/project\/brookings-papers-on-economic-activity\/?__cf_chl_tk=EALery1tzGH.FN_d8WtDGQiLw6wWO92PYb9kIcqNt9Q-1734652667-1.0.1.1-fTeye94_nRaMBSCKdV_CguA3vsxWwWqiCoeYR7Q2P.Y",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1734652667',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/project\/brookings-papers-on-economic-activity\/?__cf_chl_f_tk=EALery1tzGH.FN_d8WtDGQiLw6wWO92PYb9kIcqNt9Q-1734652667-1.0.1.1-fTeye94_nRaMBSCKdV_CguA3vsxWwWqiCoeYR7Q2P.Y",md: "bLp3IlG9Xvn9YP3Cll4d0SMas9SpdI0jlN_9gWRX6uw-1734652667-1.2.1.1-u4356KbioxQ7lRpJjaO19lr_vb_XRlMFM_qOLv7yHavFLHBwedfTrF7ewdwHs_Ta2X8UOE.Ii9ze.yqLcBQf1e8bnR2qoyQJtlBzn1yFvvNEcJlDamJSGMhJqPpZT15mpFA2LJn.h9uz3.DlB03OvaneEvLXdpNggemzT.opbLgFVKMYhC9EkQRWSBmEkLi0k5xX1TCoy_vEtRUbNGYkK.efXUcspiCf8SdD2Bo3Zb8FjD7jRYhkiQ1_ZhBR0wzuWT8A6q3StY4gn2GGCaW._MwM2yTyVThEKwJXE4yqkKKo6qeUErfmmwAsx65xGx3iCUvynlpEnFxUZbL1JUU87hPTCUh3l4GIlwBRZyCbK42cUXDsJRl2wYsae52KcZlH_Yj8qDiI4RT3kZtkF5UQcichlGaGLGuFl51e8T8ct7VaUhs4nWg5axGl7q4RuOY6U4kl1XUvkE_R5ikJZbyp1In9Q2P7xZ3P44e2S3crGqKEM32mSK_t2BtOj0dqfQYkC.YpgpNDoGiHSUVCRz22PN0VcBSqNl9EbtdqJzwZFvRiU8gmb1Po4LscR0_hRRs9J2CqJOeAMIHFjvUFvYWGhcygJ2TOwLpVMB3vMd3I1r4li9nsldS9fPCUTm.POcxv8O7gzb5qWU_wkYsXfdNsCf35BZ.cvB99m9WCdO9oD602gEDjSFrJVkSItx8NwiHzny8Bf8eTkeCQjjLlMureAD7Vcwz02QNIpYnPTo.baUTFyUUtAuhBVeAGz0vCAv.e4q228h0sSVnLyu.xqjIXaJPppPnQlDPUGOS.YG.eLwa4NLgNl9HijLrHrozAb95ebEx2dy004B4ImFx4FpmBbvQdm5rkxf7Ob.OtHIA73Rmq.Y.D6uKOFD5XXtWukcO8PVdrZsPU0AV.FSnLdjb3mb_mHG5bvWOr1h8jTkmAi36_JXeMdlZ7AEx7qNQ6tdI_.JHracOw_YSUtXJCZGuoMFUEhrV19CvJZuGdKtkpXwj_Z0qanJUtYvwX8HKcwdtvlFwnV3tHscb1rdwWVrGMGB5GZF1H4hsnsUtqoaHGe1H2TyqP_S_65bdgZAXyUzhGvCaOahGeePbrkIEdARYDZqVKztgDAkS1R7ZawW0WoU0Soonv2EqH15JBDOa0equRJBJPJkIFXNbMEHwmDp55zvXBQs3d3huvaddBoNPIVpKxY0.GR9LlSsWCRHf0mZ7NySpD2dD7j3EKXjZsKO1QCjtt.9HQwDzKgAXtSSVBdT7ShF9k4Wa3qrcrmRR9LHtJYNjrflBxutf2CE0r3FABWH8JEGiPnpAFYUH3Rt_9mCPIK6tfNfGAIUIsnSfbi8Nz1OEpoOvOFxq3okeToucpwGVPDyO0l4hwBWo.L4b607PFvLMnUAE3bnOhOd2_bjKw9pZW1bhy4y3OmUAHlHSEYDNdR3BoVxP_AZ1hOQ_jRL6FfPJgAx5xpKCl7lh6H6THeGm2Pxqio_RKofkFDMQD8tbcR7M8GaaBJjG0tlScKDeDe4JNC77PC9zlqWBJ2MwDsEdmXfzmIEfjDz1i7TDooHwGmensJ4n0Q9tOFFcfC9KwLArT4UQR_zIZ1RnYTnB.5aDkHPUFp395kBK1yjr1EZgjqERZiiehEmdsUfOI8FO2PamhjqKyciXUS438yVIq2KnzQLfWfBKdETpKzRwvlgMj1o5HaU24rFdXRnSb8eh9lWpF9BGsolfjf2RSK9Jfw1yONoWG5qi7nRWPyBi_YdQLxqwELE007bFgmMi0i8dowxOid0PykDbCDZpbVw_udwtCHPHkUoTAv91sO5xvGrkLLrqNZrEH9spOfoqo33vhtOL._FN9NRHp9FUd9YZ7TAWbTxwXIV_ZnzNoyuxfliGumDcXvvAB91TwfSqEq0NlLOeisCq747ceb8Ae82Tb4VF_ZH_m1y2uER_VGYWfDka2.Ouj2pZowcYOZzcF5SsPUMGERnHGA3nyvNs_aohWFS4UD4tUq7fXhsrlphC_CKnUG.STzROFPfh_nqD8gv.Cmp9aGUap_4IrCp53l8YLO_I7eq.HMVyOizmHmeHdPfW.YrblF_hzf0LIT47k07TF_xV6trtC89ZSKGh36aNVbAQ3U9ie4d2W_Sw0fdyLIxxMqNzin6B0WO_sPr4oMzGXDUb6Bj3TC_ZEjPfwcDBs2J4EMwajR5kRiFmvPG3zDCiY8R1pTCsgZ3E9PdnAJP0npVnHeXag_Gm0egu_Cxg4EZoYZA9Jyrvf.FE1qmKoMeoepHL_s4Q6x50Av9zxRNgNiOoFeUc8T8_gLrIxyNWrqA6MogxJQVlH_Hl.bcbeDSUabNSE8YSLfI4jagKlKnkiwcHfPDqt77PI0Mt5eoeZKMYTUx.jenUFuXhMCcsDnyz_Wyji_4rw1RnL6hBJhA102.JzgaUmizfGSQcUX8zvsVduJzQIjDDTiy2HyuB4Hizl0CwMqQCoihVpHwUaSE1tKa8YdGReykK0GZWG.dyA10lWuTYm3..zbOzn79fdkcKoIaUHb4JlHuBtcV6BQlkw2gqDzjSkP9jS770dknlzZZ2YJbYAofpagF.s3xc5cL_1RFde.GqOWSQZmPDnFAyadgKMUSwGlgxypKezVIEF9m.yadj5xBJU1mkZbWwSJidaU8R5lz8mbMDgcMi8eQdoOMorU1MRiiImCgjymj11lEa25gfifT6baDORQbzdoVed0EOipWX.hHET2cYN0yNE7XrGtdyeScnck_0bVjxBUw1W5cAoRdCh6XTkjwM1Bwrsnoe4nHIVnDxk699MacG3o0sIlX4Y.3rFvOScjliVPsPxm28doQVjQ.X7GG6oLrdRgtIcGq3HshIgioP_rOvW4GlE540IDZ9coVcdw9Te",mdrd: "2er8aLtBM2ENDAPhJNo8VxZHeZnFvbWUa5TZDvrNTgk-1734652667-1.2.1.1-onaOjOMleSk9MKJ9hC04kduZBoENSy_VdPth_ejl9jv2T1CO6Vt5EN0yktaHRtVhPyUxjGtN11APSKh0GSyFb8P9N5ikkadFKQ1GCuQEmqHx5GRvHCHjRUPF29GtB_xzqY0A8OLriTw1hUUrGpW74HYt1s3gb1_d0JfC0sEVYuMKCbTIsdZ4GZGV4sUHpVmRqBOmqdTFkBh.4mBez6pJeUrSSP_sh0rcHEjUzY7THPPGhv9H.zghLHNZ3bsjXEXYhJQoy3ihxYFj4CLtqoLgeMANQ83W9vUZQaJh_2Wxfmq0R3OeJ6me499scv7gUA_cDHxcG6.t5WgEqjLDQKcNN5EaLrj_zuagMBqf7kYNOXF.hE7qKUXttodRp4gJIFdUNpqMeF6RjOsHi1qcVulwwy4r9iDiXGry21lxDuPsE12xB1edrOIhBh8aX_ORZNAXtNvZciDwqF2GftyeHXSqZtg7vAxS0jgP2.6IXrI9LKV5hsAhZr6GpiW2WWlszBT3Pisv9mBZ6yz0YdONPK5UgWlkwcPeNx.GSMwRhqUDcZx1G43qYmQXVrcl.vTcWrijU8vDs8Pi7_gRczeFRpISfkCv8woTKXNCzGgAmxUldf6YzygOkGilB0G3PmtkvfOeRzwR4mxuS.2nS060JX3I9HK24jKUGEZpY8KFvitdvxNsbr3fzElyLDoG5x4GnsldOXoDJUkBDe5DKLMEL5Jt8UwygziaxFUhLm8423Vim.eLdMF0QEr0iw1UbwgN9KCiaQFYFQaTFhiX5tTsU_nfzyrzMenAl3ws2EO9sorn3eSetzdmi80th1VID._o2NPMAEVs5CNsC4e.TpQXzeQRqcrHNl36at7NchxOSpf5FXi6bljZNCqatBxzE5u6FRF.yg4eDPGdvRa2SVOCngoBbCW0gyRtxHEbM8Kr9TpSzsRlxz7zY1ugQvF_DRAd.ocij7OF4hyUBtSIJfUv8BDVdOJosRny0xBDmyyptjUwah8jYTj1BMUsCmwwV83P1c6k_SlLrQv0VIa4R4IJqBHTWQE52nziPj8UCzTPTsG9dJqhWssDppzanjQSa1rmNcVfesIlEbWSWIVzlJ6wn9_78NvPe8EzynilNh_CkB.pAFZgZGqWuMDsYAhfagTKGE0nfJEp7CsecWZSVjLDpLR3D0.GVraQrMdUA9_0FCe8TFKevj2ZadF_yKA9S1eH6fFeRyDMN4D2VNBmBrjXZL8bsB9Kk2noAPR2OnmgW7pfrrckLHUiDhiRVXHaJk.JJr7wZTJugMhZUhwDwh4uDcQJeWdlJlkkTUnQU7h3IVIuV1mlZuAVfuUtQBDa3850NXBUr_Q9Ui7v4uMZZM3CmzYj_93BmabIO3avK.8QmyjrQ1XJnJ5jgbzDQiCtoaJkJAqT6UzFNXkZm960YB9R9._CF9p9kO_wM7Vp8FpV0G2_Nr7ml9RpdxC7.WLC4mLB4UpScLgGvzOs6PaqFQnG.V7.U7V6uuxya3.OYdpDdqPfIq5fWcGvWq8Iu7tPHOJ9DqUD2O4wLi5QRIX5mUpgDvgT7jNMIlY09XncFQ5mov5n638vjnzTFmDE4frFPhs7Ux7iqSJ5iWwBO1tv3qkJgZS3my0.J40YX4nBOFH1E1oJ.7js66CsTK9mhcQi2pHP6GiEGTDZV4.Dzaq536pWvCt.H89LSncv8t7KAhDtsRJqBQBqSmgjKHysgAy1ygrI_zDq3loFQ9xMLN6aKm_U4xV0vGdI5TGWv3ndAvr0PFEFqDt7mtipn8jgBGST3BdwqZZ6BZHTBColLE4eHjJRpunLG7ojZQ84uS_FEjm0DXzo.RLKpS3et9trdIKYth7M0jYMrD4e8uE._XKaYnEvAyVIydKfvgomCLqibUHA6rWd4LrxktBAeJt5kMUM._cW.V6ImWNRMgggTJfbNGmw.T4mP.C1.0.djQGJmw3xzdRowow"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8f4b56450c95f93a';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/project\/brookings-papers-on-economic-activity\/?__cf_chl_rt_tk=EALery1tzGH.FN_d8WtDGQiLw6wWO92PYb9kIcqNt9Q-1734652667-1.0.1.1-fTeye94_nRaMBSCKdV_CguA3vsxWwWqiCoeYR7Q2P.Y" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>