CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "pubs.aeaweb.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '913964ae4a27895f',cH: 'HylR4m_YVb.0aQ2LyigjoW0uQhl_ryb9.V.MCdK1Yg0-1739833223-1.2.1.1-YCpisaN5I658AH1smCKTeFjKcTaEpVeFfSb2vQE9MIu7WlAul6RJNHir0ygJ13uX',cUPMDTk: "\/doi\/10.1257\/app.20130535?__cf_chl_tk=QnKnO3fpVXoqbQPFX6PGi3fepyMOFIVMpaTdYLLUih0-1739833223-1.0.1.1-s38zWuKxZOtUbr2Dzts7WPMMK.X22aefZJ2ORN6K8Ek",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1739833223',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/doi\/10.1257\/app.20130535?__cf_chl_f_tk=QnKnO3fpVXoqbQPFX6PGi3fepyMOFIVMpaTdYLLUih0-1739833223-1.0.1.1-s38zWuKxZOtUbr2Dzts7WPMMK.X22aefZJ2ORN6K8Ek",md: "80jcUx3vJe97PdejPOXQRtUwBuoMqPG5ugk8hL0i1cs-1739833223-1.2.1.1-rvC214mP7BJavkm26BN6RpVMyf4cqj.eOlgF_XfVq32iCOirgthpL1ET1CqLE_N_K2I7Kh9yOqvq4pYhv42hRFrKsSTPWdJzE0CkIoFnlgSLdOXkktOlQLWQkmrfNpp0L2ZiOD8J7ndNoQHn_ob6pvfyrKDbRuvNgj0YYt7T9QAJV0_WSDr9jnhRqCFgr0RnciIg0_syxxfhDn833vjudmhHB1y9aG2HVI2AasAb6OR04XUXqXhVYTNEV8b_uGh4jFZfcyN6MDQ1XrBCa7mv8w55LJcCEaNRvL32j6wYaGkSpnEvWxG5hIo_.2rnaOEBQK6.l74B_44Sn.nHYOM1sqoOfeyw5X41pST6NX0ObEFB29dlTY6UxWYO6jezLN3kGG8QW1pHxcIZZvIVZAjoekQZ0idkznGhnRsWTzd9M8r8UI7dtMUzXzV2tB.TveRsjhR_pIFo8FtVgnyoj3H5Wvd_sKD7hYWzg8ImcNhjxqVBP.KparWleI98zm3BOLXPggDxvoAQ9tlZcjsjxtdEf1r20t96SHNeVAQegnbq_hIfBuMraj0RynPE3_bShpB8_BlDMPnkitlKFmTbDiCCTSC2cDZAoeq0oY5BdOhAkAFf.YdBeGBQ7SPIheQqOULxvnc7_qfOhR4f4UAchF69ZjlwGhhue85FjNJE8aZ.nli5ISeRPA3oCrhGo3rJmGg6P3GAMgeG5lo10OOpekQP3XXE704L0jaxCNmu__9d6cT4ncIJTA0QnnI3NqHwF5F3wK31RL0Itkpx.JbXk385zliHw7aNCCoXHohqkePg.bIglXFVSzJDhEKbhyQ1oOIPEn9h0FnH5hHqnd0_ekMn0dbKmIZME0yWhCKr2IIzhjReB8FHAXrnCZWtzKbQ4aTtIDIFU1bA_kPLIPnwdV1wYIUVuj8mU0z.1sOH0cthz_ZRx6L8WajZWwFslko2yLZVDsX3FCfgYhdpCPjOXKJZ_5WvaE.HmTbdZ9qfaZ9BFdyc58Riqvr9Y1_.w9eZxFG1b2.DhiqKBOKGOcuQTI_jmMcWAieHXU0Qzh.wWmoVuKIRdOVW9WFeGtoBf6yR0R44knKwROSbuFDS7O.tiOw8MPuM1ObfZwH2YY1QOetZNw7MC1TueTcpUiiWsZTX6NNnctqAx4wjJP5yba..lRNLGjyveRGYaOATEIpJbteD0I_IbVLyCdF3HaJDoP4eQDr0w6x9HjGz99LuQcYewls6WOswBe3MrCzND9eipXsgQ9kkH7Il_m77MFSzDVcwlL4eYrQ_o43zrzWJty_MwveL8HGyV__iSApDe97wKajiJEkevPcSEgqGY63AyZyNPU.K88fAL2DRxY8kIgVsLxX8lAw3Ogm.sVJIcASNlfYoQBfI7U4miAHgPC4iOYaN_1GzTdyGfsdEhW1bOrCyQT0lJK6KIIOCOsTb6Ro4qHkQglQZp9MiE46.hnVYSnm_sMPQdrmGg6bU2fzKuk7l_nw0E_oMl_HmQNrzv_2WKj61Rx6EsfBYQCMKumR_EJfHgdtXuJKbBpRN1CBVd4WyvT_UVCN8xDL3GbKVfO4p88AJmpium.dnuaHEhk6rAfxAS8apk8RPt1RtYExRWg40bKPVjzDejWKj521V0O0re_pD22ZM184ToEYvXmDRBfF7JqKFmKkfSIniVWWrzTjZFzbJhfLkiQc3VyOAXk3wLBtAlRlILwQenYCkytfgjXdhcKrNzsiH2NlfyxGKQcarYyRqZvK6k1R1KbrxXluCZhWbY.oQ5QThTrewL9S3c9y.sQKbGSyvWUTPPDD5pmpIi7.O_srFyWJvmXvVsaf52Dv7DG909k2UvK6Gr40eNYpnj5yt2MYzgBrshSvP0oRbETX8CnVjiKBegyivnETjL3cQVUW6Q_uCgOG_N6dDq.ygeXGrgAur0NaFaYM1ljlSxvLslEEUdSl_C9pB3cPohZRTv5eroPm_kWUVGgqlKtMZsnISwa1iWwDD2bKEJuPO5ngimpEIA8hp0Du9KijRRo1k2nX6HlKW4OqOGo0xN6O.sk9UfCDzRcNNadf7O1LzKNg_HfvwZ_cp2zGyB8vg8D67DQVtaR9rp6ET3WsRPFL5j8Gi1ltFrMYnV5ajMVaW5FudnfWzeksJmHNjilHel.JTF4O6mD58XhPDVrRxIuiohRyaFOFo3ciqxJCvAhoCgtF2MzYqiR1u6Kiiu_yWyoZeRtrxH6_QKvcst42l01NWOWbMmEO6TVuT7rvMHLDOI0G_Vy.XCscA7.UlS6U4ZxE0llUnHxnPbBFIPGYT6dRoAQ1KdMrqodBYj3dSqVL4bp983LArh_RdkRXpoKXmgUsX6SKh39Xu4Yw1H5bILQSLK7pbbl6dxdIT4jB80im.tooqPBbM_tl0ZunkkkUfHnIWhOoMvX30mw2vyMc4n4LcbQjUFntmx8PcnL1vgfxLsr2sybXy..TiiDebl1aI0cqnbGkots0DgqXGqsSEk4aY2TmYoikBeVXlV6pMlDP9f4rACUOQJgdlmf9Iuz87NO4E7c0ioBlfG3LJNmAHGLdzGY7a_Splb_HnvqU3DRaZG_xdkA",mdrd: "gMwe8Hwmg1fC.SMt7heWIYguimjIJpr1hfgzc7xvWI4-1739833223-1.2.1.1-rvy7hsHP2y1TjSWfYA1b97_JBVrhrybUwmOmS2HDIj1vBrbIehjpKqPAhLHFnUroApdyKwSVHm_ggd8iv8MIB7MKx4dyIX.AhW4a5z05AES2BqVZ9HjxrFKdK5cGVMmChyK9N.OtAWiQxjwiU0VBbQZ70QkGqXMlO8CH98UrnQrKvoUL28sisR.AEVhEVQGDo0iOKL05HnZF89clVubVQdf8ZySYBCmEHojzC379J8Sp6a7zwdQH_V1bR1VTVvqH3b41o1TAzaiWzCshcPe..BqY7JSpHM_PfOLI_Tv8X47gxr5ImMy2t3vk4vIIk5JjBX52bfhfnfTfH2.rreeoYdbLyZm_FM_6_0XdKWiJ6tSOq0QYPBsh1Mpb1imuan0DReXUnX12sGvuwF0fQ0_81TCa7bnBxkyC2OFiIQX2K0gNijUhDNcs_sU6nQ2UYoA0qfcFZ8etAx7WxsyXnmWEzHtfGUuLTyBY_uu6XQEqGR4UpIOSljeVxB6RJAAXmpaoUYpG38YWbDfVBnw_jyawQWtzBkj6U1F1w3PTuX3AjZYeirACkD_8Piq_hU0yu_gxGxHVodCavgvzrPlsxkLjpUDYjkyLaLThb2yTgIUy_cLtX1.Psg2qUK__29YqA3GSvcpj58querZzzqA10ynnJUdBQx6JNfcx61gKJC.y9SR_HTmuw1141KipfjLUoxwjtY59r9YGHjGmHvZdr68CGOwTi51Ct3RjTbthIK3TdR2wpCdM0yQXi2Beqx266N7Z8cBfGMcqgj71J1dJlY2_OJ0IY_qO0njubYaxBvaRIEZUXG7oO6X.LRHUTUwF_Wft2.mvdWH4F5qwNVevYwfCzej9NwkHD9.ZvgHbxEi2WOevfU8k3X.LB16SPpbPkn8vPkHWelCKtuKNJivjV.1TO2sSq_lM3HtQT.ODCsupY.8EalARr12DWSgGyW81YX0Jybv8_JS697m_HzWkcoGTZgjK5LMXmQJNmDujJZLi.48DKAA5dcC0kJv8ESKpTikbpLFhiHEXc2L1ZGoNkZmqZ_NRuFmGt.ccMHvFoX29fbvvsgq.MqAsONMfwbwyEm8jSIukedgnncd_Ka3fHeIr4SGqiY_pu.8wSj7N_QUNKAFu6CWNxWtF7b9yCrDCo0YpAEGT9Lq2GuCKIsvz_BknMLox_vB.e82R7udEyCeKrRULWh5apEfW6XTOmP5T7tABmTO58Q2qgba28gma11OdgUMcyR8YVUxwwUyhFv0YBmFK3JsYGzdxY.lX0Kbb9O99Xg8YPqG9GEay208cNweJv3NpSlOGYDhLfqRqZqJHuQ3rY0ccrNe2VLxHC08EGlXX_OYkBp9JyZaDXPSemW4Bo8i6FQV8jVgK72mzeLs4xdbPAohhHdiFHJ5oUNtq_S53ZCd.d4csmAEBbkHXkIeLHl_YB.qP.HRJGnd5F3sGzIrd.e1gpYSZhnjfZfanQ1NQ94oBlehxAfsK3XoHGUV5Td.ws6BZEtEwtskoTOWqNMJin.xpi9SztnrkKIyQMipkSnlHt4O46Fus5g1zu83iZhU9PW237RsUZVILUTlG3g9aPmmy_dPuiZRhLeW.IqYiMiQZVXzS7SSJml2vhg25HqDALPoBeWJg.2txTa79fqRMrrHClJGitQGKa185RfoV8A3aE9lAqhF9ey5Dh6NM__T1bjWk2MxsDwd1huns8m5YPy3YhJ8AIz8G62g5aiqNG4GM71vr1GPmdR.lPYbgEWlGTtUPUoaem3eOBV5G7BapYOSTkGX7iCYYdjZ_sSpC7Bh47IzidjrnTiDQjyVE0H8mp0hDBuHygB.7PAUCb0NolLUb1pSg1WBModm9MFB2po2a3uFq34N.CrWrUokH9c4F3V6CRS6wtlwhjMXyui4FOLZYFJOTveiqvHAWmyitttD1KkfsHCeany6PJKAcUrO4LCMg0EP9mx2QJ4ET6bQlBRme8WzQX0gDOJnE.CZr"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=913964ae4a27895f';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/doi\/10.1257\/app.20130535?__cf_chl_rt_tk=QnKnO3fpVXoqbQPFX6PGi3fepyMOFIVMpaTdYLLUih0-1739833223-1.0.1.1-s38zWuKxZOtUbr2Dzts7WPMMK.X22aefZJ2ORN6K8Ek" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>